1. When the Yankees lost out on Juan Soto to the Mets, they signed signed Max Fried and Paul Goldschmidt and traded for Cody Bellinger. On Sunday, the Soto replacements trio led the Yankees to a rubber game win to win the Yankee Stadium portion of the 2025 Subway Series.
Once again, Fried didn’t have his best stuff, and once again, without it, he only allowed two earned runs over six innings: 6 IP, 3 H, 2 R, 2 ER, 2 BB, 8 K. It was Fried’s 10th start of the season and the Yankees are 9-1 in those starts, having only lost his last start in Seattle 2-1 in extra innings.
“It was intense,” Fried said. “Series that feel like playoff series are always good, especially early in the year. It preps you for the kind of baseball you want to play towards the end.”
Goldschmidt led off in the series finale against the left-handed David Peterson and reached in the first inning on a Mark Vientos error. He came around to score on Bellinger’s two-run double and with the Yankees leading by one run in the eighth, he made it two runs with a crucial two-out RBI single.
That hit kept the inning going for Bellinger to eventually come up and break the game open with a grand slam. Bellinger went 3-for-3 with two walks, the double, the slam and six RBIs.
“I feel like his approach is a little better,” Aaron Judge said of Bellinger. “When he gets what he’s looking for, he’s not missing.”
I would say his approach is more than just “a little better.” Since May 3, Bellinger is hitting .377/.450/1.129 with four doubles, four home runs and 12 RBIs in 13 games. Prior to May 3, Bellinger had hit .190/.263/.340 in the first 28 games of the season.
2. If Soto had signed with the Yankees, Fried would be elsewhere and Bellinger would still be a Cub or something else. It’s likely Goldschmidt is the only one of three that would have still become a Yankee and that’s not a certainty, considering after the Yankees signed Carlos Rodon two years ago they did nothing else to improve the roster and after they traded for Soto last year they did nothing else to improve the roster.
Soto went 1-for-10 at the Stadium with three strikeouts and four walks. He was taunted for the entirety of the series as he will be for the duration of his 15-year contract. He failed to drive in a run over the weekend, came up in big spots several times and did nothing and declined being an in-game interview for ESPN after initially excepting.
3. Soto finally met up with Judge before the series finale in the outfield after the two went all of Friday and Saturday without a greeting. Like Soto, Judge contributed little offensively over the weekend. He had had his worst game of the season on Saturday and was unable to come through in a few big moments like Soto. With all of the players mentioning how the atmosphere over the weekend felt like the postseason, I guess it’s no surprise Judge gave us a postseason performance.
4. The Yankees may have won by six runs and the Soto replacements all did their part in winning a fourth straight series for the Yankees, but it wasn’t as easy the final score indicates. For most of Sunday’s 8-2 win, it felt a little too much like Saturday’s disappointing 3-2 loss in that the Yankees blew an early lead and then failed time and time again to come up with a tie-breaking hit.
5. I’m sorry I wrote something nice about Anthony Volpe last week when I wrote how good he looked at the plate of late. I did provide caution though, writing:
Am I ready to believe he is the player the Yankees promised? No. He’s done this before. He has fooled us all into believing he has figured it out several times in his first two-plus seasons in the league.
If you were on the latest Volpe Has Figured It Out train, it came to a stop on Sunday. Volpe was so bad offensively on Sunday he nearly cost the Yankees the game all by himself. Volpe grounded out in the first to strand Bellinger and struck out in the third to strand Bellinger again. In the fifth, Volpe came up with the gamed tied at 2 and the bases loaded with two outs. Peterson had just walked Bellinger four straight pitches. So what does Volpe do? He swings at a first-pitch curveball at the bottom of the zone and hits a weak ground ball to short to end the inning. If your plan is to attack on the first pitch with the belief you’re going to see a fastball with the bases loaded following a four-pitch walk then you better get that fastball and do damage with it. You better not swing at a bottom-of-the-zone curveball like you’re down 0-2 in the count and hit a 66-mph grounder to leave three on.
6. With an 0-for-3 night and five left on already to his name, Volpe came up in the seventh in the same situation: score tied at 2, bases loaded and two outs. Huascar Brazoban had thrown 21 pitches in the inning and was clearly fatigued when he started Volpe out with three straight balls, none of which were close to the zone. David Cone opined on the broadcast that Volpe shouldn’t just take one strike, but take all three since it was doubtful Brazoban would throw three strikes before another ball.
Volpe had other plans. He took a fastball down the middle for strike 1. Then he swung at ball 4 in on his hands and fouled it away to create a full count. Then he swung at ball 5, which was the same pitch and result as the previous pitch to keep the count full. Then he swung at ball 6 and missed it to strike out, end the inning and leave the bases loaded again.
7. Had Volpe gone to the plate for his plate appearance without his bat, the Yankees would have led 3-2 after Brazoban walked him to score a run and the bases would have remained loaded for the Yankees to potentially add to their lead. Instead, Volpe moved to 0-of-4 on the night with eight left on and the score remained tied at 2.
8. It’s hard to believe you can blow a chance like Volpe got in the fifth and get another chance, but he did in the seventh and blew that one too. It’s hard to believe the Yankees would find a way to win after the missed opportunity like the one in the seventh, but in the eighth, Pete Alonso gave them the help they needed.
Jasson Dominguez worked a leadoff walk against Ryne Stanek to begin the eighth and after DJ LeMahieu struck out, Austin Wells doubled to right field. Dominguez didn’t try to steal with either LeMahieu or Wells at the plate and was never even in motion, and and just like the day before, he was unable to score from first on a late-inning double to right field because of it.
9. The Yankees had second and third with one out and Jorbit Vivas at the plate. The Mets brought the infield in and Vivas would need to hit a ball through the drawn-in infield or a fly ball to score the speedy Dominguez and give the Yankees a lead. Vivas battled Stanek, fouling away 100- and 101-mph fastballs before finally hitting the 11th pitch he saw on the ground to first. The Yankees had the contact play on because that’s what they do under Aaron Boone and the only way for the contact play to work when the ball is hit to a corner infielder is for the infielder to bobble the ball or throw it away. And that’s what Alonso did as his throw sailed over the head of Francisco Alvarez allowing Dominguez to score. A god throw wouldn’t have just beat Dominguez to home, it would have been there waiting for him for a couple of seconds as Dominguez was barely in the picture when the ball was approaching Alvarez. The throwing error gave the Yankees a 3-2 lead, and then Goldschmidt provided his RBI single and Bellinger his blast.
10. The Subway Series is stressful. It’s very much like a postseason series and there’s a heightened sense of concern when the Mets get a baserunner and a heightened sense of importance when the Yankees score a run. I wish the Yankees were about to play the Rockies during the week rather than next weekend after the last three games against the Mets. Instead, the stressfulness of the Subway Series will remain as the Yankees host the Rangers on Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday at the Stadium and will face a renewed Patrick Corbin (3.35 ERA this season after after a 5.62 the over the last five seasons), Jacob deGrom (1.49 ERA over his last six starts) and Nathan Eovaldi (1.61 ERA this season). The Yankees won’t have Fried for the season and will counter with Will Warren, Ryan Yarbrough and Carlos Rodon. The offense that took down the Mets in the eighth inning on Sunday will need to be present this week against the Rangers.
Last modified: May 19, 2025
