1. I thought this season could be different. I thought maybe the annual Boone Swoon wouldn’t happen. Not because I thought the clueless manager would get a clue in his ninth year on the job or that the “Run It Back” offense would be better than it was last year or that the piss poor defense that has defined this Yankees era wouldn’t constantly piss itself or that the bullpen would be trustworthy enough, but because I thought this rotation wouldn’t allow it to happen. What I didn’t account for was the manager, offense, defense and bullpen overpowering the rotation in baseball and making it irrelevant.
2. This weekend was bad. Very bad. The Yankees went from having the division lead to now being two games back of the Rays in the loss column. They were humiliated by a last-place Red Sox team that has had nothing to feel good about all season, and the Yankees gave them the four best days of their season. They lost a Cam Schlittler start in which they didn’t allow an earned run, they were dominated by Payton Tolle again, they lost a Gerrit Cole start because Cole can’t beat the Red Sox whether Rafael Devers is on the team or not and then came the grand finale: the worst loss of the season on Sunday night. The Yankees scored eight non-automatic-runner runs in four games at Fenway Park. They had three hits in each of the last three games of the series. They blew a two-run lead with Schlittler on the mound in the opener and then blew a two-run lead in the 10th inning in the finale, further improving their record and reputation as the worst road extra-inning team since the automatic runner was implemented.
3. The Yankees have now lost eight of 11. Their lead in the AL East has become a deficit for the second time this season. I thought the worst part of the weekend for Aaron Boone would be him walking onto the field in the 10th inning on Sunday with an infield glove for Amed Rosario to use with the winning run on third and one out and the current at-bat already in a 1-0 count. But then Boone sat in his office at Fenway Park and gave one of the most tone-deaf, disturbing postgame press conferences of his nine-year tenure.
“We got a really good freakin’ team,” Boone said. “We played crappy on this trip, feels bad, kind of pissed off.”
There’s nothing the Yankees love more than telling you how good they are when things go badly. Brian Cashman said the 2023 team that went 82-80, had the worst record by a Yankees team in three decades and missed the postseason entirely in a format in which 40 percent of the league gets in was “really fucking good.” After the 2024 World Series disaster, they spent the offseason telling us how good they were to win the AL pennant, never mentioning their path to a pennant was the AL Central road of the Royals and Guardians. Boone told us the 2025 team was “the best he ever managed” and that team had to play in the Wild Card Series and won one game in the ALDS. The front office decided to run it back with the same roster that got run out of the postseason, and now they want you to know how good they are after getting swept in a four-game series by the last-place Red Sox in a year in which there are two other teams in the AL above .500 and one of them is the White Sox.
4. At full strength, the Yankees have a good team. Not a “really freakin’ good” team and nowhere near a great team. After all these years, their lineup is still reliant on one bat, the rotation isn’t as sound as it’s made out to be, the bullpen has one truly trustworthy arm and after nine seasons, the manager continues to show why hiring someone who never coached, let alone managed at any level should have never been given the keys to a team coming off a Game 7 defeat with a chance to go to the World Series. He continues to speak like someone who has never won anything at the major-league level, wanting people to believe he knows what it takes to win when all he has known is postseason failure.
5. How could he only be “kind of pissed off?” He was more pissed about Jazz Chisholm bringing a lollipop out to second base (an antic he supposedly didn’t even know took place until after the game) than he was about losing four straight to a last-place team, losing eight of 11 and once again losing the division lead to the Rays. The weekend was ugly and these last two weeks have been uglier.
With no date in sight for Aaron Judge to be re-imaged and Giancarlo Stanton only going through “low-volume workouts,” the offense you see is what you get. Ben Rice and Cody Bellinger have failed miserably to carry the offense when it was needed the most. Rice is hitting .114/.139/.200 over the last nine games and Bellinger is hitting .135/.273/.162 over the last 11 games. The Yankees had a top-heavy lineup with Judge and Stanton and Trent Grisham in it, without them, they need Rice and Bellinger to not be the zeros they have been these last couple of weeks and to pray the clock doesn’t strike midnight on Paul Goldschmidt’s renaissance.
6. I have given up thinking Jazz Chisholm will do anything this season other than hit the occasional solo home run and then take 49 seconds to jog around the bases. Chisholm led off for the first time as a Yankee on Sunday night and was eventually ejected after arguing a check-swing call and throwing his helmet like the baby he is. When Chisholm isn’t sucking on lollipops at the plate or in the field or telling the media he’s going to hit 50 home runs and steal 50 bases or that the Yankees are going to win the World Series, he’s leaving every runner in scoring position stranded and flailing at breaking balls low and away. With each game that comes off the schedule, we are that much closer to the end of Chisholm as a Yankee.
7. I couldn’t sleep after Sunday’s loss and I found myself searching for the worst single-season OPS for a regular player in major-league history with Austin Wells now at .499. The players who finished a season with a lower OPS than Wells all played in the early 1900s. Barry Bonds had four seasons with a higher OBP than Wells’ current OPS. Despite Wells being the undisputed worst offensive player in all of Major League Baseball, over the weekend, Boone said, “I feel like he’s moving the needle right now, believe it or not.” Wells went 1-for-11 in the series and is 2-for-21 since coming off the injured list. We are now in the second half of the season as Sunday was the 83rd game and Wells has two doubles, four home runs and 10 RBIs. Stanton has six doubles, three home runs and 14 RBIs and last played on April 24.
8. The Yankees called up Oswaldo Cabrera because he had been red-hot in June and hitting left-handed pitching extremely well. The Yankees faced three lefties in a row from Thursday through Saturday and Cabrera was on the bench all three games. Then they had him play against a righty on Sunday night after having not played in any game at any level over the previous four days.
9. Every game Anthony Volpe plays shortstop for the Yankees is a game they choose not to field their best team. Volpe’s arm is a disgrace for the position at the major-league level. I watched Bobby Witt Jr. finish turning an inning-ending double play on Sunday afternoon purely on arm strength that would have never been possible for Volpe and would have led to the inning being extended. Yes, it’s unfair to compare the best shortstop in baseball to the worst everyday player in baseball since his 2023 debut, but my point is that Volpe doesn’t defend well enough to justify his hitting, and if you haven’t noticed, his little hot streak is over and he’s back below the league-average line offensively. It’s only a matter of time until his season OPS is in line with his .665 career OPS. And when it is, we will still be watching him play every day for the Yankees as we remain trapped watching the same season unfold each year.
10. Last Monday, I listed the the tough opposing probables for the next 10 games and they are 2-5 in the first seven games of the 10-day stretch. Now they get to face Casey Mize and Tarik Skubal again to close out June before beginning a July littered with games against the Rays, Dodgers and Phillies, and also the .500-or-better Cubs, White Sox, Nationals and Pirates.
With no expected return date for Judge or Stanton or Max Fried and no immediate help for the bullpen, the offense and bullpen are going to have to hit and pitch better, the defense is going to have to play major-league-caliber defense and the manager is going to have to put the best team on the field as often as possible or this swoon will make previous swoons look like a walk in the park.
Last modified: Jul 10, 2026
