1. The Yankees held an eight-game lead over the Blue Jays on May 28. That lead is now gone. That lead is now a deficit. Because of the head-to-head tiebreaker, the Yankees are in second place in the AL East. They are a wild-card team.
2. It took a lot of losing to get to this point. It took a 13-14 June into an 0-3 July. It took going 6-10 against five teams outside of the playoff picture (Red Sox, Angels, Orioles, Reds and A’s). It took blowing a two-run lead to the Blue Jays on Monday and blowing another two-run lead to them on Tuesday. It took giving up five runs before recording an out on Wednesday and facing an 8-0 hole in the fifth, only to come back and tie the game at 9 to then lose anyway, 11-9.
3. Wednesday’s game was much of the same from the Yankees. Will Warren laid another first-inning egg and the offense took the first four innings off. The offense woke up and made one of their rare appearances just in time for the bullpen to implode. The Yankees wasted an amazing three-week run of starts from their rotation with embarrassing offensive efforts. Now that the starting pitching has regressed, the offense has reappeared, but so have the early-season bullpen meltdowns. Mark Leiter Jr. ruined Monday’s game (with help from the left side of the infield). Luke Weaver ruined Tuesday’s game (with help from his catcher). Devin Williams ruined Wednesday’s game (with help from his catcher).
4. The Yankees are a collection of pieces that don’t fit and it’s by design. After years of being too right-handed heavy, they overcorrected to become too left-handed. They have multiple players without positions, so they have some of those players play out of position. Then for players that do have positions, they play them out of position as well.
Their best second baseman plays third base every game to accommodate an immobile statue who will turn 37 next week because he’s still owed $22 million between this season and next. Their best defensive shortstop sits on the bench every day, but when he does get the rare chance to play, he plays second base or third base to cater to the 24-year-old Golden Boy of the organization — the only player who gets to play as much as Aaron Judge. Their starting left fielder is a center fielder who they have forced to play left field, so that their supposed fourth outfielder (who wasn’t good enough to play over Alex Verdugo last season) can play center field. On Wednesday, their starting catcher was making his fourth career start behind the plate because he’s really only been a first baseman in the majors. Two weeks ago the Yankees weren’t convinced he could start a game at catcher in the majors and now he has started four of the team’s last 14 games there, starting over the actual backup catcher, who the Yankees believed in more than the right-handed-hitting Carlos Narvaez, so they gave away Narvaez to the Red Sox where he is a middle-of-the-order bat with an .800 OPS. Now the Yankees have three left-handed-hitting catchers on the roster. All of these players playing out of position has led to game-changing errors and mistakes throughout the season.
5. When the Yankees lose (which they have nearly every day for the last three weeks), well, “That’s baseball.” When they win, they act as though they will never lose again. They have the swagger of Yankees teams that won without ever having won. This has been going on throughout the Boone era.
They carried themselves like defending champions in 2018 when Judge carried a boom box blasting “New York, New York” while walking out of Fenway Park following a Game 2 win in the ALDS. The Red Sox responded by blasting the Yankees for 16 runs in the worst home postseason loss in franchise history the next game and eliminated them in four games. After winning Game 1 of the 2019 ALCS, they lost four of the next five games to end their season. They thought they could outsmart the Rays with their series-changing opener strategy with Deivi Garcia and J.A. Happ in Game 2 of the 2020 ALDS. After being the odds-on favorite to win the AL in 2021, they finished fifth in the AL, went on the road for the one-game, wild-card game and were laughed off the field in the first inning. After that loss, Boone said, “The league has closed the gap on us,” as if the team was coming off a run of four championships in five seasons.
That level of arrogance continued in 2022 when they were pantsed by the Astros in the ALCS, culminating in Boone using video of the darkest moment in Yankees history as a motivational tactic that resulted in no motivation. It continued in the summer of 2023 when Boone kept saying the team would turn a corner they never turned missed the playoffs despite 40 percent of the league getting into October. Last season, seven years of no accountability and a lack of fundamentals came to a head in the World Series and they were humiliated on the game’s biggest stage.
6. Boone has learned nothing from seven seasons at the helm. He makes the same lineup mistakes, presses the wrong bullpen buttons and lies to the media and fanbase in 2025 as if it’s 2018.
Judge — the captain — has learned nothing with Boone at the helm. Judge was likely one of the driving forces in Joe Girardi being replaced and he has spent the last seven seasons recycling Boone-isms about how “They’ll get ‘em tomorrow” until they run out of tomorrows, and they have always run out of tomorrows during this era.
Young Yankees like Anthony Volpe don’t know what accountability is because they have never seen or needed to experience it. That’s why you get postgame answers like Volpe gave on Monday, when instead of owning up to his two-game changing fielding decisions, he doubled down and said he would do the same thing “every single time.”
New(ish) Yankees like Jazz Chisholm talk shit they can’t back up. Chisholm called the Royals’ Game 2 win in last year’s ALDS “lucky” even though he hit .133 in that series. He hit .182/.250/.309 in the postseason. After salvaging the third game in Cincinnati last week, Chisholm participated in the postgame, on-field interview and said, “I feel like we got a great team and I feel like we’re going to make the World Series again,” even though it was June 25, the Yankees had lost eight of 12 and their lead in the loss column had dropped from seven to one.
On Friday, after beating the second-worst team in the AL, Boone called the Yankees “a team to be reckoned with.” They had lost nine of 14 at the time and have lost three of four since. They are being reckoned with and are being wrecked in the process.
7. Now that they’re out of first place for the first time since April 13, you would think maybe, just maybe they would be humbled by the last four weeks. Not only are they not humbled, they are every bit as cocky and delusional as they have ever been.
“We think we’re really good,” Boone said after Wednesday’s crushing loss.
If the players on the team take on the personality of their manager in Boone then Boone has taken on the personality of his manager in Brian Cashman. It was Cashman who told reporters after the 2023 season in which the team missed the postseason, “I think we’re pretty fucking good.” If Cashman could think a roster that went 82-80 and missed the playoffs is good then of course Boone thinks a team that blew an eight-game division lead in just a month is good.
8. Boone was asked, “Is it jarring when you’ve been in first place for two months and then somebody ties you?”
“No,” Boone quickly answered.
Of course it’s not jarring. This type of thing happens every year under Boone, He’s used to it. Three years ago, the Yankees had a 15 1/2-game lead in the division that got cut by 15 games. You think blowing an eight-game lead is a big deal?
9. Asked if he thinks it’s going to be a tight race all season now, Boone replied, “I hope not.”
It didn’t have to be. You had an eight-game lead over the team that has now passed you. (Spoiler: It’s going to be a tight race.) And it’s not just about winning the division. It’s about winning the division and getting a bye. If you win your division, but finish as the third division winner and end up in a best-of-3 series anyway, who cares.
10. After Tuesday’s loss Boone said, “We gotta play better overall and hopefully get it going tomorrow.”
Surprisingly, hoping for a win didn’t work.
After Wednesday’s loss Boone said, “We’ll come ready to go tomorrow, hopefully Clarke will get us off to a good start.”
That’s the Yankees’ plan to get out of this mess: hoping. Not benching underperformers. Not putting players at their best positions. Not putting the worst hitters at the bottom of the lineup no matter what hand they hit with. Not shoring up the defense. Not playing a full, clean game. Hoping. A team with a $300 payroll and World Series aspirations is hoping to win games.
