1. When the Yankees get shut down by the opposing starting pitcher, they tend to have an opportunity early on to get to them, don’t and end up being stifled for the remainder of the outing.
It happened on April 2 against the Diamondbacks’ Zac Gallen. The Yankees had second and third with one out against the righty in the second inning and failed to score and Gallen settled in to throw 6 2/3 scoreless innings (with 13 strikeouts).
It happened on April 8 in Detroit against Tarik Skubal. The Yankees led off that game with back-to-back singles, couldn’t get either of them in and Skubal found his groove to retire 16 straight in a Yankees’ shutout loss.
It happened again on Monday in Cleveland. Gavin Williams isn’t Gallen or Skubal, but he certainly has the stuff to be, and like the other two, Williams was in trouble early in the game. The Yankees were gifted a leadoff error by defensive wizard Brayan Rocchio and also had two walks in the first and didn’t score a run. Cody Bellinger unsurprisingly hit into a double play and Jazz Chisholm struck out and the Yankees were held scoreless.
2. Williams kept the Yankees off the board until the seventh when he gave up a two-run home run to Jasson Dominguez right before being relieved at 104 pitches. While Williams (6.1 IP, 7 H, 2 R, 2 ER, 2 BB, 8 K, 1 HR) was throwing up zeros, Clarke Schmidt (4 IP, 7 H, 5 R, 5 ER, 3 BB, 7 K, 2 HR) was throwing batting practice to light-hitting Guardians.
“I felt like he was a little off command-wise,” Aaron Boone said, stating the obvious.
Schmidt put 10 baserunners on in four innings, allowed up five earned runs and two home runs. Lefties mashed off of him, especially Jose Ramirez and Kyle Manzardo who hit back-to-back homers off Schmidt in the third.
“We did a good job limiting the damage,” Schmidt said in all seriousness.
3. Prior to Monday, Schmidt had made three career starts at Progressive Field with this line: 13 IP, 16 H, 10 R, 9 ER, 9 BB, 17 K, 3 HR, 6.23 ERA, 1.923 WHIP. Add in him blowing Game 3 of the 2022 ALDS, being unable to get through five innings in Game 4 of the 2024 ALCS and Monday night, and it’s a good thing the Yankees don’t play in Cleveland again this season.
“I think I was able to make some good pitches,” Schmidt said after getting lit up.
4. The Guardians had a 6-0 lead after six, but the Yankees put together one of their patented trick-you-into-thinking-they-may-actually-come-back comebacks that fall just short. The Yankees scored two in the seventh (Dominguez home run) and another two in the eighth on a Chisholm home run. In the ninth, they brought the tying run to the plate in Aaron Judge, but he struck out against Cade Smith to end the game.
If only the Yankees had scored in the first when they had three baserunners and Williams had tiring at 25 pitches. It may have not mattered since Schmidt was so bad anyway, but the inability to move runners over and get them in and score runs while making outs continues to be a problem during the Boone era. It’s why the team has been awful in extra innings games since the implementation of the automatic runner. The situational hitting remains poor and the manager doesn’t have the creativity to build runs unless someone is hitting the ball over the wall.
5. When you remove two Yankees from the lineup who have been hitting the ball over the wall in Ben Rice and Trent Grisham (who is out on paternity leave), it’s hard to win. Rice was held out of the game after being hit on the elbow on Saturday (despite all tests coming back negative), however, he was able to pinch hit in the ninth. So Rice (who is only used as the designated hitter) was healthy enough to bat once in the game, but not four times? Was his elbow going to break with three more plate appearances?
6. It’s hard to win without Rice and Grisham because so much of the lineup sucks. Austin Wells went 0-for-5 and his OPS is down to .687. Bellinger (.548 OPS) may as well not bring a bat to the plate and hope the pitcher throws four balls before three strikes. Chisholm (.680 OPS) seems to hit a home run every few days and do nothing else in between. Anthony Volpe has a .614 OPS since April 2 with 20 strikeouts in 60 at-bats. Pablo Reyes isn’t a major-league player.
The lineup is essentially Judge, Rice, Paul Goldschmidt (who is basically a singles hitter), Oswaldo Cabrera (who is also a singles hitter), Dominguez against righties (.926 OPS against righties and .390 OPS against lefties) and Grisham when he plays, which isn’t every day since the Yankees have to play Bellinger because of owed money.
7. Bellinger is a big problem because he’s going to play because of owed money and his name and for the front office to justify the trade for him. The problem is he’s going to bat near the top of the lineup when he plays because of those things, whether he’s producing or not. The biggest problem is that there’s precedent for Bellinger being this bad.
Bellinger won the NL MVP in 2019 when the baseball was juiced and Brett Gardner (28 home runs) and Gleyber Torres (38 home runs) became power hitters. Since then, Bellinger has a 99+ OPS in 575 games and 2,352 plate appearances. He’s a .242/.304/.421 hitter since the start of 2020.
Within these last five-plus seasons, Bellinger posted a .542 OPS in 2021 and a .654 OPS in 2022, and the Dodgers moved on from him. The Dodgers –the best organization in baseball — moved on from their homegrown, 2017 Rookie of the Year, 2019 MVP and Gold Glove center fielder after his age 26 season. That’s not great.
8. The Yankees have used Bellinger in the 2-hole hoping he would mash in-zone pitches expected with Judge behind him. They have used him as Judge’s protection. They have used him to clean up. He has done nothing in every spot. The season may only be 14 percent through, but again, there is precedent for Bellinger being a complete zero at the plate for an entire season. And if this is one of those seasons from Bellinger in a year where a single game could decide the AL East or a wild-card berth, the Yankees can’t afford to play him over other bats, whether those other bats are owed less money or not.
9. Bellinger isn’t the only problem, he’s just the biggest once. Chisholm, Volpe and Wells have been atrocious, Devin Williams has been a joke and every starter not named Max Fried has an ERA of at least 4.34. Despite their glaring issues, the Yankees are fortunately 14-9.
Schmidt was bad and Williams was solid, but the Yankees hit into three double plays in the game (one of them was bad luck on a Chisholm line drive), and when you hit into three double plays in six innings, it’s going to be difficult to win.
10. It’s going to be difficult to win on Tuesday as well. Will Warren gets the ball and based off of his Thursday night showing in Tampa (1.2 IP, 4 H, 1 R, 1 ER, 2 BB, 1 K), it’s hard to have much confidence in him. Tanner Bibee goes for the Guardians. Bibee has made four starts this season. Two of them were against the Royals, in which he 10 1/3 scoreless innings. The other two were against the Angels and Orioles, and he allowed 13 earned runs and seven home runs in 9 2/3 innings. The Yankees are going to need that Bibee to show up. They’re also going to need some combination of Bellinger, Wells, Volpe and Chisholm to show up and for Rice to play.
Last modified: Apr 22, 2025
