fbpx

Blogs

BlogsYankeesYankees Thoughts

Yankees Thoughts: Division Race About Done

The Yankees continue to lose ground on the Rays and barely hold off the Red Sox. Here are 10 thoughts on the Yankees.

1. The Yankees continue to do the bare minimum. After going 6-4 on a road trip in which they blew three late leads, the Yankees went 3-3 this past week at home against the crappy Cardinals and the very good Braves. Since Saturday’s Thoughts, the Yankees won a game started by Chris Sale before losing yet another extra-inning game.

Over the last five games, the Yankees scored 12 runs or 2.4 runs per game. What I wrote in Friday’s Thoughts (The Yankees have one way to win at the moment: get an outstanding pitching performance and score two runs. That’s it. A quality start isn’t good enough to give them a chance to win. They need near perfection. They need something like six scoreless innings to have a chance.) remains true. Only once over the last five games would a quality start have been good enough to win. Only twice in the the last 10 games would a quality start have been good enough to win.

2. The Yankees’ ways of scoring runs has become a modified version of the trivia question ‘What are the different ways to reach first base?’ The Yankees only seem to score runs if there is an error, balk, wild pitch, passed ball or a random home run. On Saturday against Sale, they took advantage of a Sale balk and a couple of late solo home runs to win. On Sunday, their only run was a solo home run. It’s hard to hit multi-run home runs when there’s no one on base. I would have liked to see Jacob Misiorowski against this version of the Yankees offense, considering they have made Colin Rea, Andre Pallante, Tyler Mahle and Grant Holmes look like Misiorowski recently. Over the weekend, the Yankees went 12-for-62 with seven walks and 22 strikeouts. But yes, keep on waiting for all of the dead wood in the lineup to “get it going” and “turn the corner.” I’m sure it will happen any day now, 118 games into the season.

3. It’s amazing how Luis Garcia and Heliot Ramos joined the Yankees and were immediately infected by the offense’s inability to do anything. Garcia joined the Yankees as the league leader in slugging, hit a home run in his first game with the team and is 2-for-15 with two singles since. Ramos came over as the third-best hitter in recent years against lefties not named Aaron Judge or Yordan Alvarez, and at 2-for-17 with seven strikeouts as a Yankee, the Yankees could have just kept the prospects they traded for him and kept playing Jasson Dominguez. When these two are your 3-4 hitters, following a 1-2 duo of Trent Grisham and Ben Rice, who are also slumping to no end, you get an offense whose ceiling remains three runs.

4. Grisham was back in the leadoff spot on Sunday and back making an out to lead off the game. Grisham has now started 50 of 65 games as the leadoff hitter with an out. But then in the eighth inning, Grisham did what he always does, which is hit a random solo home run from time to time. Here is what I wrote about Grisham back in May during the Subway Series:

Grisham always seems to do just enough to reset his place atop the order. After a bad week, he’ll hit a ball out or pick up a pair of doubles to maintain his place in the lineup and then suck for the next week and then do something positive, over and over.

Well, that solo home run was his positive impact for the week or maybe two or maybe three. Grisham will likely disappear now for a few series and just when you think, maybe just maybe he will finally be moved down in the order, he will pop another one out, and then the process starts over again.

5. It’s no different for Jazz Chisholm, who provides infrequent positive production. I hate to say it, but I don’t think Chisholm is going to hit 50 home runs this season like he said he would back in February.

“I just can’t help, but get that gut feeling — it’s going to be an amazing year,” Chisholm said at the beginning of spring training.

Chisholm has never made a proclamation that has come true. He said the 2024 Yankees would win the World Series. They did not. During the pennant-winning celebration in Cleveland, he told the Yankees to “pay Juan Soto.” They did not. Last year, he said the Yankees would win the division. They did not. He also said the Yankees would win the World Series. They did not. This year he said he would hit 50 home runs and steal 50 bases. He needs to hit 33 home runs in 44 games. He also said his teammates told him he’s “the greatest player in the world.” Here I was thinking Shohei Ohtani was the greatest player in the world when the actual greatest player in the world has been right in front of me all along with his .216 batting average, .295 on-base percentage and .690 OPS as a hitter who is 8 percent worse than league average. Chisholm isn’t even an average hitter, let alone THE GREATEST PLAYER IN THE WORLD.

Chisholm sat against Sale and went 2-for-15 with six strikeouts in the other five games against the Cardinals and Braves, contributing one of the worst throwing errors you’ll ever see on Sunday.

6. It wasn’t all bad. Everything about George Lombard Jr.’s game continues to mirror Derek Jeter and Spencer Jones seems to slowly be figuring out major-league pitching. But that’s where the good ends. Grisham and Rice continue to struggle, Garcia and Ramos are lost, Chisholm’s season is unsalvageable, Ryan McMahon is unplayable and Austin Wells is an atrocity. When Judge comes back, the Yankees need 2022-25 Judge. When Cody Bellinger comes back, the Yankees need 2025 Bellinger. If Giancarlo Stanton comes back, the Yankees need 2017 Stanton.

7. The Yankees continue to give injury updates on Stanton like he’s recovering from a life-threatening event. There are people who suffer traumatic brain injuries who learn to walk again faster than Stanton heals from a calf injury.

On Saturday, Boone said Stanton has “started the introduction to some bases.” What does that mean? “Giancarlo, meet first base. First base, meet Giancarlo.” Why do the Yankees try to sound so smart and bolster words and phrases that don’t need bolstering. Brian Cashman is the worst at it. It’s like the Yankees are using a thesaurus in every press conference too. Just talk normal. “He has started to run the bases.”

Boone also said, “He’ll be in there when the time’s right.”

The Yankees are petrified to give injury return timetables. They keep Judge injury information sealed like it’s plans for a military attack. They have been so bad and so wrong at diagnosing and treating injuries dating back to Judge’s wrist injury nine years ago that now they have decided to just share nothing. And then when Judge gets asked if he’s coming back, he acts surprised that would even be a question. Well, considering you haven’t played in more than two months, it’s a fair question. It will be absurd if Judge returns with what was deemed to be a potential season-ending injury before Stanton returns from a calf injury the Yankees initially said may not require an injured list stint.

8. On Sunday, Cam Schlittler pitched seven innings, allowed one run on a solo home run and struck out 11 and the Yankees lost. Schlittler is the favorite to win the AL Cy Young, leads the league in ERA, starts and innings pitched, and yet, the Yankees are only 15-10 in his starts.

These are Schlittler starts the Yankees have lost.

6 IP, 0 ER
6 IP, 2 ER
5 IP, 0 ER
6.1 IP, 1 ER
7 IP, 1 ER

There’s the division race summed up.

9. The Rays have 45 games remaining. If they go 22-23, they will finish at 93-69. The Yankees need to go 27-17 to finish with 93 wins. If the Rays win one of the four remaining games against the Yankees, they win the division tiebreaker, and because of that the Yankees would have to finish with one more win than the Rays. So if the Rays go 22-23, the Yankees have to go 28-16. A team with a .607 winning percentage playing under .500 the rest of the season is just as unlikely as a team with a .559 winning percentage playing .667 baseball for the rest of the season. Barring an unforeseen Rays collapse and Yankees surge, the division is over.

If you think the Yankees can win the division, then you must think the Yankees can miss the playoffs because the Yankees are six games back in the loss column from the Rays and seven games up in the loss column on a playoff spot. I’m not one of those people since I don’t think the Yankees can win the division, but know they won’t miss the playoffs. What does that mean? That means back to the best-of-3 Wild Card round for a second straight season. That means playing the Red Sox in a best-of-3. The only thing on the table now is if those three games will be at Yankee Stadium or Fenway Park. Given how this team has handled playing at Fenway Park this year and last, a Wild Card series there means elimination.

10. The Rays and Red Sox seem to do what the Yankees can’t. The Yankees couldn’t beat the Dodgers and struggled with the White Sox. The Red Sox swept both teams. The Rays just swept the Mariners in Seattle. The Mariners show up in the Bronx on Tuesday. Let’s see if the Yankees can take care of business like the Rays did and beat a fraudulent Mariners team that is seven games under .500. Beat the Mariners like the Rays did and finally get some help from whomever is playing the Rays and Red Sox, since neither of those teams seems to lose and neither rarely lose two games in a row.

Read More

BlogsYankeesYankees Thoughts

Yankees Thoughts: Biggest Win of Season

The Yankees pulled off an improbable comeback for much-needed win. Here are 10 thoughts on the Yankees.

1. For most of Friday’s game against the Braves, it felt like an inevitable loss. The Yankees once again couldn’t score and could barely “muster” (an Aaron Boone buzzword) any offense. It felt like only a matter of time until the Braves broke through with a home run and they eventually did in the eighth and again in the ninth. Trailing 2-0, when Raisel Iglesias struck out Spencer Jones to begin the ninth, another Yankees loss was on its way.

Not just any loss either. With the Red Sox having won already, a Yankees loss would mean the Red Sox would pass the Yankees in the standings, a feat that seemed impossible when they trailed by 15 games at the end of June. Not only that, but the Rays were working on closing out the Mariners in the ninth in Seattle. The Yankees were going to fall farther behind the Rays, get passed by the Red Sox and finish the night in third place in the AL East.

2. George Lombard Jr. was able to beat out a slow roller in the infield that Iglesias picked up and launched well past first base, allowing Lombard Jr. to move to third. The tying run was on base with two cracks at potentially tying the game, the only problem was that the two cracks belonged to Ryan McMahon and Austin Wells.

Having yet to strike out in the game, McMahon made sure to do so in the ninth for the second out of the inning, leaving the final out of the game in the hands of Wells — the worst offensive player in all of baseball. Somehow, Wells managed to double to right field to score Lombard Jr. and extend the game. The only problem was that the game was being extended for Amed Rosario.

The improbability of the inning continued when Rosario worked an eight-pitch walk against Iglesias. Now the Yankees really had something with Ben Rice coming to the plate. Rice came through with the biggest hit of the season to date, drilling the ball off the base of the wall in right field to score Wells and tie the game. Because nothing has been going the Yankees’ way the past two months, the ball couldn’t have gone over the wall to end the game or bounced away from Ronald Acuna to end the game. Instead, the ball stayed in and Acuna played it perfectly to hold Rosario at third, and eventually the game moved to extra innings.

3. The Yankees are the worst road extra-inning team since the implementation of the automatic runner, but they’re also the best home team during the same time. David Bednar pitched around the automatic runner in the 10th to set up a scenario in which the Yankees could walk off the Braves without recording a hit.

Easier said than done for the clown show that is the Yankees when it comes to baseball fundamentals. With Luis Garcia serving as the automatic runner, Jose Caballero stepped up to the plate with a myriad of options available to him to handle his at-bat. Caballero attempted to bunt the first pitch of the at-bat in what was one of the worst bunt attempts anyone has ever seen. Behind 0-1 in the count, Caballero then decided to swing away at the next pitch, a pitch that was at least a foot off the plate and he swung through it wildly to push the count to 0-2. Prior to the third pitch of the bat, Caballero showed bunt, but it was obviously only going to be for show to try to throw off Braves relier Tyler Kinley. Or not. Caballero did indeed try to bunt with two strikes and fouled the pitch away for an out. With the strikeout on a foul bunt, given the process of the at-bat, the situation and the magnitude of the game, Caballero officially clinched worst plate appearance of the season for the Yankees. It won’t be topped. It can’t be topped.

4. The Braves then did the Yankees a favor by walking Jones to put runners on first and second with one out. No, Jones’ run didn’t mean anything other than to set up a potentially double play and let Kinley face the right-handed rookie Lombard Jr. But if Kinley was going to strike anyone out in the inning, it was going to be Jones, and the Braves foolishly put him on. Lombard Jr. followed with a walk to load the bases and McMahon followed with a walk-off sacrifice fly for a 3-2 win.

5. Rice’s game-tying hit was the biggest moment of the game, until Luis Garcia made an over-the-shoulder-catch in right field with his back to the infield to keep the game tied at 2 in the 10th. Without that play, the Braves take a lead in extra innings and who knows how the bottom of the inning plays out. Actually, I think we all know how it plays out if the Yankees fall behind.

6. “It’s good to come out on top,” McMahon said. “We’ve got to get going a little more. It’s not from a lack of work or effort.”

No, it’s not from a lack of work or effort. It’s from a lack of talent. The Yankees have a lack of offensive talent, but they knew that last season and ran it back with the same offense this season. The below-league-average hitters like McMahon (and Wells and Caballero) are living up to their career track records. Goldschmidt was always going to fade as the season wore on, just like he did last year. Grisham was never going to replicate his 2025 season, and Chisholm being the head case he is, was always going to crumble under the pressure of being an impending free agent, just like he has crumbled in his two postseasons as a Yankee. Every offensive problem the Yankees have isn’t a surprise. It was to be expected. Add in injuries and you get the kind of disgraceful offensive performances the team provides on a daily basis.

7. It was another hitless game for leadoff-hitter-no-matter-what Trent Grisham. Grisham is down to 6-for-55 with nine walks leading off a game. I don’t see a need for a lineup change. Having a leadoff hitter who has started 40 of 55 games with an out is exactly what you want.

Rice was only 1-for-5 with three strikeouts, but the one was enormous. Jazz Chisholm went 0-for-3 with two strikeouts before he was pulled for a pinch hitter and then showed up back in the dugout in a T-shirt, as did Grisham. Paul O’Neill was quick to call them out for it. It wouldn’t surprise me if O’Neill is suddenly not on the broadcast this weekend. When Michael Kay said he had people in the Yankees tell him Anthony Volpe refused to play second base in the minors back in May, Kay did an about-face a day later and said it was not true. How dare O’Neill question how Boone manages his team, clubhouse and dugout. If Chisholm wants to pout after being removed from a game and wear a T-shirt in the dugout, so be it. When you’re nine percent worse than league average, you can do whatever you want: suck on lollipops in the field or in the batter’s box, make unhinged and emotional challenges on called strikes, get ejected from games, get tagged up on infield pop-ups, say your teammates told you you’re the greatest player in the world. Do whatever you want!

8. Fernando Cruz and Tim Hill both gave up solo home runs in the game as both have fallen far in terms of trustworthiness in recent weeks. Cruz has allowed 16 baserunners and three home runs in his last nine innings over the last three weeks. Hill has allowed six home runs and has a 5.84 ERA over the last month (12 1/3 innings).

Here is my current order of trust in the bullpen with gaps in between:

David Bednar

Brent Headrick



Paul Blackburn





Fernando Cruz

Tim Hill (much higher on the list if he’s entering with two outs in an inning and a lefty up)



Ryan Yarbrough

That’s not great for a team that didn’t trade for a single reliever at the deadline.

9. Max Fried was really good (6.1 IP, 3 H, 0 R, 0 ER, 2 BB, 7 K) because Max Fried is really good. I expect greatness out of him every time he takes the ball. And for the most part, as a Yankee, he has delivered. (Outside of the biggest start of his Yankees career in Game 2 of the ALDS.)

10. Not allowing the Red Sox to officially pass the Yankees in the standings is important. There’s something to be said for the Red Sox going 32-5 in their last 37 games only to tie the Yankees in the loss column. All of that work hasn’t even gotten them past the Yankees. Maybe that happens on Saturday. The Red Sox are paying the embarrassing Athletics, while the Yankees are facing Chris Sale. But at least there’s still the possibility now that it doesn’t happen and never happens.

If the Red Sox do end up passing the Yankees, I think the Yankees won’t recover in the standings and will end up as the second wild card. That can’t happen. It’s Gerrit Cole’s job to make sure it doesn’t happen on Saturday. He’s going to need some help from an offense that hasn’t been able to hit Colin Rea or Andre Pallante or Tyler Mahle of late, so I don’t know how they plan on scoring against the future Hall of Famer in Sale ,who is experiencing the highest average fastball velocity of his career at age 37.

Read More

BlogsYankeesYankees Thoughts

Yankees Thoughts: A Third-Place Team?

The Yankees lost a home series to the under-.500 Cardinals. Here are 10 thoughts on the Yankees.

1. The Yankees scored one run on Wednesday and lost 3-1, losing a three-game home series to the under-.500, going nowhere Cardinals. The offense turned in its latest pathetic effort, going 4-for-30 with 10 strikeouts against five different pitchers, and Will Warren failed to build on his last start against the Cubs, allowing eight baserunners and three earned runs in 5 1/3 innings.

2. Trent Grisham put together his latest 0-for at the plate, going 0-for-5 with a strikeout. Offering Grisham the $22 million qualifying offer was a horrible decision in real time. This isn’t second-guessing after 379 miserable plate appearances for someone hitting eight percent worse than league average.

These are Grisham’s OPS+ by season since becoming a full-time player in 2021:

2021: 106
2022: 81
2023: 84
2024 (only a part-time player): 91
2025: 123

Which of those numbers is unlike the others? Last season, of course, when Grisham hit 34 home runs, 17 more than he had hit in any other season. Sure enough, his OPS+ is down to 92 this season and he has 12 home runs. He’s hitting the ball out once every 32 plate appearances. Last season, it was once every 17. He’s hitting .211/.310/.379, and yet, he continues to lead off for the Yankees. He’s 6-for-54 with a .111/.238/.204 slash line as the first hitter of the game. He has a .588 OPS when he leads off any inning. How is it that after 115 games of this he’s still batting first? And the answer isn’t because Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton and Cody Bellinger are hurt because none of them bats first. It’s unacceptable and irresponsible that Grisham is still leading off and if he’s doing so again on Friday night in the series opener against the Braves, I may openly root against the Yankees. If they don’t care to provide the best possible lineup then why should I care if they win?

3. Ben Rice went hitless, but did provide three walks. Rice has homered once in the last two weeks, and when he isn’t hitting the ball over the wall, he’s not doing much else. He’s 6-for-50 with 19 strikeouts and a .474 OPS over the last two weeks.

Luis Garcia also went hitless as did Spencer Jones. The Yankees sent Jasson Dominguez down in favor of Jones, and with Judge and Bellinger out, Jones is getting everyday playing time and not doing much with it. His last hit came last Saturday at Wrigley Field.

Jazz Chisholm and Ryan McMahon also went hitless, but I think that’s a given from those two at this point. They did draw walks, but put either of those two up in a big spot with runners on and the chance to tie or take a lead in the game, and they will fail, just like they did on Wednesday.

4. It would seem to be a problem that George Lombard Jr., who has two days of being a major leaguer to his name, provides the most competitive plate appearances on the team. Lombard Jr. had a seven-pitch groundout and singled after falling behind 0-2 before striking out in his final two at-bats. Not only is it a problem that Lombard Jr. provides the best quality plate appearances, but it’s also a problem that the team needs him to be much more than a recently-called-up rookie because all of the veterans on the team suck.

5. No one sucks more than Austin Wells. The Yankees’ failure to get another catcher at the trade deadline is deplorable. They knew Wells and J.C. Escarra weren’t a worthy tandem last year then ran it back with them this year, eventually admitting Escarra can’t hit major-league pitching (despite Aaron Boone saying he would start on most teams in the majors) and replacing him with Ali Sanchez, who also can’t hit. The Yankees would be better off taking an automatic out at the catcher position, or at least having their catchers not go to the plate with a bat. The first option prevents them from hitting into rally-ending double plays, which is a Wells staple, and the second option allows them to potentially be walked or hit by a pitch. Wells should be in Triple-A with his best friend Anthony Volpe and he should be (and should have already been) removed from the future plans for the team like his best friend.

6. We’re at the point where it’s going to be hard to win the division unless the Rays collapse. The Rays could play .500 baseball from here on out and they would finish with 92 wins. For the Yankees to get to 92 wins, they have to go 28-19. There’s nothing to suggest the Rays are going to play .500 baseball for the remaining 30 percent of the season. And similarly, there’s nothing to suggest the Yankees are going play .596 baseball.

Sure, the Yankees still have four-game series left with the Rays and Red Sox, but does anyone think the Yankees will do anything more than split both of those series at best? The Rays and Red Sox also have a three-game series left against each other, so the Yankees will lose ground on one team no matter what with any loss during those three games. It’s getting late early for the Yankees.

7. Not in terms of making the playoffs. That’s a given since the AL is a joke and the final wild card currently belongs to the under-.500 Rangers, and it’s possible an under-.500 team will reach the postseason. It’s getting late early in terms of having any advantage in the postseason. The first-round bye and being able to set your rotation and have home-field advantage in the ALDS is unlikely (FanGraphs gives the Yankees a 20 percent chance to win the division). Having home-field advantage for all three games of the best-of-3 Wild Card Series is also fading. The Yankees had a 15-game lead in the loss column over the Red Sox at the end of June. They are now tied in the loss column.

8. The Red Sox are on a seven-game winning streak and are 31-5 in their last 36 games. Guess who started the 31-5 run for them? Your 2026 Yankees, when they got swept in four games at Fenway Park to end June. The Yankees scored nine runs in those four games and one of the nine was an automatic runner, so they scored eight runs in four games in the most hitter-friendly environment in the world. The Red Sox’ next six opponents are the Athletics, Blue Jays, Pirates, Diamondbacks, Giants and Marlins. The only potentially postseason team in the group is the Diamondbacks, who currently hold the third-and-final wild-card berth in the NL. That’s 19 games against teams that are .500 or worse. Teams that are going nowhere, have little to play for and are counting down the days until the offseason.

What the Red Sox are doing is the actual Impossible Dream season. Forget 1967. Winning 31 of 36 with the roster they have is truly absurd. They were left for dead when the Yankees arrived at Fenway to close out June, but then the defense fell apart behind Schlittler as Amed Rosario gave the Red Sox season-saving CPR and they haven’t looked back. Willson Contreras is having the best season of his career at age 34, Caleb Durbin is batting fucking cleanup and Masataka Yoshida is hitting like Hideki Matsui. Everything they are doing defies logic, math, physics, you name it.

9. Prior to Wednesday’s loss I wrote that the offense’s ceiling for the game was likely three runs and they scored once. Three runs for this team feels like 13. In reverse chronological order, they have scored 1, 2, 7, 2, 2, 2, 1, 5 and 3 runs dating back to July 28. The 7 came in the game in a game they lost after overcoming a six-run deficit. The 5 came in an extra-inning game, in which one run was an automatic runner — a game in which they had Cam Schlittler on the mound in the seventh inning with a four-run lead and lost. The Yankees have one way to win at the moment: get an outstanding pitching performance and score two runs. That’s it. A quality start isn’t good enough to give them a chance to win. They need near perfection. They need something like six scoreless innings to have a chance.

10. That’s not a recipe for success in Major League Baseball. It may work from time to time against the White Sox or Cardinals, but it’s not going to work against the Braves who arrive in the Bronx this weekend riding an eight-game winning streak and are 25 games over .500. While the Yankees are battling the Braves, the Rays will be playing the fraudulent Mariners and the Red Sox will be playing the second-worst AL team in the Athletics. The Yankees will very likely be in third place in the AL East by this weekend.

Read More

BlogsYankeesYankees Thoughts

Yankees Thoughts: The George Lombard Jr. Game

The franchise shortstop has arrived. Here are 10 thoughts on the Yankees.

1. Cam Schlittler’s performance in Game 3 of the Wild Card Series against the Red Sox last October. That’s the last time I felt as good watching a Yankees game as I did on Tuesday night for George Lombard Jr.’s debut. It was so much more than just another game or another win (a much-needed win with both the Rays and Red Sox winning). It signified change at a position that has been a failure over the last four seasons. It signified the promise that for the foreseeable future you won’t have to question who’s playing shortstop for the Yankees on a daily basis.

2. Yes, it was just one game, but Lombard Jr. checked every box. The defense prowess lived up to the hype. The plate discipline did too. He nearly beat out a slow roller in his first plate appearance, homered in his second and walked in his third. And in between his offensive opportunities, he made routine plays in the field look routine and made difficult plays look easy. I can only assume the result of LASIK eye surgery feels like watching Lombard Jr. throw a ball to first base after watching Anthony Volpe throw a ball to first base for four years.

3. Lombard Jr. didn’t just act the part in his first major-league game on the field, he did so in his pregame media session as well, speaking like a seasoned veteran instead of a 21-year-old kid being asked to somewhat help save this slog of a season and help the Yankees do something they haven’t done in going on 17 years. He looked the part with a 6-foot-2 build, immaculate defensive footwork, a strong arm and a plan at the plate. If you could create a shortstop’s build it would be Lombard Jr. He looks straight out of central casting manning shortstop in the Yankees’ infield.

4. Down in Scranton, Volpe must have felt like Ron Burgundy watching Veronica Corningstone do his job. The Stadium crowd went crazy every time Lombard Jr. had a putout or walked to the plate and lost its minds when he homered in a way it never did for Volpe. There was Lombard Jr. turning double plays with Jazz Chisholm and batting in front of Volpe’s best friend in Austin Wells. (I like to think Wells swung at the first pitch and grounded out following Lombard Jr.’s home run to ruin the moment and prevent the curtain call the Stadium crowd was asking for.)

5. As I recently wrote, if Volpe played second base and batted ninth for the Yankees, the perception of him would be completely different. And maybe that’s how he gets back to the Yankees, as a second baseman. Because it’s clear he won’t be playing shortstop again for the Yankees. Lombard Jr. was everything I wanted him to be and needed him to be and I look forward to watching him play shortstop for the Yankees again on Wednesday and on Friday and on Saturday and hopefully every game for the next 15-plus years.

6. Ryan Weathers turned in his third straight gem with six scoreless innings and has allowed just one earned run over his last three starts. The Yankees needed another masterful performance from their starting pitcher because the offense consisted of the Lombard Jr. solo home run and a Chisholm solo home run, while going 5-for-28 with three walks and five strikeouts. They had first and third with no outs in the fourth and failed to score, had first and second with one out in the seventh and failed to score, and also had the leadoff hitter on base in two other innings and did nothing. Heliot Ramos’ Yankees debut was overshadowed by Lombard Jr. mania as the newest Yankee went 0-for-4 with a strikeout.

7. Fernando Cruz and Brent Headrick were shaky, but the overused duo along with David Bednar combined to throw three scoreless innings around four baserunners to preserve the lead and close out the win. Bednar struck out the side in the ninth.

8. How about a 10-run blowout on Wednesday before Thursday’s day off to give the bullpen a rest? The Yankees have won one game by more than three runs since July 9, and in that game, they won by four runs and the White Sox had the tying run in the on-deck circle in the ninth inning. The Yankees either win a nail-biter or lose. It’s unsustainable and it’s completely on the offense. At some point they need to start scoring more than two or three runs per game.

9. It will be Will Warren against Andre Pallante in the series finale on Wednesday. Warren is coming off his best start of the season with 6 2/3 scoreless innings at Wrigley Field. Unfortunately, when it comes to Warren, one start has no bearing on the next. He’s consistently inconsistent and could throw seven scoreless innings against the Cardinals or be pulled in the first inning. I would expect to see the same lineup for the Yankees on Wednesday against another right-hander. Pallante is a good starter, and considering the Yankees’ best offensive attribute is making mediocre-to-good starters look unhittable, I wouldn’t expect anything more than a ceiling of three runs for the offense.

10. It’s a home rubber game against an average team going nowhere and it’s a game the Yankees need to win. The Rays seemingly never lose and the Red Sox actually never lose. The Yankees have gone 14-8 over the last three weeks ago and haven’t gained anything on the Rays in the standings and have lost nearly everything to the Red Sox in the standings. If those two are going to win every day, the Yankees have to do the same. With Garcia essentially replacing Goldschmidt, Ramos replacing Dominguez and Lombard Jr. replacing Volpe and the best rotation in baseball, they have the ability to.

Read More

BlogsYankees

The End of the Anthony Volpe Era

Anthony Volpe has been sent down. George Lombard Jr. has been called up. It’s a beautiful day.

Hal Steinbrenner never specifically talked about prospects the way he talked about Anthony Volpe and Oswald Peraza in November of 2022.

“In my opinion, they’re going to get a shot,” Steinbrenner said. “In March, I remember saying that they’re the middle infield of the Yankees in the future. That’s why we made some decisions in the offseason, as opposed to going out and getting a huge free agent.”

At the time, the Yankees were coming off a humiliating ALCS loss, having been swept by the Astros in four games. A series in which Aaron Boone used video from the 2004 ALCS — the darkest moment in Yankees history — as a motivational tactic for his players following Game 3. The Yankees stepped up by blowing an early three-run lead and a late one-run lead in Game 4 and their season ended the same way for the 13th straight season: without a championship.


Prior to the 2022 season, the Yankees decided to sit out the deepest free-agent shortstop class in the history of the sport. Instead, the Yankees went after Isiah Kiner-Falefa, who had been traded by the Rangers to the Twins. The Rangers chose to give a half billion dollars to Corey Seager and Marcus Semien rather than roster and play the inexpensive Kiner-Falefa. The Twins didn’t really want him, but knew the Yankees desperately did and were able to get the Yankees to take on the $51.5 million owed to Josh Donaldson to get Kiner-Falefa. Using the money recouped from getting rid of Donaldson, the Twins turned around and signed Carlos Correa.

When Kiner-Falefa proved incapable of fielding the position (and hitting), the Yankees turned to Oswaldo Cabrera to play shortstop in the postseason. When Cabrera was needed in left field in the playoffs, the Yankees turned to Peraza. While the Yankees named a different starting shortstop each game during the 2022 playoffs (because that’s a strong, proven recipe for winning), Volpe watched the games from the stands, like a fan.


Steinbrenner said what he said a month after the loss to the Astros because he needed the fans to be excited about something for 2023, and Kiner-Falefa, Donaldson, Harrison Bader and Frankie Montas weren’t moving the needle. The Yankees needed to give the fans something for 2023 other than having Boone tell the media anyone who didn’t think Donaldson could still hit was “crazy.” (In two seasons with the Yankees, Donaldson posted a .678 OPS in the regular season and went 5-for-29 with 16 strikeouts in the postseason. He was released by the Yankees with a month left in the same season Boone called fans “crazy” for not believing in him.)

In spring training 2023, Volpe went off, hitting .309/.415/.618 in 64 plate appearances. It didn’t matter the quality of pitcher he faced in those 19 games, a 1.033 OPS against a combination of career minor-league pitchers and major-league pitchers working on their stuff before the season was enough for him to be named the 2023 Opening Day shortstop.


Volpe posted a .666 OPS in 601 plate appearances in 2023. After a disappointing offensive rookie year, Cashman appeared unhinged at the General Meetings that November when he had the memorable exchange with Joel Sherman in which he called his 2023 roster that went 82-80, missed the postseason and provided the worst Yankees’ regular-season record in 30 years “really fucking good.” He also defended Volpe (and the rest of the Yankees’ failed young players) to no end.

“I look forward to you telling me when Volpe crushes it offensively this year for us,” Cashman said to Sherman. “Then you’ll say, ‘Hey man, I guess your development program did a good job and it was just sea legs under him his first maiden voyage year with not much Triple-A under his belt.'”

It was Cashman’s fault Volpe was made a major leaguer after 22 Triple-A games. But Sherman didn’t have to apologize to Cashman after 2024 because Volpe showed no progress in his second season, posting a .657 OPS and a clear defensive regression.


Things didn’t get better in 2025. Volpe had a .663 OPS and an 82 OPS+ and displayed the worst defense of his three-year career. The Yankees acquired Jose Caballero at the trade deadline to compete with Volpe for the starting shortstop position — the first time in three years Volpe’s job was even somewhat threatened. But when Caballero produced an .845 OPS in September with better defense and a superior arm to Volpe’s .534 OPS, shaky defense and weak arm, it didn’t matter. It was Volpe starting at shortstop in all seven of the Yankees’ postseason games. With the Yankees facing elimination in Game 4 of the ALDS and boos raining down on Volpe after each failed at-bat, Boone finally removed him from the game in the ninth inning for a pinch hitter (Jasson Dominguez, who doubled off the wall in his first plate appearance in weeks) to prevent Volpe from being exposed to more fan vitriol. Volpe finished the ALDS 1-for-15 with 11 strikeouts.

Volpe had experienced a shoulder issue during 2025 when he said he felt a “pop” in his shoulder after diving for a ball in the Yankees’ May 3 game against the Rays last season. Volpe remained in the game and then was sent for X-rays and an MRI, all of which came back as “good news,” Boone said at the time. Volpe was held out of the lineup the next day, but the day after that he went right back to being the Yankees’ everyday shortstop.

After the season, he underwent surgery to fix the issue that didn’t appear on any imaging after it happened. The Yankees used this to their advantage in explaining why Volpe hadn’t gotten any better in three years in the majors. With a timeline that would keep him out for the first month of the season, without saying the exact words, Boone made it clear Volpe would be the team’s starting shortstop following his rehab.


The problem with Boone turning the job back over to the organization’s Golden Boy was that the Yankees were winning without him and Caballero was playing exceptional defense and doing enough offensively. It would be hard for the front office to explain to the clubhouse and the fans why Caballero was being removed from a role he was excelling at while the Yankees were piling up wins. The Yankees did the only thing they could do once Volpe’s Triple-A rehab assignment was up and assigned him to Triple-A.

Volpe had been treated like only Aaron Judge, Juan Soto and Cody Bellinger had been during his three seasons in the majors, seemingly immune to days off. A lack of days off for the other three made sense, but Volpe got to play every day like he was actually the second coming of Derek Jeter. He was never benched. The only time he was threatened with a loss of playing time was when the Yankees acquired Caballero, and even when Caballero greatly won the head-to-head battle, the Yankees still went with Volpe. This was the first time the Yankees had handled Volpe appropriately and you couldn’t find a Yankees fan who wasn’t ecstatic with the move.

It didn’t last long. Volpe couldn’t hit Triple-A pitching, just like he couldn’t hit major-league pitching, but when Caballero dove back to first on a pickoff attempt, hurt his finger and landed on the injured list, Volpe got an undeserving call-up. After a couple of “good” initial weeks against five straight opponents that won’t make the playoffs (Orioles, Mets, Blue Jays, Royals and Athletics), the Yankees had seen enough, and Volpe took the job back from Caballero, despite Boone saying Caballero would be the starting shortstop upon his activation from the IL. For the next two months, Volpe provided the same offensive and defensive performances he had given the past three years. He hit one home run in 194 plate appearances, posted a .646 OPS (the lowest of his career) and an 82 OPS+, right in line with his career 83 OPS+, all while booting routine ground balls and making throws look like he was throwing a weighted ball.

Finally, on Tuesday, after 2,080 regular-season plate appearances that combined for a .680 OPS and some of the worst defensive footwork and maybe the worst major-league shortstop arm you’ll ever see, the Yankees sent Volpe down to Triple-A. In his place comes George Lombard Jr., the one “untouchable” Yankees prospect, who represents the same promise Volpe once did: a long-term answer at shortstop. The difference between the two is obvious in their defense. Offensively, Lombard Jr. has played more minor-league games than Volpe and has raked at the higher minor-league levels in a way Volpe didn’t.


The Yankees were so desperate for Volpe to be Jeter they made him the shortstop based on less than three weeks of spring training games, and two weeks into his career had him batting leadoff. They treated him in a way they have never treated any other prospect or player. Cashman lost it on the media in 2023 over him. Boone called him “fucking elite” to Meredith Marakovits in July 2025 despite every metric on both sides of the ball suggesting he wasn’t elite at any part of baseball. He doesn’t hit for power or average. He has no arm strength and questionable defense and lost his basestealing abilities along the way. Volpe possesses none of the five tools of the game and yet he was given more run and more plate appearances with such little production than any player in history.


The same mistake can’t be made with Lombard Jr. He has proven he will hit at every level, it just doesn’t happen overnight. At every new level in the minors, Lombard Jr. experienced a learning curve offensively before finally figuring it out, and now he’s making the leap from a level where J.C. Escarra has a .987 OPS to a level where Escarra has a .510 OPS. He’s shouldn’t be counted on to change the Yankees offensively. He’s going to provide a level of defense that your eyes will feel like they did going from standard-definition TV to high-definition TV, and he will figure it out offensively along the way. He should bat ninth every game, like Jeter did, no matter what hand the pitcher throws with. Leave him there and let him learn.

Tuesday night begins a new era in the Bronx and the best thing Lombard Jr. has going for him is he isn’t Volpe. He doesn’t represent the arrogance of the Cashman/Boone Yankees, a tandem that has acted like they are smarter than everyone and has acted like they have won together. He represents change at a time when the Yankees are enduring their annual midseason collapse, can’t overcome their deficit to the Rays and have watched their 15-game lead over the Red Sox in the loss column fall to just one game.

Lombard Jr. may not be “fucking elite” yet, but he shouldn’t be told he is either. He should be treated like every prospect not named Anthony Volpe has been treated during Cashman’s tenure as GM. If the Yankees are right this time about their shortstop of the future, they won’t have to worry about who is starting there every game for a long, long time.

Read More