Yankees Thoughts: The DJ LeMahieu Game

The Yankees finished off a three-game sweep of the Phillies, have won five straight and head home to begin the easiest schedule in the majors over the next month.

Here are 10 thoughts on the Yankees.

1. I thought the Phillies were supposed to be good? The Yankees went into Citizens Bank Park and swept a three-games series from the team with the best record in the majors. They beat up on Cy Young candidate Zack Wheeler on Monday, got to the Phillies’ bullpen on Tuesday and then got a career-high, six-RBI game from DJ LeMahieu on Wednesday, as he drove in every Yankees run. The Yankees won in a 10-run blowout and then won back-to-back one-run games after having just one one-run win since May 29.

2. Not only did the Phillies get swept at home, but they allowed the Yankees to win a game started by Nestor Cortes for the first time since June 18. Wednesday’s 6-5 win was also the Yankees’ first road win started by Cortes since June 2.

“I was just ready to make my start today, and that’s what I worked for,” Cortes said about his name being involved in trade speculation. “Hopefully, I can put up a string of good starts going forward.”

Cortes will have a great opportunity to put together that string as the Yankees’ schedule is about to get as easy as a major-league schedule can get with three-game series against the Blue Jays, Angels, Rangers, White Sox, Guardians, Rockies and Nationals. Outside of the series with the Guardians, August is full of wins.

3. The Yankees were finally able to win a game started by Cortes because of LeMahieu. LeMahieu hit a grand slam in the second inning for his second home run of the season to give the Yankees a 4-0 laed, and then with the Yankees clinging to a 4-3 lead in the sixth, he smoked a two-run double to the gap in right-center

“It’s been tough for me, but today felt good,” LeMahieu said. “My teammates have my back in supporting me. To come through and see how excited they are, it’s a good feeling for sure.”

Back on July 21, LeMahieu said, “It hasn’t given me much hope the last month or so. As long as I’ve played this game, whatever challenges have presented itself, I’ve always come out of it one way or another.” Since then, LeMahieu is only 4-for-19, but two of those four were home runs and another was a double. Maybe this is him coming out of it? I sure hope so, as on July 22, I wrote:

I love LeMahieu. I was all for re-signing him after 2020 for what he did in 2019 and 2020. He deserved to be re-signed. After posting a .922 OPS in his first two seasons with the Yankees, he has a .702 since. He suffered season-ending injuries in 2021 and 2022, played through injuries last year and missed a large portion of this season because of injuries. It fell apart quickly for LeMahieu after 2022 and while there have been moments over the last three-plus years where he looks like himself, they are only moments, nothing consistent or frequent. On a team full of unplayable names, he is the most unplayable of them all. But because of all of those other unplayable names and because he’s owed about $41 million through 2026, he’s going to keep getting opportunities to prove his career isn’t over.

I want nothing more than for LeMahieu to return to his old self, regain the starting second base role and send Gleyber Torres to the bench. That’s the dream.

4. After re-signing LeMahieu to be their second baseman for the next six years, he was forced off the position when Torres couldn’t handle shortstop. The Yankees catered to Torres and LeMahieu started being a third baseman and first baseman regularly. Then when the Yankees traded for Jazz Chisholm Jr., they played him in center field for a game and then third base the last three games — a position he has never played before. Why? To cater to Torres.

On Wednesday, Torres batted leadoff. He went 0-for-5 with a strikeout. In his first chance at being a leadoff hitter this season (March 28-April 9), he went 10-for-50 with a 11 strikeouts, hitting .200/.281/.240. His slash line for the season is down to .231/.306/.357. For his career, he’s a .237/.282/.356 hitter in the leadoff spot. Please stop trying to make him a leadoff hitter. (Please also stop using Alex Verdugo and his .298 on-base percentage as the leadoff hitter.)

5. After Cortes was removed, Luke Weaver pitched an inning and gave up a run. Tommy Kahnle got two outs and Mark Leiter Jr. allowed his first run since June 19. The only reason Leiter allowed a run was because Torres couldn’t handle ball hit at him that every major-league second baseman should be able to handle.

6. Then it was time for Clay Holmes. A day after blowing his eighth save opportunity of the season, Holmes allowed a leadoff single to Kyle Schwarber and it looked like Here we go again. Instead, Holmes was able to get Austin Hays on a flyout (he narrowly missed hitting a walkoff home run) and got a double play off the bat of the struggling Bryce Harper. A seven-pitch save from Holmes? Add another humiliating moment to the series for the Phillies.

7. Brian Cashman spoke to the media about the trade deadline and the roster for the rest of the season.

“I liked what we had before we made the moves, and I know we’ve improved since these moves,” Cashman said.

There’s no one in the world who liked what the Yankees had before the moves. Before acquiring Chisholm, the team had lost 24 of 35 games. If Cashman liked the team so much, he wouldn’t have made any moves.

8. “I think we have a really good team already, and it’ll get better over the course of time when certain guys come back from the IL,” Cashman said. “With the imports, we’ve made it better.”

The team is really good now. (That’s also because they have won five straight games, so the feeling and perception around them has changed drastically since Trent Grisham had an 0-2 count against Kenley Jansen on Saturday night.)

The only player I’m excited about “returning” is Jasson Dominguez. Dominguez would make the lineup deeper and better and would mean the bench for Verdugo. Unfortunately, barring injury, I don’t think Dominguez will be called up until rosters expand on September 1.

9. “He’s a legitimate force when he’s healthy and all the rust is knocked off,” Cashman said of Dominguez. “It’s exciting to know that’s an opportunity that’s there, but I have no idea past that. We like what we have currently, and it’d be nice to know that’s sitting there if we need it.”

Cashman definitely has an idea, and that idea is September 1. That gives Dominguez more time at Triple-A to get healthy from his oblique and develop, and it gives more time for Verdugo to play himself out of the starting lineup. A Yankees lineup with Dominguez over Verdugo (if Dominguez stays healthy and hits at Triple-A) and LeMahieu over Torres (if LeMahieu can continue to hit the ball in the air) is a real possibility.

10. The Yankees have Thursday off before hosting a Blue Jays team that has given up and traded away pieces off of their 26-man roster within the last week. The Blue Jays are counting down the days until Game 162 with a focus on next year and are the perfect team for the new-look Yankees to beat up on over the weekend. The dog days of summer and the stretch run is here, and so is the easiest schedule in the majors over the next month.