1. The Yankees continue to do the bare minimum. After going 6-4 on a road trip in which they blew three late leads, the Yankees went 3-3 this past week at home against the crappy Cardinals and the very good Braves. Since Saturday’s Thoughts, the Yankees won a game started by Chris Sale before losing yet another extra-inning game.
Over the last five games, the Yankees scored 12 runs or 2.4 runs per game. What I wrote in Friday’s Thoughts (The Yankees have one way to win at the moment: get an outstanding pitching performance and score two runs. That’s it. A quality start isn’t good enough to give them a chance to win. They need near perfection. They need something like six scoreless innings to have a chance.) remains true. Only once over the last five games would a quality start have been good enough to win. Only twice in the the last 10 games would a quality start have been good enough to win.
2. The Yankees’ ways of scoring runs has become a modified version of the trivia question ‘What are the different ways to reach first base?’ The Yankees only seem to score runs if there is an error, balk, wild pitch, passed ball or a random home run. On Saturday against Sale, they took advantage of a Sale balk and a couple of late solo home runs to win. On Sunday, their only run was a solo home run. It’s hard to hit multi-run home runs when there’s no one on base. I would have liked to see Jacob Misiorowski against this version of the Yankees offense, considering they have made Colin Rea, Andre Pallante, Tyler Mahle and Grant Holmes look like Misiorowski recently. Over the weekend, the Yankees went 12-for-62 with seven walks and 22 strikeouts. But yes, keep on waiting for all of the dead wood in the lineup to “get it going” and “turn the corner.” I’m sure it will happen any day now, 118 games into the season.
3. It’s amazing how Luis Garcia and Heliot Ramos joined the Yankees and were immediately infected by the offense’s inability to do anything. Garcia joined the Yankees as the league leader in slugging, hit a home run in his first game with the team and is 2-for-15 with two singles since. Ramos came over as the third-best hitter in recent years against lefties not named Aaron Judge or Yordan Alvarez, and at 2-for-17 with seven strikeouts as a Yankee, the Yankees could have just kept the prospects they traded for him and kept playing Jasson Dominguez. When these two are your 3-4 hitters, following a 1-2 duo of Trent Grisham and Ben Rice, who are also slumping to no end, you get an offense whose ceiling remains three runs.
4. Grisham was back in the leadoff spot on Sunday and back making an out to lead off the game. Grisham has now started 50 of 65 games as the leadoff hitter with an out. But then in the eighth inning, Grisham did what he always does, which is hit a random solo home run from time to time. Here is what I wrote about Grisham back in May during the Subway Series:
Grisham always seems to do just enough to reset his place atop the order. After a bad week, he’ll hit a ball out or pick up a pair of doubles to maintain his place in the lineup and then suck for the next week and then do something positive, over and over.
Well, that solo home run was his positive impact for the week or maybe two or maybe three. Grisham will likely disappear now for a few series and just when you think, maybe just maybe he will finally be moved down in the order, he will pop another one out, and then the process starts over again.
5. It’s no different for Jazz Chisholm, who provides infrequent positive production. I hate to say it, but I don’t think Chisholm is going to hit 50 home runs this season like he said he would back in February.
“I just can’t help, but get that gut feeling — it’s going to be an amazing year,” Chisholm said at the beginning of spring training.
Chisholm has never made a proclamation that has come true. He said the 2024 Yankees would win the World Series. They did not. During the pennant-winning celebration in Cleveland, he told the Yankees to “pay Juan Soto.” They did not. Last year, he said the Yankees would win the division. They did not. He also said the Yankees would win the World Series. They did not. This year he said he would hit 50 home runs and steal 50 bases. He needs to hit 33 home runs in 44 games. He also said his teammates told him he’s “the greatest player in the world.” Here I was thinking Shohei Ohtani was the greatest player in the world when the actual greatest player in the world has been right in front of me all along with his .216 batting average, .295 on-base percentage and .690 OPS as a hitter who is 8 percent worse than league average. Chisholm isn’t even an average hitter, let alone THE GREATEST PLAYER IN THE WORLD.
Chisholm sat against Sale and went 2-for-15 with six strikeouts in the other five games against the Cardinals and Braves, contributing one of the worst throwing errors you’ll ever see on Sunday.
6. It wasn’t all bad. Everything about George Lombard Jr.’s game continues to mirror Derek Jeter and Spencer Jones seems to slowly be figuring out major-league pitching. But that’s where the good ends. Grisham and Rice continue to struggle, Garcia and Ramos are lost, Chisholm’s season is unsalvageable, Ryan McMahon is unplayable and Austin Wells is an atrocity. When Judge comes back, the Yankees need 2022-25 Judge. When Cody Bellinger comes back, the Yankees need 2025 Bellinger. If Giancarlo Stanton comes back, the Yankees need 2017 Stanton.
7. The Yankees continue to give injury updates on Stanton like he’s recovering from a life-threatening event. There are people who suffer traumatic brain injuries who learn to walk again faster than Stanton heals from a calf injury.
On Saturday, Boone said Stanton has “started the introduction to some bases.” What does that mean? “Giancarlo, meet first base. First base, meet Giancarlo.” Why do the Yankees try to sound so smart and bolster words and phrases that don’t need bolstering. Brian Cashman is the worst at it. It’s like the Yankees are using a thesaurus in every press conference too. Just talk normal. “He has started to run the bases.”
Boone also said, “He’ll be in there when the time’s right.”
The Yankees are petrified to give injury return timetables. They keep Judge injury information sealed like it’s plans for a military attack. They have been so bad and so wrong at diagnosing and treating injuries dating back to Judge’s wrist injury nine years ago that now they have decided to just share nothing. And then when Judge gets asked if he’s coming back, he acts surprised that would even be a question. Well, considering you haven’t played in more than two months, it’s a fair question. It will be absurd if Judge returns with what was deemed to be a potential season-ending injury before Stanton returns from a calf injury the Yankees initially said may not require an injured list stint.
8. On Sunday, Cam Schlittler pitched seven innings, allowed one run on a solo home run and struck out 11 and the Yankees lost. Schlittler is the favorite to win the AL Cy Young, leads the league in ERA, starts and innings pitched, and yet, the Yankees are only 15-10 in his starts.
These are Schlittler starts the Yankees have lost.
6 IP, 0 ER
6 IP, 2 ER
5 IP, 0 ER
6.1 IP, 1 ER
7 IP, 1 ER
There’s the division race summed up.
9. The Rays have 45 games remaining. If they go 22-23, they will finish at 93-69. The Yankees need to go 27-17 to finish with 93 wins. If the Rays win one of the four remaining games against the Yankees, they win the division tiebreaker, and because of that the Yankees would have to finish with one more win than the Rays. So if the Rays go 22-23, the Yankees have to go 28-16. A team with a .607 winning percentage playing under .500 the rest of the season is just as unlikely as a team with a .559 winning percentage playing .667 baseball for the rest of the season. Barring an unforeseen Rays collapse and Yankees surge, the division is over.
If you think the Yankees can win the division, then you must think the Yankees can miss the playoffs because the Yankees are six games back in the loss column from the Rays and seven games up in the loss column on a playoff spot. I’m not one of those people since I don’t think the Yankees can win the division, but know they won’t miss the playoffs. What does that mean? That means back to the best-of-3 Wild Card round for a second straight season. That means playing the Red Sox in a best-of-3. The only thing on the table now is if those three games will be at Yankee Stadium or Fenway Park. Given how this team has handled playing at Fenway Park this year and last, a Wild Card series there means elimination.
10. The Rays and Red Sox seem to do what the Yankees can’t. The Yankees couldn’t beat the Dodgers and struggled with the White Sox. The Red Sox swept both teams. The Rays just swept the Mariners in Seattle. The Mariners show up in the Bronx on Tuesday. Let’s see if the Yankees can take care of business like the Rays did and beat a fraudulent Mariners team that is seven games under .500. Beat the Mariners like the Rays did and finally get some help from whomever is playing the Rays and Red Sox, since neither of those teams seems to lose and neither rarely lose two games in a row.