1. Cortes delivers …
Freeman hits a ball to right field …
SHE IS GONE! …
GIBBY, MEET FREDDIE! … GAME 1 OF THE WORLD SERIES!
For many Yankees fans, they probably only heard Joe Davis’ call of Freddie Freeman’s walk-off grand slam once. They probably heard it in real time, turned off the TV and went to bed. Not me. I heard it a second time. And a third time and fourth time. I heard it for nearly an hour after the game had ended from the other room as my wife — a Dodgers fan — watched the historic moment on an endless loop.
I’ll never get over Game 1. I’ll never get over the litany of bad decisions that started with Gerrit Cole being removed in the seventh inning and ended with Nestor Cortes being asked to get Shoehei Ohtani and Freddie Freeman out.
2. When these Yankees lose, they don’t just lose. They lose in the excruciating, heartbreaking, kick-you-in-the-nuts-then-punch-you-in-the-face-when-you-go-to-grab-your-nuts fashion. They don’t lose games 7-2 or 5-0. They lose games like Game 1 of the World Series or Game 4 of the ALCS, which is how these Yankees always lose in the playoffs. The Dodgers lost two games to the Padres by scores of 10-2 and 6-5. They lost two games to the Mets by scores of 7-3 and 8-0. Normal, easy-to-accept losses. The Yankees? They carry high-’90s win probabilities into the final inning and come within an out or a strike of a winning before suffering an unbelievable loss.
Game 1 didn’t have to be an unbelievable loss. It should have been a statement win, letting the Dodgers know they aren’t playing the Padres or Mets anymore. Instead, the Dodgers let the Yankees know they aren’t playing the AL Central anymore. (The Yankees have not won a postseason series against a team outside of the AL Central since the 2012 ALDS against Baltimore.) The game was a perfect summarization of the Aarons era with Aaron Boone managing his team to a loss and Aaron Judge doing absolutely nothing at at the plate to prevent it.
3. Boone desperately wants to be known as some kind of baseball genius or managerial savant. It’s why he interjects himself into games in the oddest ways, even when he doesn’t have to. His father — a 19-year veteran, World Series champion and seven-time Gold Glove winner — and brother — a 14-year veteran, four-time Gold Glove winner and two-time Silver Slugger winner who led the league in RBIs one season — had careers that overshadowed Boone’s 92 OPS+ in the majors. (Maybe that’s why he’s so infatuated with giving endless chances to below-league-average hitters he manages.) Managing the Yankees was going to be his way of stepping of that shadow.
Boone was selected as the manager of the most prestigious organization in major sports following the young, exciting core coming within a win of the World Series despite having no managerial or coaching experience at any level. His lack of experience showed in his first spring training when he called on Dellin Betances to enter a game even though Betances had yet to warm up. The umpiring crew gave him a mulligan and let Betances warm up anyway. In the first series of his first regular season in Toronto, he managed the Yankees to a late-inning loss with his bullpen choices and from that moment on he has never evolved.
4. His longing to be the smartest baseball mind in a major-league dugout is why he makes the moves he makes. He didn’t need to remove Cole from the game. Not after 88 pitches. He didn’t need to show the Dodgers all of the Yankees’ elite relievers in Game 1 of the series. He didn’t need to use Clay Holmes in relief of Cole. He didn’t need to try to steal outs with Tommy Kahnle. He didn’t need to pinch run Jasson Dominguez for Gleyber Torres with two outs, but he wanted Judge to single in Dominguez, so talking heads would praise him for the awareness to use Dominguez in that spot. He didn’t need to go to Jake Cousins in relief of Luke Weaver with the Yankees three outs from a win in the 10th and Weaver having thrown only 19 pitches. He didn’t need to use Cortes over Tim Hill, but he wanted to try to turn one of his starters into a shutdown postseason reliever like his friend, rival and much more heralded and respected Alex Cora did in 2018.
5. Boone had his worst night as Yankees manager in the biggest game he has ever managed. It was the type of managerial performance I have feared from him for seven years. It was a performance he foreshadowed to us all over the last seven years.
“I just like the matchup,” Boone said of using Cortes in the 10th. “The reality is, Cortes has been throwing the ball really well the last few weeks as he’s gotten ready for this.”
What are you talking about? What reality? Cortes facing Jahmai Jones in live batting practice in an empty Yankee Stadium isn’t reality. That’s a controlled environment. Reality is pitching in Game 1 of the World Series with a former MVP at the plate and the bases loaded.
“I knew with one out there, it would be tough to double up Shohei if Tim Hill gets him on the ground,” Boone said. “Then Mookie behind him is a tough spot matchup there. So I felt convicted with Nestor in that spot.”
Whenever Boone lays out the thought process he uses to make decisions, we all get a look inside the brain of a confused idiot. If Hill gets Ohtani on the ground, he doesn’t need a double play. There were runners on first and second with one out. Ohtani goes on the ground and there are two outs. Cortes didn’t face Betts, so Hill wouldn’t have either. If the bases are loaded and Hill gets Freeman on the ground, guess what? Game over.
6. I don’t blame Cortes for the missed location to Freeman. Once the bases were intentionally loaded, he had to throw strikes. Freeman knew this and was ready for a fastball in the zone. Even if Cortes hits his intended location, Freeman likely still gets a hit and ends the game. It’s Freddie Fucking Freeman, not Josh Naylor. But no, it’s not Cortes’ fault. He last pitched in a game on September 18. He didn’t put himself on the World Series roster after missing five weeks and being on the brink of Tommy John surgery and he didn’t put himself in that spot.
7. Boone doesn’t believe the Yankees’ Game 1 loss is on him. In his mind he pressed all of the right buttons and his players didn’t perform. The idea of putting your players in the best possible position to succeed isn’t a concept Boone comprehends. The ironic part about Boone is that he is always managing with tomorrow on mind. It’s why he pulled Weaver after going five up and five down on 19 pitches, rather than using Weaver in the 10th and securing a win. But while Boone always manages for tomorrow, he never manages a game thinking the game may go to extra innings, and when it does the Yankees are ill-equipped to win. Do you think it’s just a coincidence the Yankees have lost every extra-inning game in the postseason with Boone as manager?
The bigger the game, the worse Boone is at his job. Just like his superstar, $40-million-per-year MVP.
8. Giancarlo Stanton is everything that Judge isn’t. He’s a big-game performer who saves his best for the playoffs and has become the second coming of Mr. October. Judge is Mr. May. No one destroys back-of-the-rotation starters and middle relievers like Judge does in the spring and summer.
Everyone thought Judge had moved past his postseason failures when he hit the home run off Emmanuel Clase in Game 3 of the ALCS. But since his home run off Clase (that came in the Yankees’ only loss of that series), Judge is 2-for-14 with a pair of singles and 10 strikeouts. He has struck out 16 times in 36 at-bats this October.
If Judge just sucked and wasn’t abysmal, the Yankees’ offense wouldn’t be in such a dire position. But he has been impossibly bad, culminating in his three-strikeout performance in Game 1 of the World Series, a game in which he looked blindfolded swinging at Jack Flaherty breaking balls. Late on fastballs and unable to hit curveballs. That’s Mr. May.
9. Judge’s absence has turned the Yankees into a two-batter lineup. Opposing pitchers can fear Juan Soto and Stanton and no one else. The threat of slug in the lineup dies after Stanton bats. Sure, Jazz Chisholm and Austin Wells each hit solo home runs in this postseason, but no one is threatened by the idea of them doing that consistently. Anthony Rizzo is a slap singles hitter and Anthony Volpe is the same. Alex Verdugo has trouble getting the ball in the air past infielders, so the thought of him hitting one over the fence is far-fetched. When Wells makes contact it’s a miracle, so no one is expecting him to drive the ball with any authority. When the bat gets taken out of Soto’s hands through an intentional walk and Stanton’s at-bat doesn’t end with a home run, the Yankees don’t score. Unless the Dodgers are going to start walking in runs like the Royals did or throwing wild pitches and dropping popups like the Guardians, the Yankees are going to have a tough time scoring without Judge being himself.
10. At this point, I have no expectation he will be himself. The last time he looked like himself was exactly a month ago today when he finished a streak of five straight games with a home run at the end of September. Since the calendar turned to October he has performed his annual disappearing act while the two batters he is sandwiched between in the lineup have carried him and the team. The Dodgers are too good to let Soto and Stanton alone carry the Yankees to another series win.
The narrative after the ALDS was that the Yankees were able to advance without Judge hitting, so just wait until he starts hitting! Then the ALCS came and he went 3-for-18 with eight strikeouts and the narrative remained the same: The Yankees were able to advance to the World Series without Judge hitting, so just wait until he starts hitting! Well, the World Series is here. It’s a game in and Judge looked worse at the plate than he did at any other time in the playoffs. There are some star players who can’t handle the postseason with any consistency, and to this point in his career, Judge is one of them.
Last modified: Oct 26, 2024
