1. I wasn’t worried about Giancarlo Stanton hitting on Tuesday night even though he had been in a horrific slump overall, including 0-for-17 against left-handed pitching this season. When the games are big and the crowds are bigger and the atmosphere is more pressurized, that’s when Stanton is at his best. To no surprise, he led the Yankees to a 4-0 win over the Red Sox in the series opener. Stanton has always hit well against the Red Sox, just like he has always hit well in the postseason. The bigger the game, the better ‘Big G’ is.
“It’s always a fun rivalry game,” Stanton said. “And you’ve got to raise your game in those types of situations.”
2. Stanton went 2-for-4 in the game with a double, a home run, three RBIs and was robbed of a second double by Ceddane Rafaela. Stanton had been 8-for-55 with one double, one home run and a .448 OPS in April until last night. And because Stanton is as streaky as it gets in the game, you can expect it to continue in Boston (and hopefully throughout the road trip).
3. This is what the offense should look like. Stanton carries them one game, Aaron Judge another, Ben Rice another and so on with everyone else having their moments in between. What can’t happen is what happened against the Athletics and Rays where the entire lineup disappears for days at a time. One or two top-half-of-the-lineup bats need to always be producing for the team to have a chance with how weak the bottom half is.
4. It’s been a long time since Luis Gil was good, except when he faces the Red Sox. Even when Gil can’t be trusted to throw five good innings, he can always be trusted to shut down the Red Sox. Gil entered his start on Tuesday with a 0.99 ERA across 27 1/3 innings in five career starts against the Red Sox and then threw 6 1/3 scoreless in his sixth and latest start.
5. “Hopefully that’s something he builds on,” Boone said, “because we know how good he can be when he’s right.”
I don’t know that Gil will “build on” the performance since he still doesn’t seem to know where the ball is going once it leaves his hand. His success on Tuesday came from the Red Sox being so bad, more than him being good. He only struck out two and was effectively wild enough to keep the Red Sox off balance. Most major-league starters are going to have success against a lineup that has Masataka Yoshida batting third.
6. Every time Tim Hill enters a game and gets a few ground balls and makes lefties look foolish I immediately begin to think about Boone going to Nestor Cortes over Hill in Game 1 of the 2024 World Series. Hill has been exceptional this season with one earned run and no walks allowed in 10 innings. He needed just 10 pitches to get the Yankees out of the eighth inning after needing just eight to get through his last appearance six days prior. He’s the most trustworthy reliever the Yankees have.
7. Brent Headrick has increased his level of trustworthiness though and had another strong outing in this one. David Bednar looks like a completely different pitcher when he has some rest, which he didn’t have for most of the first few weeks of the season coming off the World Baseball Classic and then being thrown into so many close and one-run games immediately.
8. Ben Rice was allowed to start against a lefty again and hit third, but was the only Yankees starter to not reach base. Rice went 0-for-4 with four strikeouts, but got screwed on a few outside pitches called strikes he was unable to challenge because Aaron Judge and Jose Caballero blew the Yankees’ challenges on ill-advised challenges. Caballero and Jazz Chisholm should be banned from challenging pitches.
9. I don’t want Rice to sit ever and because I never want Rice to sit, there’s no place for Paul Goldschmidt on the Yankees, just like there wasn’t before they unnecessarily re-signed him. Goldschmidt should only play against lefties, but that means either Rice or Stanton doesn’t play. And if Goldschmidt isn’t going to play against lefties, he has no role. Goldschmidt is 3-for-20 on the season (his one important hit came against a righty in George Kirby in Seattle) and has started once in the last four games with all four games against lefties.
10. It will be Max Fried against Ranger Suarez on Wednesday. I was unhappy when the Red Sox signed Suarez because I envisioned him doing to the Yankees what lefties have done to the Yankees this season prior to the last three games. I expect Fried to pitch well because the Red Sox’ offense is abysmal and because the Yankees have lost his last three starts with his last win coming on March 31. He will need to pitch well with how well Suarez has pitched in his last two starts (14 shutout innings). For the Yankees to extend their winning streak to five they will need to win a fourth straight game started by a lefty.
Last modified: Apr 22, 2026
