1. If you didn’t watch Saturday’s Subway Series game, the only information you need to know the outcome is that it was a one-run game. Knowing that, you can safely assume the Yankees lost. And they did.
The level of ineptitude displayed by Aaron Boone in every close game somehow grows. Now in his eighth season as Yankees manager, for a man who was born into baseball, it continues to be startling how bad he is at everything involved with in-game strategy. It’s disturbing really.
Boone’s entire in-game job description is to put his players in the best possible position to succeed, and the times he does so each season can be counted with your fingers and you’ll likely have a few unused fingers. He has not improved in this aspect of his role since become manager. At best, he’s the same in 2025 as he was in 2018, though, in actuality, he may be worse.
Boone’s lack of common sense and creativity is the reason the team has the worst extra-inning road record in the majors since the automatic runner was implemented, but his inability to make simple choices that nearly everyone in attendance and watching at home can identify is why the team is 7-15 in one- and two-run games this season (and 19-4 in games decided by three runs or more). The closer the score, the more important every managerial decision becomes. The Yankees’ expected record based off of their run differential is 30-15 and their actual record is 26-19. It’s not a coincidence they are playing four games worse than their run differential when you factor in who is managing the team.
2. Boone had it easy on Friday night. The Yankees scored six runs and Carlos Rodon allowed one run over five innings. By the time Boone had to make a bullpen decision the Yankees had a five-run lead and it wasn’t exactly difficult to call on Jonathan Loaisiga, Mark Leiter Jr. and Devin Williams, who combined to throw three scoreless innings. With a five-run lead in the ninth, Boone decided to go with the last man in the bullpen in Yerry De los Santos. (Tyler Matzek had arguably been the last man in the bullpen, but was designated for assignment by the Yankees on Friday. He was good enough to be pitch in a one-run game in Seattle on Wednesday, but then not good enough to be a Yankee on Friday.) Yes, De los Santos should be able to get three outs with a five-run lead, but there’s a reason he was in Triple-A before injuries led to his call up, and he created a mess in the ninth. Boone ended up needing to use Luke Weaver to get the final out on Friday with two pitches. Those two pitches meant Weaver had pitched three of the last four days and that would make him unavailable on Saturday by the Yankees’ self-created pitching rules. (A little bit of foreshadowing for you.)
3. The Yankees offense wasn’t as good on Saturday as it was on Friday. They only managed to score on a pair of solo home runs in their 3-2 loss, but that doesn’t mean the opportunities weren’t there for them to score more. Their manager prevented them from doing so.
The Yankees didn’t get their first baserunner until the third inning and that runner touched them all. DJ LeMahieu hit a home run to the short porch in right to five the Yankees a 1-0 lead.
“It just felt good to play at Yankee Stadium again and in front of these fans,” LeMahieu said. “It’s obviously a big series. I’m just excited to be out there.”
4. To keep with the Yankees’ ongoing lack of shutdown innings, Clarke Schmidt immediately gave the run back and more in the very next inning. Schmidt walked Francisco Lindor and allowed back-to-back singles to Juan Soto and Pete Alonso. After Brandon Nimmo struck out, the Mets didn’t wait around for another base hit to score a second run. With Soto on second, Schmidt paid no attention to him and Soto took off to easily steal third as Yankees pitching continues to think stealing bases against them isn’t allowed. Mark Vientos hit a fly ball and Soto scored to give the Mets a 2-1 lead.
5. The Yankees had an opportunity to tie the game in the fifth and squandered it in an unbelievable (but very believable with Boone at the helm) way. J.C. Escarra led off with a walk and LeMahieu singled. The Yankees had first and second with no outs and 9-hitter Jorbit Vivas up. Vivas has been 60 percent worse than league average in 34 career plate appearances, so everyone knew he was going to bunt. Everyone except Boone. Vientos was drawn in at third anticipating the bunt, but Boone had Vivas swing away, and swing away he did, all the way to a strikeout to keep the runners where they were for an unproductive out. The Yankees could no longer tie the game with back-to-back productive outs and when Ben Rice followed with a deep fly ball that would have scored the tying run, it made the decision to not bunt hurt that much more. Aaron Judge followed with a groundout. Rally extinguished.
6. The Yankees did tie the game in the sixth with the only way they know how to score in close games: a home run. Cody Bellinger led off the inning with a long solo home run. After a Paul Goldschmidt groundout, Jasson Dominguez and Anthony Volpe hit back-to-back singles with Dominguez going to third on Volpe’s. The Yankees had first and third with one out and Escarra due up. It was too early in Boone’s mind to hit for Escarra with Austin Wells since Boone only hits for his catcher if the team trails in the ninth inning (a scenario that was created for him in this game). He bypassed hitting for Vivas in the fifth and bypassed hitting for Escarra in the sixth. Escarra hit the first pitch from Huascar Brazoban weakly to Pete Alonso at first. Holding true to his managerial deficiencies, Boone had the contact play on and Dominguez was easily thrown out at home. (I can think of one time the contact play worked for the Boone Yankees and it worked because of a throwing error.) The Yankees failed to score in the inning.
Schmidt had given the Yankees six innings of two-run ball and when he reached the dugout after the sixth it looked like his day was over. Not for Boone. Boone sent Schmidt back out for the seventh and he allowed a 105-mph single on the first pitch. Then Boone took him out. Was that really Boone trying to steal outs in the seventh inning of a game in which he already failed to bunt runners over to tie the game didn’t pinch hitter for his backup catchers with a chance to take the lead? You bet it was.
The Yankees caught an enormous break in the inning when Leiter Jr. allowed a double in the gap to 9-hitter Tyrone Taylor. There was only one out in the inning, but that didn’t stop the Mets from sending Brett Baty home in a move I thought only the Yankees were dumb enough to make. A perfect Yankees relay ended with Baty being thrown out at the plate to keep the game tied. Instead of having second and third with one out and Lindor and Soto due up, the Mets ran themselves out of the inning.
The Yankees would certainly make the Mets pay for their mistake, right? With Trent Grisham pinch hitting for Vivas (two innings two late) and Rice and Judge due up the Yankees had a chance to take a late lead. The trio went down in order.
7. In the eighth, with the game still tied at 2, the Yankees were in a prime position to take the lead. The effective-but-wild Reed Garrett came in for the Mets and walked Bellinger to start the inning. Unfortunately, Goldschmidt banged into a first-pitch double play to erase Bellinger. Dominguez battled for a seven-pitch walk to extend the inning and with the slow-to-the-plate Garrett on the mound it was likely he could take second and get into scoring position. But Dominguez never took off for second. Not even when Volpe got into a 2-2 count did Dominguez get out in motion. So when Volpe doubled down the right-field line, Dominguez was unable to score. Escarra walked to load the bases for LeMahieu who crushed a first-pitch fastball at 107 mph (an exit velocity we haven’t seen from LeMahieu in years), but it was hit right at Soto in right. Instead of scoring a run or two or clearing the bases with a smoked line drive, LeMahieu and the Yankees had nothing to show for it. Only the Yankees could draw two walks and produce a single, double and a 107-mph line drive in a single inning and not score.
The old adage that you use your closer in the ninth inning of a tie game at home meant Weaver would pitch the ninth. Except he didn’t. Remember the two-pitch outing from the night before? That was enough to keep Weaver out of the game. So Boone sent Fernando Cruz back to the mound after he had gotten the last out of the eighth. Cruz allowed a walk, single, hit a batter and gave up a sacrifice fly and the Mets took a 3-2 lead.
The Yankees went down without a fight in the ninth inning. Boone finally used Wells against Edwin Diaz and he struck out. Rice hit a little flare to third that was caught and Judge struck out for the game. Judge finished the game 0-for-5 with three strikeouts, and unsurprisingly, the Yankees played a close game and lost.
8. “It was a great baseball game,” Boone said. “It really was.”
Boone really said that. The manger of the losing team in a game he single-handedly lost thought it was a “great game.” It was a losing quote from a losing-minded manager. All I could think about after hearing it was the image YES showed during the game of Boone presenting Soto with his American League Championship ring before the game as if producing or wearing a ring celebrating winning the AL and getting pantsed in the World Series isn’t embarrassing. Soto already has a ring. A real ring from when he posted an 1.178 OPS and hit three home runs against the Astros in 2019 to beat the team the Boone Yankees have lost to in the postseason three times during his tenure. Soto doesn’t need some piece-of-shit pennant ring.
9. Sunday presents a rubber game in the Stadium version of the Subway Series. The Yankees will face the left-handed David Peterson. Maybe they can bring back Jahmai Jones and J.D. Davis, the duo Boone famously hit first and fourth against the Mets in last year’s Subway Series.
Would Boone dare to hit LeMahieu first against the lefty? Based on LeMahieu’s at bats in three games it wouldn’t be the worst thing. He did hit a home run on Saturday and hit a ball 107 mph. If you want to say it was a short-porch homer, too bad. I didn’t see anyone else on the Yankees using the short porch on Saturday. I think I would be inclined to use LeMahieu as the leadoff hitter against a lefty. He’s as healthy as he’s going to be and with the more games he plays you never know when he’s going to get hurt and no longer be available. You might as well use him while you still can. I wouldn’t use Trent Grisham or Rice. If anything, I would go with Volpe or Bellinger as both have crushed lefties.
In actuality, this is what Boone is likely to do on Sunday night:
1. Trent Grisham, CF
2. Aaron Judge, RF
3. Cody Bellinger, LF
4. Paul Goldschmidt, 1B
5. Jasson Dominguez, DH
6. Anthony Volpe, SS
7. Austin Wells, C
8. DJ LeMahieu, 2B
9. Oswald Peraza, 3B
10. It shouldn’t matter that much because Max Fried is starting and the offense doesn’t need to provide much when Fried starts. The Yankees lost the last time Fried started on Tuesday and it was the first time they have lost one of his starts, and they lost 2-1 (another one-run, extra-inning road loss). Fried didn’t have his best stuff and still only allowed one run over five innings. I don’t see him having to grind through a second straight start.
Fried is starting and the only relievers who should be needed when he starts are rested in Loaisiga and Weaver and the Yankees have a day off on Monday. The Yankees are set up to win the Stadium portion of this year’s Subway Series. Unless their manager screws it up.
Last modified: May 18, 2025
