1. For the last two seasons I have written a lot of words about Carlos Rodon, nearly all of which have been critical. Those words have been deserved. I don’t need to recite all of Rodon’s shortcomings since signing his six-year deal for which he makes roughly $800,000 per start, but every word I wrote about his lackluster first two seasons with the Yankees was earned.
2. For as bad as Rodon was in his first season and inconsistent in his second with the Yankees, he’s been that good and that consistent this year. Sure, the season is only one-third of the way through and at he could revert to his clean-shaven self, though I don’t see it. It doesn’t mean that I trust Rodon (or will ever, especially in the postseason), it’s that this version of Rodon is different, mainly because he stopped being a two-pitch pitcher.
3. “I just have a good understanding of what I want to do out there,” Rodon said. (Where was that understanding the last two years? I don’t know.)
Rodon has made 11 starts for the Yankees this season and has allowed just 42 hits in 72 2/3 innings. He’s averaging six innings per start and looks like the 2021-2022 version of himself that the Yankees were so eager to give $162 million to.
4. Rodon’s seven shutout innings on Tuesday in Anaheim were nearly for nothing. With a 3-0 lead in the eighth, Jonathan Loaisiga relieved Rodon and pitched a 1-2-3 eighth, but with Luke Weaver down after a recent heavy workload, Devin Williams served as the fill-in closer for the ninth and was every bit as shaky as he was when he was the closer.
Williams gave up a leadoff home run to Yoan Moncada to make it 3-1 and Taylor Ward followed with a single. Williams got Travis d’Arnaud to fly out to center on a ball hit 105 mph with an expected batting average of .900 before Luis Rengifo singled to center, setting up first and third with one out. Jo Adell grounded out to make it 3-2 with the tying run was still on base at first. Williams fell behind Logan O’Hoppe 3-0 and O’Hoppe swung at the 3-0 pitch and popped it up to third in foul territory to end the game.
“At the end of the day, we won,” Williams said, “and that’s all that matters.”
Yes, that’s true, but the inning did nothing to dispel the fear Williams is still broken.
5. The Yankees built their three-run lead with a Ben Rice solo home run in the fourth, an Anthony Volpe RBI single in the sixth and an Oswald Peraza solo homer in the seventh. Runs were going to be tough to come by against a left-handed starter (despite Michael Kay telling everyone still awake and watching how good the Yankees have been against left-handed pitching), especially a lefty like Tyler Anderson. The Yankees only had six hits in the game, but three of them were for extra bases and they drew five walks and caught a massive break when Matthew Lugo misplayed a ball in center.
6. Kay continues to ask the question of what’s going to happen with Rice once Giancarlo Stanton returns, and as of now, there’s no answer. Rice’s bat is worthy of playing every day, but without a position other than first base, it will be even harder than it has been to play him every day. The Yankees’ lineup conundrum continues to be that their best bats all play the same position or have no position and their worst bats are the only options at second base and third base. If Rice were a third baseman, there wouldn’t be a problem. Unfortunately, he’s not. Until Stanton is off of the injured list and available to play in a game, it’s not an issue. And given Stanton’s lengthy injury history and inability to recover without setbacks, it’s a problem not worth worrying about until he’s activated.
7. Jasson Dominguez got the night off against the lefty, but the Yankees are going to face another lefty on Wednesday in Yusei Kikuchi, who always had their numbers as a Blue Jay. Dominguez will be back in the lineup, and I think Trent Grisham will sit since Bellinger has destroyed lefties this season and just had a day off in Colorado.
8. Is this the lineup on Wednesday?
Paul Goldschmidt, 1B
Ben Rice, DH
Aaron Judge, RF
Cody Bellinger, CF
Anthony Volpe, SS
Jasson Dominguez, LF
DJ LeMahieu, 2B
Austin Wells, C
Oswald Peraza, 3B
9. Weaver pitched on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Sunday and Monday, so I think he will be unavailable again on Wednesday (and he should be). Williams may be down also (though no one is sad about that) after throwing 19 pitches on Tuesday. So the “A” arms available will likely be Loaisiga and Mark Leiter Jr. That means there will be some outs in the middle innings needed from Tim Hill, Yerry De los Santos, Brent Headrick and Ian Hamilton. And there will be outs needed in the middle innings because Clarke Schmidt is starting.
10. It would be great if Schmidt could go seven (like Rodon did) and hand the ball off to Leiter Jr. and Loaisiga the way, but Schmidt has just to get an out in the seventh inning this season. I’ll sign up for five strong innings from Schmidt, a big day from the offense and a sweep of the Angels before Thursday’s day off and the Dodgers this weekend.