1. The Yankees had to have the series and road trip finale in Detroit. A loss on Thursday in Detroit would have extended their losing streak to four straight, would have dropped them to .500, would have wasted a dominant starting pitching effort, would have made for a depressed plane ride and trip back home and would have lingered throughout Thursday’s day off. Thankfully, none of that happened or will happen. The Yankees have Max Fried and Ben Rice to thank for that.
2. After Fried’s most recent start in Pittsburgh (5.2 IP, 6 H, 1 R, 1 ER, 1 BB, 6 K, 1 HR), I wrote: It’s exciting to think about how good Fried will be when he’s “on” in one of his starts, which he certainly wasn’t on Opening Day and really wasn’t against the Pirates.
Well, Fried was “on” on Thursday for the first time as a Yankee: 7 IP, 5 H, 0 R, 0 ER, 0 BB, 11 K. He stifled the Tigers’ bats in a way the two Carloses couldn’t and led the Yankees to a win.
Prior to Wednesday’s game, I wrote: The series finale is the kind of start the Yankees got Max Fried for. Three straight losses and a matchup against an unimpressive offense. This is a game the Yankees need to Fried to go out there and hand the ball off to Luke Weaver and then Devin Williams with no one in between and salvage the final game of the series and road trip. Fried did just that.
3. For six-plus innings it felt like Fried’s best day as a Yankee may be for nothing. The Yankees couldn’t score against Jack Flaherty (5.1 IP, 3 H, 0 R, 0 ER, 3 BB, 9 K) and let Flaherty and Tyler Holton off the hook in the sixth inning, unable to score with runners on second and third and one out.
In the seventh, Holton quickly retired Jasson Dominguez and J.C. Escarra.
“The Yankees are a team that’s built on home runs and they have not homered in three games and 6 2/3 innings,” Michael Kay said with two outs in the seventh. “When a pitcher or pitching staff can keep them in the ballpark, you have a chance.”
After Kay finished opining, Oswaldo Cabrera singled.
The Yankees hadn’t homered since Saturday and were a few innings away from not homering in four straight games for the first time since September 2020. Rice made sure that unfortunate stat wasn’t duplicated.
Rice crushed a 1-0 pitch from Holton 419 feet over the center-field wall to give the Yankees a 2-0 lead.
Prior to the home run, the Yankees had scored five runs in their last 34 innings. Those five runs came in three innings, so the Yankees had scored in 31 of the last 34 innings.
4. After the Rice home run, Fried put up his seventh and final zero of the day before turning the ball over to Weaver (just like I had asked for). Weaver worked around a one-out single to pitch yet another scoreless inning.
In the ninth, the Yankees scored two extremely important insurance runs as a result of some Yankees-esque defense from the Tigers. The game had an ominous feel as though it could turn into a complete letdown after the heroics from Fried and Rice if Williams were to blow the game in the ninth. And based off Williams’ early-season appearances, it certainly wasn’t out of the question.
5. Williams walked the first batter of the ninth. A walk with a four-run lead. If not for the two tack-on runs in the eighth, the Tigers would have the tying run at the plate with no outs in the ninth. Williams struck out the next two, but after a two-out single from Javier Baez (you know Williams isn’t right when Baez is getting a line-drive base off of him), he unraveled. Williams walked Trey Sweeney, threw a wild pitch to score Baez (who had taken second on defensive indifference) and allowed a single to Zach McKinstry to make it 4-3. Aaron Judge (who earlier in the game idiotically got caught in a rundown between third and home on a ball hit back to the mound) moronically threw the ball home, allowing McKinstry to go to second. With two outs in the ninth, the Tigers had the tying run on second and Aaron Boone was forced to take the ball from Williams and give it to Mark Leiter Jr. It’s bad enough Williams nearly blew a three-run lead in the ninth on Opening Day, but now he was about to blow a four-run lead, had given up a hit to Baez and was being pulled for Leiter. What a first 13 days in pinstripes.
6. Leiter got Justyn-Henry Malloy to pop up to Jazz Chisholm in shallow center to end the game. If the Yankees had lost, it would have been a loss that would be hard to top as the worst of the season even with 150 games remaining. A loss would have wasted Fried’s brilliant outing. It would have wasted Rice’s heroics. It would have extended the losing streak. It would have lingered on the plane ride, travel home and day off. It would have dropped the Yankees to .500.
7. The win wasn’t withouts its warts with Williams being the biggest. Chisholm had another hitless day and is down to .180/.255/.460. Anthony Volpe continues to morph back into his 2023-24 self (and lost the grip on the bat on two different strike 3s in the game). Dominguez had an 0-for (.205/.295/.359), and then’s there Cody Bellinger.
8. Bellinger is a problem. Normally, you would think someone being bad (.562 OPS) through seven percent of the season isn’t a big deal, but it is. It is because Bellinger is evidently going to bat second ahead of Judge or third behind him no matter what because of his veteran status, because he was the National League MVP (with the juiced baseball) six years ago and because he bats left-handed. It takes an extraordinary amount of struggling for Boone to move a veteran down in the lineup, and it’s going to take a lot for him to move Bellinger down even if it’s deserved. Here’s to Bellinger figuring it out after a day off with the familiar-for-him Giants coming to the Bronx this weekend.
9. On the positive side (aside from Fried and Rice), Judge looked like himself at the plate after a few shaky days, Paul Goldschmidt had two more hits and Cabrera had a two-hit day with the second hit coming from his “weaker” side (the right side). That hit led to him being on base when Rice blasted his two-run home run.
On Friday, Cabrera had a three-hit game then was benched on Saturday and Sunday, played on Monday and was benched again on Tuesday. With a lefty scheduled to start against the Yankees on Friday, Cabrera will likely be on the bench again. How about just letting him play every day and bat from both sides? The Yankees clearly don’t believe in Oswald Peraza (and shouldn’t believe in Pablo Reyes as even a bench option), otherwise Peraza would have played more in 2022, 2023 or 2024, so they need to stop acting like they believe in him now. Play Cabrera every day, against all starting pitchers and let him be the everyday third baseman.
10. The Yankees head home at 7-5 instead of 6-6. They head home having salvaged the third game of the series to finish the road trip at 3-3 instead of 2-4. They head home on a happy and upbeat plane rather than a somber and disappointed one. They head home to host the Giants where they will have their work cut out for them with Robbie Ray, Jordan Hicks and Logan Webb scheduled to pitch. They can’t let what happened to them against the Diamondbacks and Tigers happen to them against the Giants when facing a team’s best three starters.
Last modified: Apr 9, 2025
