1. A two-run lead with 12 outs to go and a completely rested bullpen. That’s the position the Yankees found themselves in on Tuesday night in Cleveland. Twelve outs to get between some combination of Mark Leiter Jr., Tim Hill, Fernando Cruz, Luke Weaver and Devin Williams. It may not have been as easy of a winning formula as Max Fried to Weaver to Williams, but in terms of easy-to-navigate scenarios, it wasn’t exactly difficult.
Aaron Boone made it difficult. After getting five shutout innings from Will Warren in what had been his best start in the majors, Boone decided to push Warren a little more. Boone’s obsession with stealing outs knows no boundaries, even if a pitcher who has never pitched more than 5 1/3 innings in his career and is about to face the top of the lineup for a third time should be the boundary.
Boone thought it would be wise to let Warren pitch to Steven Kwan — one of the game’s premier leadoff hitters — to begin the sixth. Kwan had already singled off Warren earlier in the game after picking up two hits in the first game of the series. He singled again off Warren to lead off the sixth. (Kwan is now hitting .341/.400/.505 on the season.)
OK, leadoff man on and the 2-3-4 hitters due up. Now Boone would pull Warren with the tying run at the plate.
No, he wouldn’t.
He would let Warren face Nolan Jones for a third time in the game. Jones promptly singled.
The tying run was now on base and the go-ahead run at the plate in Jose Ramirez. Apparently, that was enough for Boone to remove Warren and bring in Leiter Jr., who could have easily started the inning clean.
2. Leiter Jr. struck out Ramirez on three pitches to bring up Kyle Manzardo. Stephen Vogt knew he would need to be creative to score runs after Ramirez was retired, so he called for a double steal with Kwan and Jones. The two took off and J.C. Escarra tried to pick-and-throw Leiter Jr.’s pitch rather than simply catch it, and it created a passed ball. Kwan raced around to score and Jones reached third. The Yankees’ lead was now 2-1 with the tying run at third and one out.
Manzardo then hit a ball to Aaron Judge, who dove and missed it, allowing Jones to score the tying run and Manzardo to go to second with a “double”. After getting Carlos Santana to ground out for the second out of the inning, Manzardo moved to third. Leiter Jr. then walked the light-hitting Bo Naylor and allowed an infield “single” to Angel Martinez on a ball Anthony Volpe misplayed to score the go-ahead run.
3. The rest of the game became a formality with the Guardians’ elite relievers slamming the door on the Yankees. If you thought the Yankees would mount a comeback, you must not know these Yankees.
These Yankees were on full display on Tuesday. The game was a good summarization of the Boone Yankees as a whole, representing the same type of team the Yankees have fielded for the last eight seasons. It was the type of the game the Dodgers spent all season laughing about at the Yankees’ expense. It had poor managing, incapable hitting and disastrous defense.
4. When the Yankees led off the fourth with back-to-back walks to bring up Volpe, Boone let his shortstop, who is 15 percent worse than league average for his career swing away. And swing away into a inning-destroying 6-4-3 double play he did. When the Guardians had to two on with no one out in the sixth, they put pressure on the Yankees, created a shitstorm and watched the Yankees unravel and lose the game. The Yankees spent all game waiting around for a multi-run home run to save them and it never came, and when they don’t get said home run, they lose.
5. The Yankees’ offense is essentially Judge, Ben Rice and Trent Grisham (and singles-hitting Paul Goldschmidt). Their rotation is Max Fried and their bullpen is Luke Weaver. It’s a top-heavy team whose flaws are outrageous. Judge is hitting .411, Rice has a 1.004 OPS. Fried has a 1.42 ERA and the Yankees are 5-0 in his starts. Luke Weaver has allowed two hits and no runs in 12 innings. What happens when Judge cools off even a little? What happens if or when the clock strikes midnight on Rice and Grisham? What happens if the Yankees lose a Fried start? What happens if Weaver blows a late lead?
Those things are likely to happen, which is why losses like Saturday’s and Tuesday’s hurt so much. The Yankees need to win the games they are supposed to win, the games in which they hold a late lead. Unless they are going to start winning games they aren’t supposed to, and so far this season you can say that has happened once at most (their 4-2 win over the Royals).
6. Tanner Bibee had been rocked in his two starts not against the Royals, allowing 13 earned runs and seven home runs in 9 2/3 innings. It was the perfect matchup for the Yankees to put up runs, and instead, they scored two runs over six innings, with one of those runs coming on the first pitch of the game. A putrid performance.
7. The Guardians do the little things on the field and do them right because they have to. They create runs, they cause havoc on the basepaths, they play exceptional defense and they try to get to their bullpen as quickly as possible. They can’t sit around and wait for a home run that isn’t going to come because it won’t. They can’t play station-to-station baseball or they won’t score. They make the most of what they have.
8. The decision to steal outs with Warren with all five “elite” relievers available was egregious by Boone. But if the offense could have done more or done anything really, he wouldn’t have been put in the position to ruin the game. When the Yankees play close games, they are going to lose a lot of them with Boone at the helm. The Yankees are going to play a lot of close games with so many automatic outs in the lineup.
Each day I write about how bad Cody Bellinger has been and each day he makes things worse, as he went 0-for-4 with two strikeouts. Guess where he hit, yet again? Third. His OPS is down to .519.
Jazz Chisholm was 0-for-1 with a hit by pitch and two walks, and that’s actually a really good day for Chisholm, who was passed yesterday for the league lead in strikeouts. Congratulations, Jazz! (He also made a throwing error in the game.)
9. It’s hard to watch Anthony Volpe bat. It’s cringeworthy. Volpe went 0-for-3 with a walk and strikeout in the game, but nothing was worse than his final at-bat against Hunter Gaddis in the eighth. With the tying run on second and the go-ahead run on first, Gaddis blew a middle-middle 95-mph fastball right past Volpe to begin the at-bat. Knowing Volpe’s inability to hit fastballs, even ones in the zone, Gaddis threw three more to set up a 2-2 count. Volpe had seen four pitches, all fastballs. Gaddis then threw a slider about two feet off the plate, but Volpe, guessing fastball and knowing he would need to cheat to catch up to it had committed to swing. Once Volpe recognized slider, his hips had already flown open, his bat was on the plane of where he thought the pitch would end up, and instead he missed it by a laughable amount. After Volpe’s inning-ending act, it took Cade Smith four pitches to close out the ninth. When the going gets though, these Yankees get going.
10. The Yankees had a four-run lead in the ninth on Saturday and lost. They had a late two-run lead with their entire bullpen rested and lost on Tuesday. A 3-1 trip to Tampa that could have been more wasn’t and now a seven-game road trip that started out promising is on the brink of being a 3-4 letdown. That is, unless Carlos Rodon and the offense can save it.
Last modified: Apr 23, 2025
