On June 19, the Yankees led the Blue Jays by five runs. The Yankees were 10 outs away from completing a three-game sweep of the Blue Jays and from extending their current winning streak to 10 straight. But over 1 2/3 innings, the Yankees allowed seven runs and lost. Since that day, they are 30-37.

The Yankees have now been a bad team for more games (67) than they have been a good team (65). They have let a 15 1/2-game lead in the division fall to a five-game lead, and just a four-game lead in the loss column over the Rays. They are on the verge of completing the largest division-lead collapse in the history of Major League Baseball, and at this point, it doesn’t seem like a matter of if, but a matter of when the collapse will be complete.

I knew the Yankees were going to lose to the Rays on Friday night. I knew it the moment the lineup was announced and both Oswald Peraza and Oswaldo Cabrera weren’t in it.

The Yankees botched not calling up Peraza all season long as Isiah Kiner-Falefa cemented himself as the worst everyday player on a supposed contender and arguably the worst starting shortstop in the majors. Then the Yankees botched actually calling him up. They let him start a Triple-A game on Thursday before pulling him for the call-up, risking injury in a move they must have knew they were going to do that day all along since they waited until rosters expanded on September 1 to give Peraza a chance in the majors. Then they botched his major-league debut, not starting him in the most important game and the most important series of the season to date, choosing to give him his first taste of major-league action as a pinch hitter in the bottom of the ninth with two outs and no one on and the Yankees trailing by nine runs after having just sat on the bench for the previous three-plus hours.

As for Cabrera, the energetic 23-year-old has been a breath of fresh air since being called up and the Yankees’ second-best position player after Aaron Judge since his call-up. He was inexplicably sat on Wednesday in Anaheim despite a scheduled day off the following day, and then was held out of the starting lineup on Friday as well.

Prior to Friday’s game when the Yankees’ horrific lineup was posted, Aaron Boone was asked about his decision to not start Peraza, the Yankees’ No. 3 prospect in his first game with the team.

“Probably try and maybe get him in there tomorrow,” Boone said. “But we’re trying to win.”

“Probably … maybe get him in there tomorrow?” What? What is that? Does Boone think he is doing the kid some kind of favor by having him on his team and in his dugout? As if he hasn’t earned this well overdue call-up. And “trying to win?” Yes, that’s Boone insinuating Peraza won’t help the Yankees win.

What Boone really said was: “We’re trying to win, so we are going to play the same players who have prevented us from winning for the last two-and-a-half months.”

Rather than give opportunities to Peraza and Cabrera who are more than deserving of those opportunities, Boone created this lineup for the first game of a three-game series against the Rays — the team closest to the Yankees in the standings who are essentially trying to get Boone fired.

DJ LeMahieu, 1B
Aaron Judge, RF
Andrew Benintendi, LF
Giancarlo Stanton, DH
Jose Trevino, C
Gleyber Torres, 2B
Aaron Hicks, CF
Isiah Kiner-Falefa, SS

Boone iterated that Kiner-Falefa is the team’s starting shortstop, and that he spoke with Kiner-Falefa about the Yankees promoting Peraza, reassuring him his job wasn’t in jeopardy. (Oddly enough, Boone never felt the need to talk to Gary Sanchez when he was being benched for Kyle Higashioka. Kiner-Falefa is a Boone favorite, and Boone favorites always get treated differently.)

“Izzy is such a big part of what we’re doing,” Boone said, “And I expect him to continue to be right in the middle of everything we’re doing.”

Boone’s right. Kiner-Falefa is a big part of what the Yankees are doing: losing. He represents the everything wrong with the 2022 Yankees and how they play, how they are managed and how they are run from top to bottom.

There was Josh Donaldson and his .691 OPS batting fifth. There was Gleyber Torres (who has the lowest OPS of any player in the Major League Baseball over the last month) batting seventh. There was Aaron Hicks, who last had an extra-base hit on July 9 and who was supposed to be a bench player moving forward. There was Kiner-Falefa (who is now second on the team in games played this season, only behind Judge), once again, in the lineup.

In desperate need of a big weekend in Tampa, Boone turned to his favorites, all four of them, rather than ride with the rookies. What did it get him?

With two on and two out in the first inning, Donaldson struck out looking, taking a 91 mph fastball down the middle for strike 3. In the bottom of the first, he misplayed a ground ball into a hit, and in the fourth inning, he made a fielding error and throwing error on back-to-back plays. He finished the game 0-for-4 with two strikeouts, two errors, and what should have been a third error, if not for some homecooking from the official scorer.

Gleyber Torres grounded out weakly to short on the second pitch of his first at-bat, reached on an infield single in his second and then struck out swinging in his last two at-bats.

Hicks struck out swinging in his first two plate appearances, walked in his third and reached on a ground ball single in his fourth.

Kiner-Falefa hit a lazy fly ball on the first pitch he saw in the game, hit a double in his second at-bat and lined out in his third.

Collectively, the players Boone claims will help the team win went 3-for-15 with a double, walk and six strikeouts, as well as two errors in the field.

Trailing 3-0 entering the eighth, the Yankees went down 1-2-3 on 11 pitches and two strikeouts. At that point, the game was over. Even if the Yankees were to keep the score where it was, they would have Torres, Hicks and Kiner-Falefa due up in the ninth. But they weren’t able to keep the score right where it was anyway, thanks to some waving-the-white-flag managing from Boone.

With two on and two out, Greg Weissert foolishly threw away a ball behind the mound that he had no play, scoring two for the Rays, making it a 5-0 game and putting it officially out of reach. Boone then called on Anthony Banda to get the last out of the eighth, and not only could Banda not do that, he couldn’t even throw a strike. It was one of the single-worst pitching performances in Yankees history, including Weissert’s in Oakland, and Jonathan Holder’s 2018 meltdown in Fenway Park. Banda walked three, gave up to singles, hit a batter and walked in two runs, throwing just 10 of 29 pitches for strikes. If you told Banda he would receive $1 billion if he could throw a strike, I don’t think he would be able to, and would instead just half-heartedly toss his shitty changeup into the dirt.

It was both fitting and comical that Banda was pitching in the biggest game of the season to date. It was even more fitting and comical that Marwin Gonzalez was called on to get the last out of the eighth inning, and he did so, needing just three pitches to do it, after Banda couldn’t on 29.

I wish I could say Boone was upset or angry after the game, but he wasn’t. He had his usual who-gives-a-fuck tone to his postgame answers, harping on the fact that there’s always tomorrow as if he were auditioning to be Annie on Broadway. It’s only a day away!

“We’ve set a better standard around here,” the delusional Boone said.

“A better standard?” Under Boone, the Yankees have won one division title, have two ALDS losses, one ALCS loss and a wild-card game loss. They have been eliminated in the postseason twice by the rival Red Sox, have endured the most lopsided home postseason loss in franchise history, and just had the worst month record-wise the organization has had in 31 years. The standard under Boone is losing, and being comfortable with it. These Yankees aren’t meeting the Boone era standard, they are exceeding it with flying colors.

For possibly the first time as Yankees manager, Boone did use the word “embarrassing” to describe his team’s effort. A word he didn’t use when the Yankees were run out of their own stadium in the 2018 ALDS, when they couldn’t get a hit with runners in scoring position in the 2019 ALCS, when they were defeated by the team with the second-lowest payroll in the 2020 ALDS or when their postseason ended four batters into the bottom of the first in the 2021 wild-card game.

“That’s an embarrassing loss,” Boone said. “Hopefully, one of those rock bottom situations.”

Rock bottom is rock bottom. It’s not plural. So Friday couldn’t be “one of those situations.” It’s either rock bottom or it isn’t. But it wasn’t. That loss wasn’t rock bottom. He hasn’t seen rock bottom and the Yankees haven’t experienced rock bottom yet. Rock bottom will be when the 15 1/2-game collapse is complete. Again at this point, it feels like, not if, but when.

Subscribe to the Keefe To The City Podcast.

My book The Next Yankees Era: My Transition from the Core Four to the Baby Bombers is now available as an ebook!

The Yankees lost another series to a bad team. They went to California with three straight wins and left as losers of four of seven against the A’s and Angels.

Here are 10 thoughts on the Yankees.

1. On July 8, when the Yankees held a 15 1/2-game lead in the AL East, I never thought I would be here. Here being scoreboard watching the Rays and Blue Jays games as the calendar turns to September. But the Yankees’ 30-36 since June 19, their 15-24 since the All-Star break and their 10-18 in August has me doing exactly that with five weeks to go in the season.

A week ago, the Yankees were in the middle of what would be a five-game winning streak, momentarily stopping their free fall of more than two months. They were going to California for seven games against the worst team in the AL in the A’s and an Angels team that once again failed to meet expectations, fired its manager midseason and is just counting down the games until their miserable 2022 season ends. The Yankees were supposed to go beat up on the two AL West teams the same way they did earlier in the year when they went 6-0 against this lowly competition. They were going to make up some of the ground they had lost in recent weeks. They instead lost more ground.

2. After winning the first two games in Oakland, the Yankees lost the next two, splitting a four-game series with a team that traded their supposed best pitcher a month ago to the Yankees. The Yankees were one-hit over 11 innings in the third game of the series and scored one run in the final game of the series. Over the final three games of the series, they scored six runs in 29 innings against a team on pace for more than 100 losses.

Things would get better in Anaheim, right? That’s what Aaron Boone said. “We gotta better … We gotta turn the page.” Boone spewed his two patented lines after the debacle in Oakland, continuing to believe there’s always tomorrow up until he’s giving an end-of-the-season press conference while the postseason is still taking place, like he has in every season as Yankees manager. Things didn’t get better in Anaheim. Things got worse.

3. The Yankees lost the first game of the series 4-3 with Frankie Montas on the mound. Montas had allowed two earned runs total in his last four starts against the Angels, but in this one, he allowed four earned runs on eight hits, including three home runs.

Montas has been a bust as a Yankee. In five starts, he has only given them 25 2/3 innings. In those 25 2/3 innings, he has allowed 20 earned runs and 43 baserunners. After each of his starts, Boone has thought he looked “good.”

It was another bad performance from the Yankees’ prized trade deadline acquisition. How did his manager think he pitched?

“I thought he was good,” Boone said. “I thought his stuff was good.”

If “good stuff” has a pitcher giving up three home runs in six innings, I would hate to see what Boone considers to be “bad stuff.”

4. The Yankees finished August at 10-18. It was their worst month since 1991. So add that to Boone’s resume as Yankees manager. He has overseen one division title, one ALCS loss, two ALDS losses, one wild-card game loss, two postseason eliminations to the Red Sox and the most lopsided home postseason loss in franchise history. He was the first Yankees manager to return for a fifth season without winning a championship and now was at the helm for the worst month of Yankees baseball in 31 years. He does it all! Give him a lifetime contract!

5. The Yankees scored seven runs against the Angels in the second game (scoring more than four runs in a game for just the third time in their last 20 games) in a 7-4 win. Would that game be the game for the Yankees to go on another extended successful run? Just like every other failed attempt to go on an extended run since June 19, the Yankees followed it up with a disappointing effort in the series finale.

On Wednesday night, the Yankees staked Gerrit Cole to a two-run lead, and Cole looked like he would be able to preserve that lead for seven or maybe eight, possibly even nine innings to avoid having the division lead fall to just five games in the loss column.

Leading 2-0 entering the bottom of the sixth, Cole retired Max Stassi to begin the inning. He then allowed an infield single on a tough play that Josh Donaldson threw away to allow David Fletcher to go to second with one out. Fortunately, Cole got Mike Trout to swing at the first pitch of his at-bat and hit a routine ground ball to short. Unfortunately, Isiah Kiner-Falefa booted the ground ball. With Shohei Ohtani due up with two on and one out, trailing by two, well, if you didn’t see it, I think you know what happened next.

Two nights after beating the Yankees with a home run, Ohtani launched a 2-0 pitch from Cole to straighaway enter to give the Angels a 3-2 lead. Don’t let Trout or Ohtani beat you. That’s all the Yankees needed to do going into the series, and they decided to pitch to both of them throughout the series, and Ohtani beat them … twice.

6. Kiner-Falefa should have never been the 2022 Yankees’ everyday shortstop. I have spent the last four months writing and saying as much. The Yankees have acted as though they are sacrificing his anemic bat for defense equivalent to Omar Vizquel, except they are getting defense equivalent to Gleyber Torres. The only way to justify Kiner-Falefa being an everyday player on this team would be if he played shortstop like Vizquel. He doesn’t hit enough (since he doesn’t hit at all) to continue to be the starting shortstop for the New York Yankees. If he were to be released today, he wouldn’t start at shortstop for another team in Major League Baseball.

Boone doesn’t see it that way. After the game he said Kiner-Falefa “has been one of the best defenders in the league at shortstop.” There is no defensive metric that suggests that’s true, so it’s just yet another lie from the mouth of the Yankees manager who lies daily.

As Kiner-Falefa continues to be an automatic out at that plate and unable to make the routine play in the field, the Yankees have the No. 5 prospect in all of baseball posting an OPS over .900 in the last three months at Double-A, and the No. 53 prospect in baseball posting a nearly .900 OPS over the last three months at Triple-A. While the Braves and Astros (the two teams that met in the World Series last October), along with teams like the Mets and Orioles continue to dip into their Triple-A and Double-A farm systems, the Yankees continue to stand pat, playing Kiner-Falefa every game.

7. Donaldson too. I have an inordinate amount of time, time I will never get back, writing and talking about the need to bench Donaldson. But because the Yankees owe him $24 million next year, and because once upon a time he was one of the best hitters in the league, he gets endless opportunities to turn his season around. There isn’t enough time to turn his season around. It’s September 1. Even with an Aaron Judge-like September, his overall season will still be a disaster.

The two seem to be a package deal. They came over as a package, and they man the left side of the infield and waste two rosters spots as a package. It’s gotten to the point where if Anthony Volpe or Oswald Peraza isn’t starting at shortstop on Friday night at Tropicana Field, I don’t know how I can root for the Yankees against the Rays. If the actual organization doesn’t care about fielding the best possible roster, why should any fan care whether they win or lose?

8. The Yankees have every ingredient needed for an unspeakable collapse. They have a front office unwilling to make a change. They have a manager who talks and acts as if there is an “x” next to the Yankees’ name in the standings denoting the team’s clinched postseason berth. They change leadoff hitters nightly, changing between DJ LeMahieu, who is playing through a foot injury and has a .349 OPS over the last three weeks, and Andrew Benintendi, who has a .698 OPS as a Yankee. They have a first baseman who has now missed games for a third time in the last month for chronic back issues. Their highest-paid position player has missed more than one-third of the season (again) and has a .776 OPS, which is more than 100 points below his career average. They have two automatic outs at short and third, and at second, a player they tried to move at the deadline and likely plan on moving in the offseason. The only two good position players to feel good about are Judge and Oswaldo Cabrera. The former is the AL MVP and the latter was inexplicably given the night off on Wednesday the day before a scheduled day off. Yes, a day off for an energetic 23-year-old, who was recently called up to the major leagues and probably sits in his uniform all day waiting for first pitch.

9. I used to love when the Yankees played West Coast games. I would look forward to them and stretch myself out for them in the days leading up to them like a reliever transforming into a starter. Now I hate them. Staying up late until the early hours of the following day with a four-month-old and near-two-year-old isn’t conducive to a healthy lifestyle. By the time I got my life back on track from the early-August games in Seattle, the Yankees were headed to California. I have had a headache since the series opener in Oakland last Friday and coupled with the Yankees 3-4 record against the A’s and Angels, and their overall free fall, the consistent headache is the least of my worries.

Last week, I wrote that things could get worse for the Yankees before they got better, and they might not get better this season. The Yankees could collapse themselves out of a first-round bye in the postseason. It’s still unlikely mathematically, but this Yankees team spits in the face of math. Their lack of urgency and general who-gives-a-shit attitude is why they are now playing meaningful games in September rather than sitting back and waiting for the postseason to begin. Their approach of sitting regulars and giving extra rest to their best starters and holding back their best relievers didn’t prevent injuries (yet again) and only helped them to this two-and-a-half-month stretch of under-.500 baseball. The Yankees have been acting like they have had everything clinched since early June and now they are clinging to a five-game lead in the loss column against a team they will play six times in the next 10 games. I thought it was bad enough when they weren’t playing to win the best record in the AL. They aren’t even playing to win the AL East.

10. September was supposed to be about getting healthy and ready for the postseason. Instead, the Yankees will have to play as if it’s already the postseason to avoid playing in the best-of-3 wild-card series.

This weekend represents the biggest series of the season. Something that didn’t seem possible two and even three months ago. Domingo German, Clarke Schmidt and Montas for the three games at the Trop? As we say goodbye to summer, we might be saying goodbye to the Yankees’ 15 1/2-game lead.

Subscribe to the Keefe To The City Podcast.

My book The Next Yankees Era: My Transition from the Core Four to the Baby Bombers is now available as an ebook!

The Yankees momentarily ended their second-half slide with a five-game winning streak, but after losing back-to-back games to the worst team in the American League, the second-half misery is as bad as ever.

Here are 10 thoughts on the Yankees.

1. After the Yankees were able to salvage the final game of their four-game home series against the Blue Jays a week ago and then beat the Mets twice at the Stadium, you know Aaron Boone, Brian Cashman, the entire front office and ownership breathed a sigh of relief. They definitely thought the Yankees were “turning the page” Boone seems to always reference in his postgame press conferences, and that the team was putting their abysmal second-half performance to date behind them. When they opened their four-game series in Oakland with a 13-run outburst, it likely only further reinforced the idea within the organization that the team was back, and scoring 13 runs without hitting a single home run would quiet the critics that the team too desperately relies on the long ball. But over the weekend, the post-June 18 Yankees returned after a five-game hiatus, posting back-to-back losses to the worst team in the American League and the second-worst team in baseball.

2. Not only did the Yankees lose back-to-back games to the A’s on Saturday and Sunday, they recorded one hit in their 11-inning loss on Saturday and scored one run on Sunday. Over the final 22 2/3 innings in the series, the Yankees got five hits, all singles.

After losing the series finale, Boone was asked about the offense’s struggles, and after tipping his hat to another fringe major-league starter he actually referenced the shadows in Oakland because of the West Coast start times as a reason why the offense didn’t show up against a team on pace for 102 losses.

The fact that the word “shadows” came out of Boone’s mouth is despicable because it means that he truly thinks that’s a valid excuse for why the Yankees were embarrassed over the weekend. Are the shadows the reason why the under in Yankees games is 15-3 since August 9? Are the shadows the reason why the Yankees have multiple everyday players with sub-.700 OPS? Did the A’s not have the same shadows covering the home plate area when they batted?

3. Prior to Opening Day, the Yankees tweeted their 2022 slogan:

No moral victories. No excuses. No storylines. No narratives. Talk is cheap.

Remove the four uses of “No” and change “cheap” to “everything” and you have the 2022 Yankees.

4. It’s not like the Yankees were shut down by (now former A’s) Sean Manaea or Chris Bassitt in Oakland. They were shut down by Adam Oller (who entered Saturday with a 6.41 ERA) and Adrian Martinez (who entered Sunday with a 6.08 ERA). Both starters managed to have the best starts of their careers on back-to-back days against a team that’s supposedly vying for a championship.

Yes, the two losses on Saturday and Sunday erased whatever feel-good mirage the Yankees had created over their previous five games. The wins over the Blue Jays (1), Mets (2) and A’s (2) leading into the weekend weren’t a sign the Yankees were getting back to being the pre-June 19 Yankees.

5. Not a single person other than Aaron Judge should receive a first-place AL MVP vote this season. The Yankees hold a rather comfortable AL East lead (though it has been cut in half over the last two months) with five weeks left in the season. With Judge, the Yankees are going to finish with the second-best record in the AL and get a first-round bye in the playoffs. Without him, they are likely on the postseason, wild-card bubble.

From mid-April until mid-June when the Yankees were keeping pace with the 1998 Yankees, I consistently wrote the reason the Yankees were where they were was because of Judge, the starting pitching and the combination of Michael King and Clay Holmes. But since King went down for the year (and likely next year), Holmes became ineffective and got hurt, and the starting pitching regressed, the only constant has been Judge. He is the sole reason the Yankees are where they are, and has been the only consistently productive presence on the team all season.

6. Judge homered on Monday and Tuesday against the Mets and on Friday against the A’s (all Yankees wins). Those were the only home runs hit by the Yankees all week. The last time a Yankee other than Judge homered was last Sunday when Andrew Benintendi hit his first home run as a Yankee. The team that relies on the home run to produce a biggest percentage of its runs than any other team in the majors hit one home run in 38 innings against the A’s and had only one of its players hit home runs in a six-game span. Yeah, the Yankees are fine!

That’s sarcasm, obviously (have to tip my hat to Boone any time I use the word “obviously”). The Yankees aren’t fine. Fare from it. They are now 29-34 since June 19. They are 14-22 since the All-Star break. They are 9-16 in August.

Judge’s historic season combined with the starting pitching and the early-season backend-of-the-bullpen dominance has masked an abundance of issues with the team. The same issues that have existed since Opening Day that the Yankees continue to choose to do nothing about.

7. I have no idea how the Yankees can consider themselves championship caliber if Isiah Kiner-Falefa is starting at shortstop on Monday night in Anaheim and not either Oswald Peraza or Anthony Volpe.

Kiner-Falefa is down to .262/.310/.314 on the season. His .625 OPS is the lowest it’s been all year and there’s an incredibly good chance it dips below .600 by the end of the year if he continues to play. He has two extra-base hits since July 27 and three since July 15. We are almost at the point where he has grounded into as many double plays (13) as he has extra-base hits (18).

Josh Donaldson is equally as bad of a problem. His numbers are nowhere as bad as Kiner-Falefa, but given Donaldson’s salary, career numbers and the fact he continues to bat in the heart of the order based on his career numbers, actually makes him worse than Kiner-Falefa. Donaldson is as washed up as it gets, but because the Yankees are paying $24 million for this season and owe him $24 million next season, his leash is endless. We know it’s endless because he keeps batting fifth with a .694 OPS.

On Sunday, Aaron Hicks started his first in a week, and singled, scored the Yankees’ only run and walked, so you can be sure he will be back in the lineup in Anaheim, as if reaching base twice in one game somehow makes up for his .216/.337/.302 slash line.

8. Because the Yankees won a few games last week with Benintendi hitting leadoff, you can bet your ass the plan for the rest of the season will be to bat him leadoff against righties and DJ LeMahieu against lefties. I hate it. Pick a leadoff and stick with it. And if it’s between those two, give me LeMahieu. But really, give me Judge.

This is the lineup I want to see if the Yankees ever get back to full strength:

Aaron Judge, CF
Matt Carpenter, DH
Giancarlo Stanton, RF
Anthony Rizzo, 1B
DJ LeMahieu, 3B
Andrew Benintendi, LF
Oswald Peraza/Anthony Volpe, SS
Oswaldo Cabrera, 2B
Jose Trevino, C

Yes, that means Gleyber Torres, Josh Donaldson and Isiah Kiner-Falefa (and Harrison Bader if he ever actually plays) on the bench. It means a better Yankees team.

That lineup will never happen.

9. It will never happen because the Yankees aren’t going to call up Peraza (who is hitting .290/.357/.496 in Triple-A since May 25) or Volpe (who is hitting .293/.383/.544 in Double-A since May 28).

Here is how Kiner-Falefa performed at each level of the minors:

Triple-A: .479 OPS
Double-A: .699 OPS
High-A: .700 OPS
Single-A: .617 OPS
Rookie: .705 OPS

(The fact he made the majors is remarkable. Him being an everyday player for the New York Yankees is like he won a contest to do so.)

It will never happen because the Yankees won’t bench Donaldson (who they regrettably traded for and took on his entire salary, but reportedly tried to trade him at the deadline) or Torres (whose offensive career is a lost cause and who the team also reportedly to move at the deadline). And the second Bader is healthy, he is playing every day, whether he’s the outfield version of Kiner-Falefa or not.

10. This was supposed to be an “easy” West Coast trip, against the A’s (who are on pace for 102 losses) and the Angels (who are on pace for 92 losses). Instead, the Yankees are 2-2 on it and now head to Anaheim to see an Angels team that just swept the Blue Jays in Toronto. The same Blue Jays that won three of four against the Yankees in the Bronx a week earlier. After the three games in Anaheim, it’s off to Tampa for three with the Rays.

On June 18, the Yankees had a 15 1/2-game lead in the AL East. That lead is now down to 7 1/2 over the Rays and seven in the loss column. A bad few days in Anaheim and a bad Labor Day Weekend in Tampa, the Yankees could be on the verge of an all-time collapse. I’m sure Boone’s hat is ready to be tipped to Jose Suarez, Mike Mayers and Patrick Sandoval in Anaheim.

Subscribe to the Keefe To The City Podcast.

My book The Next Yankees Era: My Transition from the Core Four to the Baby Bombers is now available as an ebook!