fbpx

BlogsYankeesYankees Thoughts

Yankees Thoughts: Never a Normal Loss

Written by:

The Yankees’ first loss of the season was a game they could have won, which is how nearly all of their losses unfold. Here are 10 thoughts on the Yankees.

1. The Yankees can never just lose. By “just lose” I mean get blown out, shut down, shut out, never have a chance in the game. They either win, blow a game late, bring the tying run to the plate in the ninth, have an abundance of blown opportunities to tie or take the lead, or suffer a painful, excruciating loss. Yes, it keeps every game entertaining and means the Yankees are “in” every game, but at the same time, their losses and the way they lose always seem to be extremely detrimental to the health and wellbeing of their fans. Sure enough, they couldn’t “just lose” for their first loss of 2025.

2. It would have been easy to stomach Will Warren getting knocked around by a very good Diamondbacks lineup in his first start as officially part of the Yankees’ rotation. It would have been acceptable if the bats went quiet against Corbin Burnes and never had a chance in the game. But no, Warren was solid (5 IP, 2 ER), Burnes gave up a pair of solo home runs to Jasson Dominguez and Anthony Volpe to allow the Yankees to tie the game, and Josh Naylor, of all players, gifted the Yankees a two-run error to give them a 4-2 lead in the fourth inning.

3. Aaron Boone had it easy in the first three games of the season. On Opening Day, he was able to go from starter to middle relief to Luke Weaver to Devin Williams for a win. Things got rocky with Williams, but if he had blown the three-run lead in the ninth, no one would have faulted Boone as the game unfolded easily for him, presenting the blueprint for a win my four-year-old son could have implemented. Then in the second game of the season, the Yankees blasted the Brewers for 20 runs, and in the third game, another 12. Boone didn’t have to manage or make any difficult decisions for the first three games of the year. Then came Tuesday.

4. Once it was announced Devin Williams would be out of the equation for the birth of his child, you knew the back end of the game would have the opportunity to be complicated for Boone, and it was. After Fernando Cruz gave the Yankees two perfect and dominant relief innings with four strikeouts to keep their 4-2 lead from the fourth, Boone went to Tim Hill with the 8-9-1 hitters due up in the eighth. Torey Lovullo had Randal Grichuk (who kills both lefties and the Yankees) on his bench, and once Hill took the mound, Grichuk went in as a pinch hitter, and immediately rocked a leadoff double to left. Geraldo Perdomo followed with a single down the first-base line, and just like that, the Yankees’ lead was down to 4-3 and the Diamondbacks had the tying run on base with no outs.

Hill retired Corbin Carroll for the first out of the game, and then Boone had a decision to make. He could gamble and try to preserve the lead by getting the next out or two with Hill or another middle relief option to save Luke Weaver for the ninth inning, or he could go to Weaver right then with the tying run on second and heart of the Diamondbacks’ order due up. If you didn’t see the game, you already know which choice Boone made.

5. Boone called on Mark Leiter Jr., who was good in the Brewers series, but has been a disaster since becoming a Yankee. In order to preserve the lead, Leiter would have to get the final two outs of the eighth against the Diamondbacks’ 2-3-4 hitters.

Leiter didn’t get the last two outs of the eighth. He got one, and then gave up a go-ahead grand slam to Eugenio Suarez on a 2-2 splitter that split in the strike zone. After taking a fastball down the middle in the second pitch of the at-bat and swinging through a fastball on the fourth pitch of the at-bat, it was obvious Suarez wasn’t sitting on a fastball from Leiter. Paul O’Neill said as much based on Suarez’s takes on YES. But that didn’t stop Leiter (and Austin Wells) from going away from the fastball on the fifth pitch, and the Yankees were on their way to their first loss of the season.

“Just not his sharpest outing,” Boone said of Leiter. “It just wasn’t a good split, obviously, that he threw there.”

6. You have to love Boone essentially saying the loss was on Leiter. Did Leiter insert himself into a high-leverage situation against the heart of an order on Tuesday? If Williams had been with the team, it would have been Weaver in the eighth and Williams in the ninth, and Boone’s job would have been as easy as it had been on Opening Day. But because Weaver became the interim closer for the night he had to pitch the ninth for Boone. I thought baseball had evolved from set innings for relievers when Terry Francona went to Andrew Miller in the middle innings of the 2016 postseason. I thought the idea of having your best reliever pitch against the heart of the order with the game on the line regardless of the inning was more important than having them pitch in a set inning regardless of which part of the order was due up. Just look in the other dugout where Lovullo did just that.

7. “The Diamondbacks’ closer is Kevin Ginkel and he is out with shoulder inflammation, so they are mixing and maxing with Martinez who we saw in the eighth and A.J. Puk,” Michael Kay said on YES. “The better hitters were coming up in the eighth inning and they had Martinez pitch the eighth and he stuck them out.”

Lovullo went to his best reliever in the eighth with Aaron Judge and Jazz Chisholm due up. All Martinez did was strike out the side and put any hope of a comeback on life support. Puk pitched the ninth and even though Puk typically can’t be trusted, he could be with a three-run lead against the bottom of the order. Puk’s chance at success was vastly improved when the left-handed reliever was given an all-left-handed-batter lane to face in the ninth. How did Puk get that lane? From Boone, of course, who inexplicably pulled Dominguez after his at-bat in the sixth to put Trent Grisham in the game for defensive purposes.

“Taking Dominguez out and bringing in Grisham,” Kay said, “you set up a lane for Lovullo to bring in a lefty and counteract three straight lefties.”

8. Do the Yankees really need Grisham playing one-third of every game for defensive purposes? Do they really think that’s best for the development of Dominguez as an outfielder? All Dominguez did earlier in the game was improve his OPS to .974 on the year with his first home run of the season. (After getting ahead of Puk 1-0, Grisham took three straight strikes to strike out.)

9. Yes, it was just one loss, their first loss. Yes it’s going to happen many more times this season (but hopefully not more than 73 times for my over 88.5 wins wager). Did the Yankees deserve to win? No, it’s hard to win when you score three non-error-aided runs, strike out 14 times and have a manager who continues to be clueless in his eighth season in the position. But the Yankees could have won. They were gifted two runs with a Cy Young-caliber pitcher on the mound and were four outs away from a win.

10. Now it’s up to the two Carloses to prevent undoing everything from the wild opening weekend against the Brewers. If the Yankees don’t get back in the win column on Wednesday or Thursday, I’m sure it will come as the result of an agonizing loss. That’s the only way they lose.

Last modified: Apr 2, 2025