1. I couldn’t believe it. I couldn’t believe in the eighth inning of a 0-0 game with the 3-4-5 hitters of the Rangers lineup due up that Aaron Boone was going back to Devin Williams a night after he blew a one-run lead in the ninth inning. Then again, everything is believable when it comes to Boone and in-game decisions.
These were Williams’ last three appearances entering Tuesday:
Tuesday, July 29 vs. Tampa Bay: Entered with a three-run lead in the ninth. Allowed a triple and a walk and brought the tying run to the plate with no outs before eventually getting out of the inning.
Wednesday, July 30 vs. Tampa Bay: Entered with a one-run lead in the ninth. Allowed a walk and then a go-ahead, two-run home run for the blown save.
Monday, Aug. 4 at Texas: Entered with a one-run lead in the ninth. Allowed a game-tying home run for the blown save.
2. Williams has been untrustworthy since the first day he put on pinstripes on Opening Day when he nearly blew a three-run lead in the first game of the season. I don’t care about his run from early May through mid-July. Late March and April were enough to make me never trust him on the mound and when you add in his body language when things aren’t going well and the way he handles answering for blown saves — citing “just one bad pitch” when he blows a one-run lead like he did on Monday — there’s nothing to like about him. Devin, as a closer with a one-run lead, YOU CAN’T HAVE “ONE BAD PITCH!”
But there he was unable to command his fastball and throwing his changeup for easy takes on the Globe Life Field mound on Tuesday for the second time in 24 hours. And there he was ruining a game on the Globe Life Field mound for the second time in 24 hours as he allowed two runs and the Yankees lost 2-0.
3. It’s not Williams’ fault he was pitching in that spot in the game. It’s not his fault he’s still viewed as the highest-leverage reliever the team has. It’s not his fault he’s a Yankee. It’s his fault he sucks, but it’s not his fault the Yankees’ decision makers aren’t willing to accept that he sucks.
Boone could have and should have gone to either David Bednar or Mark Leiter Jr. for the eighth against the 3-4-5 hitters, but he decided to save both, likely wanting Bednar for a save situation as Boone continues to worry about a situation that may never come instead of worrying about the moment even as the Yankees continue to plummet down the standings. Boone stayed with Williams after he loaded the bases. He only went to Leiter Jr. once the Rangers had scored twice.
4. There have been a lot of stars over the years who have come to the Yankees and failed and failed miserably and Williams is the latest. It won’t surprise me when he’s somewhere else in 2026 and pitching like his pre-Yankee self and serving as the closer of the All-Star Game. It’s sad that so many great players and Hall of Fame players that have played for the Yankees under the Steinbrenners’ ownership were forced to cut their hair and shave daily, but the policy was modified for Williams of all players. One of, if not the softest player to ever come through the organization.
5. For as soft as Williams is, the offense as a collective group is much, much softer. After suffering a disastrous loss on Friday, the offense went out and got two-hit and shut out on Saturday. After suffering a disastrous loss on Monday, the offense went and got two-hit and shut out on Tuesday. This team has no fight. It’s why they didn’t have a late-game comeback for months to begin the season. When the going gets tough, the Boone Yankees get going. They always have, outside of a select few.
6. One of those few is Giancarlo Stanton who was held to one plate appearance on Tuesday because Aaron Judge returned and Judge can only DH, and because the Yankees are worried about Stanton’s health with 48 games left and a playoff berth hanging in the balance, Stanton is going to be held to one plate appearance a lot moving forward. Shockingly, the Yankees’ problems weren’t resolved with the return of Judge as Boone suggested they may be when he sternly said, “Judge tomorrow,” to the media after Monday’s game as if to foreshadow that everything would change. The Yankees were a bad team for a long time with Judge playing every day and continued to be one without him and are still one now with him again. Judge wasn’t himself for a long time before going on the injured list and still isn’t himself as he went 0-for-3 with two strikeouts. Judge did say the Yankees “have a good ball club” and Boone said he’s “confident” the team will turn it around. The same “good ball club” and the same “confidence” the two have never stopped referring to despite being 19-29 since June 13.
7. It’s always the ex-Yankee fucking the current the Yankees. It was Nathan Eovaldi throwing eight inning of one-hit ball on Tuesday. On Monday, it was former Yankees minor leaguers Josh Smith and Ezequiel Duran (two players traded for Joey Gallo) combining to go 3-for-7 with three RBIs. Over the weekend in Miami, it was Augustin Ramirez (traded for Jazz Chisholm) with the walk-off hit on Friday and two solo home runs in the Yankees’ 2-0 loss on Saturday. It’s always the ex-Yankees.
8. Eovaldi’s line looks great from Tuesday, but he didn’t do anything special. Eury Perez and the Marlins did the same thing to the Yankees on Saturday. Shutting out the Yankees isnt some great accomplishment. In June, they were shut out at Fenway Park on a Sunday and then shut out for 11 innings by the Angels the next day and then shut out by the Angels again the day after that. Eovaldi was good on Tuesday because he’s been good in nearly every start since leaving the Yankees after 2016.
9. Boone has had nearly three full seasons to pinch hit for Anthony Volpe in big spots and has always refrained. Yes, Stanton presented a better chance at a game-tying home run in the ninth inning on Tuesday and I would have made the same move, it’s just funny that Volpe is finally showing some semblance of offense and power for the first time in his career and now he’s a pinch-hit opportunity for Boone. Maybe Boone will finally start pinch hitting for Austin Wells now too.
10. Unfortunately, Carlos Rodon, who is as soft as Williams gets the ball in the series finale on Wednesday. Anyone who tells you they like Rodon, trust him, think he’s good or believe he will go out and lead the Yankees to a win on Wednesday is either a Yankees homer, full of shit, soft themself or all three. Sure, Rodon could go out and pitch well and the Yankees could end their five-game losing streak and avoid falling out of a playoff spot for the first time all season, but no one can feel confident in thinking he will. Because even if Rodon pitches well, the offense is likely to no-show. And if the offense does show, Rodon likely won’t pitch well. And if the offense does show and Rodon does pitch well, someone will make a baserunning or defensive mistake you have never seen before. And if the offense does show and Rodon is great and the Yankees play a clean game in the field and on the bases, the bullpen will blow it. And if the offense does show, Rodon is stellar, the Yankees play a clean game in the field and on the bases and the bullpen is unhittable, the Yankees just may win. And if all of those things happen it will be their first clean game and their first win since the trade deadline and in August. And if all of those things happen, the Yankees will leave Texas still in a playoff spot.
Last modified: Aug 6, 2025
