1. The Yankees were about to waste another Cam Schlittler gem. If Austin Wells’ ground ball doesn’t get through the right side of the infield with two outs in the 10th, the Yankees would have wasted an eight-inning, two-hit, one-run masterpiece from their ace. Because even though the score may have still been tied if Wells had gotten out there, we all know how the bottom of the 10th inning would have played out. (Michael Kay said the Yankees “haven’t had much luck” in extra innings on the road even though their abysmal record has nothing to do with luck.) But instead of adding to their humiliating extra-inning road record since the implementation of the automatic runner, the Yankees scored five runs in the 10th and pulled out a 6-3 win in Anaheim.

2. The Rays lost to the Mets and the Red Sox lost to the Mariners, so the Yankees improved in both the division and wild-card standings. They are now 3 1/2 games in back of the Rays (four in the loss column) and five games up on the Red Sox (six when you factor in the head-to-head tiebreaker). It was an all-around positive late night heading into Thursday’s day off.

3. Schlittler became the first Yankee in franchise history to have 19 starts of one run or fewer, a preposterous stat. The only two hits he allowed over eight innings were both to Vaughn Grissom: a single and a solo home run. He picked up nine strikeouts and lowered his American League-leading ERA to 2.04.

4. Schlittler’s only competition for the AL Cy Young Award is Dylan Cease and I don’t think it’s much of a competition. Schlittler has started three more games than Cease and has him beat in the majority of pitching categories, including the most important ones.

Schlittler: WAR, ERA, WHIP, ERA+, starts, innings, walks and walks per nine innings
Cease: Strikeouts, FIP, hits per nine, home runs per nine and strikeouts per nine

5. I wouldn’t have been able to sleep if the Yankees had lost to the Angels for the fourth time in seven games this season and wasted Schlittler’s effort on a night the Rays lost, considering the Yankees have already wasted and lost these starts from Schlittler this season:

6 IP, 0 ER
6 IP, 2 ER
5 IP, 0 ER
6.1 IP, 1 ER
7 IP, 1 ER
5.1 IP, 1 ER

6. Paul Goldschmidt went 2-for-3 in the leadoff spot and would have been 3-for-3 if not for a dazzling play by former Yankee Oswald Peraza at third base. It’s safe to say Goldschmidt will be leading off against any lefty for the rest of the season, including the postseason. Cody Bellinger went 3-for-5 in the game and 8-for-14 in the series. Heliot Ramos went 0-for-3 (but hit into some bad luck with a line-drive double play). Ben Rice went 2-for-4 and Amed Rosario went 1-for-5. Spencer Jones had a rare bad night going 0-for-4 with four strikeouts as Reid Detmers was able to get Jones to chase breaking pitches away and go after high fastballs. Jose Caballero went 1-for-4. Jazz Chisholm and Ali Sanchez combined to go 0-for-5. Wells went 2-for-2 after entering as a pinch hitter, Trent Grisham went 1-for-2 with a single in the 10th and Luis Garcia went 0-for-2 after entering as a pinch hitter. Garcia would have shouldered a lot of blame for a loss because of his at-bat with the bases loaded in the 10th, if Wells hadn’t picked him up.

7. Wells is a surprising 6-for-14 with two home runs and nine RBIs in his last five games. In those five games, Wells has produced 32 percent of his RBIs for the season. His overall stats for the year are a lost cause, but if he can just be bad and not historically awful for the rest of 2026, it will make a huge difference in the lineup. The Yankees have started to lessen the number of automatic outs in the lineup, and getting Wells to do something productive every once in a while instead of going weeks without reaching base will make the offense that much deeper.

8. I would expect George Lombard Jr. to be back in the lineup on Friday, and if he is, the only missing player will then be Aaron Judge. The Yankees are so close to having their expected position players for the postseason (not including Giancarlo Stanton since it’s hard to envision him being available again this season). The rotation is as good as it’s going to be health-wise since Ryan Weathers will only return as a reliever (if he returns) and Clarke Schmidt is preparing to come back as a reliever. It’s unfortunate the Yankees never had their entire expected roster for a single day in 2026. It’s annoying to think about what their record would be and how many games up in the division they would be if injuries hadn’t impacted Judge, Stanton, Cody Bellinger, Max Fried, Gerrit Cole, Carlos Rodon and Ryan Weathers throughout the year. (Rice and Lombard Jr. also missed games without going on the IL, while Caballero, Grisham, Wells and McMahon all went on the IL at some point.)

9. As long as the Yankees are within four games (which they are now) in the loss column when they play the Rays four times from September 22 to September 24, they will have a chance at the division. Ideally, the Yankees would be closer than four games, so they don’t need to sweep the four games in three days, and they have a chance to be closer given the Rays’ upcoming schedule: four at Texas, three at Atlanta and three against Houston. The Rangers are two games back in the West and 1 1/2 games back of the last wild card. The Braves have a four-game lead on the Phillies and are tied in the loss column with the Dodgers for a first-round bye. The Astros have a two-game division lead and would be out of the wild-card race. All three teams are playing for their postseason lives and will give the Rays everything they have.

10. The Yankees head to San Diego where they need to avenge what went on last weekend when the Padres blew two late leads to the Rays. (If not for those meltdowns, the Yankees would be two games back in the loss column.) After the weekend in San Diego, the Yankees have nine games against the Rockies, Mets and Twins. This is their chance to make sure the deficit when they play the Rays is less than the four games it is now.

1. How could Spencer Jones not be the team’s starting center fielder over Trent Grisham at this point? Here’s what I wrote about Jones before Tuesday’s game:

Jones is a better offensive and defensive alternative to Grisham, but I highly doubt the Yankees (who treat Grisham like Ken Griffey Jr.) are ready to make that determination. It takes a lot more than 118 games of piss-poor defense and being five percent worse than league average at the plate for the Yankees to pull the plug on someone they love internally. Jones has a better batting average, a better on-base percentage, a better slugging percentage, a better OPS, a better OPS+, has accumulated more WAR than Grisham and is actually above league average as a hitter, and the Yankees will choose not to accept that when Aaron Judge returns. Add in Jones’ overall speed (he’s the fastest Yankee) and his superior defense to Grisham, and there is no debate as to who should play when Judge returns.

All Jones did in Tuesday’s 7-3 win in Anaheim was hit a first-inning, two-run home run, draw a walk and drive in a third run with yet another base hit against a lefty. Jones is up to .245/.320/.451 on the season and is 13 percent above league average offensively. Since his call-up at the end of July, he has an .827 OPS. He’s riding a five-game hitting streak and has hits in eight of 10 and 15 of 20. His home run was his fourth in his last 13 games.

2. Grisham went 1-for-5 in the game and did have an RBI single for his first hit since last Wednesday, bringing his OPS back to an even .700 for the season. He remains six percent worse than league average on the season. He was 16 percent worse than league average from 2021-24, then 23 percent above league average last season and back to six percent worse this season. I wonder who the real Grisham in: the player who was a below-league-average hitter for his career before 2025 and again in 2026 and who never hit more than 17 home runs in a season, or the player who hit 34 home runs last season?

3. Ben Rice has only reached base once in his two-game audition in the leadoff spot, but I like him. Leave him there against righties. How about this lineup against righties?

Ben Rice, DH
Aaron Judge, RF
Luis Garcia, 1B
Cody Bellinger, LF
Spencer Jones, CF
Jazz Chisholm, 2B
George Lombard Jr., SS
Ryan McMahon, 3B
Austin Wells, C

5. Jazz Chisholm had a three-hit game for the second time in a week and is 15-for-33 over the last week and a half. It’s crazy that even after this hot streak, he’s still below league average as a hitter this season. That’s how bad he was all year before this streak.

6. Jose Caballero was so good to start the season before landing on the injured list in May, and he’s been so bad really since then. He went 0-for-5 with three strikeouts on Tuesday, his fielding has been poor (though he has had to move around the entire field) and his plate appearance quality is just not good. He thinks every called strike is a ball, takes hittable pitches all the time, swings at garbage and wastes challenges either out of emotion or because he doesn’t know the zone.

7. I wish the Yankees weren’t grinding out wins against the American League-worst Angels. But so far this season, the Yankees are 3-3 against the Angels and their three wins are two ninth-inning comeback wins and then Tuesday, a game in which a four-run lead became a one-run lead and was still a one-run lead into the eighth inning. These are the scores of the six games this season:

Yankees win 11-10 (trailed 10-8 in bottom of ninth)
Yankees lose 7-1
Yankees win 5-4 (trailed 4-3 in bottom of ninth)
Yankees lose 11-4
Yankees lose 10-1
Yankees win 7-3 (4-3 game in eighth)

8. The Angels have outscored the Yankees 45-29. The Angels have scored the third-fewest runs in the AL and have allowed the sixth-most runs. They suck. And for some reason the Yankees have struggled with them.

9. The Angels’ ability to score runs against the Yankees should change on Wednesday with Cam Schlittler starting, but it may not be easy for the Yankees to score with Reid Detmers going for the Angels. Detmers owns a 0.59 ERA in 15 1/3 career innings against the Yankees.

10. It’s a game the Yankees have to win if they want to keep the division dream alive, whether the Rays win or lose their series finale against the Mets. The Yankees can’t lose another game to the Angels. They can’t lose the season series to the Angels. Not this Angels team.

1. It took the Yankees one game to show the importance of winning Sunday’s season finale against the Red Sox. The Yankees left New York on Sunday with a five-game lead over the Red Sox (thanks to the head-to-head tiebreaker) and that lead is down to four. Had the Yankees lost Sunday’s game to the Red Sox, their lead would be one game in the loss column with the Red Sox owning the tiebreaker.

It took the Yankees one game because while there was a game in Anaheim against the MLB-worst Angels on Monday, the Yankees didn’t show up for it. Elmer Rodriguez got lit up and lasted only 3 2/3 innings, the defense committed three errors and the offense went 6-for-32 with no walks and 10 strikeouts. It was a pathetic performance all around from the Yankees, but not unsurprising. I answered reader questions on Monday and wrote the following about this series:

The Yankees historically don’t play well in Anaheim and that includes during this awful Angels era. I went back and looked at the last five seasons and the Yankees are 7-8 in Anaheim during that time. The Angels won 77, 73, 73, 63 and 72 games in those years. This year, the Angels have the worst record in the majors and are on pace to lose 100 games for the first time in franchise history. I could see the Angels series not being easy and being somewhat of a trap, especially the Monday game, with the Yankees coming off essentially a postseason series, having to fly across the country and using a rookie starter.

2. It’s not going to get any easier for the Yankees this week either. They will face Grayson Rodriguez on Tuesday and Rodriguez owns a 3.18 ERA in 17 career innings against the Yankees, and they will face Reid Detmers on Wednesday and Detmers owns a 0.59 ERA in 15 1/3 career innings against the Yankees.

3. It’s disturbing that the Angels are 3-2 against the Yankees this season and 50-83 against everyone else, and both of the Yankees’ wins were ninth-inning comebacks against the Angels. Losing 10-1 to any team is embarrassing, but losing 10-1 to the 2026 Angels and ending what was a seven-game losing streak is on another level.

4. In the 138th game of the season, Aaron Boone finally recognized Trent Grisham shouldn’t be the team’s leadoff hitter. Boone did the right thing by moving Ben Rice to first and Grisham to fifth and Rice rewarded Boone’s choice by going 0-for-4. Grisham also went 0-for-4, as did Luis Garcia. Jose Caballero and Austin Wells both went 0-for-3, as it turns out they aren’t very good when a position player isn’t pitching. Cody Bellinger had two singles, Amed Rosario had two singles, Jazz Chisholm had a single and Spencer Jones hit a solo home run. Those were the Yankees’ six hits and Jones’ was the entire offense.

5. Rodriguez didn’t build off his career-best start against the Astros, and instead, reverted back to the pitcher who looked unready for the majors from earlier in the season. Rodriguez allowed two-out walks in both the first and second innings, and then in the third, he allowed a leadoff double to a 35-year-old catcher with a .439 OPS, another two-out walk and an RBI single. In the fourth, with two outs and no one on, he hit the 8- and 9-hitters and then allowed back-to-back singles to make it a 4-0 game.

6. Michael Fulmer relieved Rodriguez to end the fourth and then showed why he’s on his fourth team since last season when he gave up a pair of doubles and a single and threw a pickoff attempt away in the fifth.

After Fulmer, Luis Gil made his first appearance since April 26 and allowed one run over two innings. He did strike out three, threw 27 of 39 pitches for strikes and even threw 98 mph, so there was some promise there.

Then it was David Bednar’s turn. After pitching once in 10 days, Bednar ate up the eighth inning to get some work in and whether it was rust or him just going through the motions to get through the game, he allowed three earned runs on four hits in his inning.

7. It was the kind of game that happens over the course of 162 and the kind of game you throw away and immediately forget about … if you’re in the position the Rays are in, leading the division by five games in the loss column with 24 to play. But the Yankees aren’t in that position and throwing away a game against a crappy opponent (the actual shittiest opponent you can have in the majors this season) is why it’s hard to take them seriously as being alive in the division race. The Rays lost to the Mets and the Yankees had an opportunity to cut the lead to four games, meaning they could control their own division destiny with the four head-to-head games remaining against the Rays, and instead, they took the night off against a team with nothing to play for, a team counting down the days until their latest miserable season ends.

8. If George Lombard Jr. is ready to play, inserting him at shortstop is the only lineup change I would make for Tuesday. Keep Rice in the leadoff spot and keep Grisham fifth. At this point, to me, Jones is a better offensive and defensive alternative to Grisham, but I highly doubt the Yankees (who treat Grisham like Ken Griffey Jr.) are ready to make that determination. It takes a lot more than 118 games of piss-poor defense and being five percent worse than league average at the plate for the Yankees to pull the plug on someone they love internally. Jones has a better batting average, a better on-base percentage, a better slugging percentage, a better OPS, a better OPS+, has accumulated more WAR than Grisham and is actually above league average as a hitter, and the Yankees will choose not to accept that when Aaron Judge returns. Add in Jones’ overall speed (he’s the fastest Yankee) and his superior defense to Grisham, and there is no debate as to who should play when Judge returns.

9. It appears as though Judge will be activated for the next homestand, which begins next Tuesday against the Rockies, whose loss on Monday dropped them one game behind the Angels as the worst team in the majors. If Judge returns on September 9, he will have 19 available games to get ready for October. It’s obviously unlikely he will play all 19 since the Yankees will of course institute some asinine return plan for him like playing a full game in right field and then sitting the next game and then serving as the DH for the next game and then sitting the next game and then playing right field for a full game and so on. The Yankees believe they have figured out a scientific way to beat injuries, and yet, their load plans don’t prevent injuries because injuries happen. It’s idiotic to not play Judge as much as possible when he returns because if Judge is healthy enough to play then he should play every day. He needs at-bats with a limited number of games remaining before October.

10. I’ll worry about Judge’s load management next week. For now, I still somehow have to worry about the Angels, a team on pace for the 100-loss season in their franchise’s history. The Yankees have to sweep the Rays in September and play one game better than them in the other 20 games to win the division. That’s the path to the best record in the American League, home-field advantage throughout the playoffs and a first-round bye. It’s the best statistical and most favorable road to ending a championship drought that’s approaching 17 years. The Mets helped out the Yankees on Monday and the Yankees couldn’t help themselves. That needs to change against this opponent over the next two days.

1. Maybe Will Warren will go out and pitch the game of his life … or maybe the offense will explode for five or six early runs off Ranger Suarez and all this worrying will be for nothing. If neither of those things happens, it will have been a disappointing weekend that could set up a disappointing October.

That’s how I finished the Thoughts after the doubleheader. Warren pitched the best game of his career (lasting at least seven innings for just the third time in 63 career starts), the offense got to Suarez for six runs over 5 1/3, and instead of losing a game in the standings to the Red Sox and losing the head-to-head tiebreaker, the Yankees clinched the first wild card. Yes, that’s right: clinched.

2. With 25 games to play, the Yankees have a five-game lead over the Red Sox because of the tiebreaker. If the Yankees go a meager 13-12 in those games, the Red Sox would have to go 18-7 to pass the Yankees. With 12 of those games against the Angels, Rockies, Mets and Twins, Max Fried back and Aaron Judge expected back within the next two weeks, it’s hard to imagine the Yankees playing that poorly over the final month. (It’s also hard to imagine the Red Sox playing .720 baseball, considering they are 42-57 sandwiched around their historic hot streak.)

3. In the 16-1 win, the Yankees scored 11 runs against actual pitchers and then put up five runs against the Red Sox’ backup shortstop, including home runs from Austin Wells (who homered twice in the eighth inning) and Jose Caballero, both on 49-mph lobs. (Having position players pitch in blowout games is a disgrace. It’s sad that it’s “strategic” now. It’s not Wade Boggs coming in and dazzling with a knuckleball. It’s an embarrassment to the game.)

4. Before the game was a one-sided rout, Heliot Ramos had his first Yankees moment with a three-run home run in a five-run fifth inning. Ramos was in a position to have his big swing because of a controversial call ruled in the Yankees’ favor earlier in the inning. Caballero led off the inning with a single. Jazz Chisholm then hit a ball to center field that was ruled a trap by Ceddanne Rafaela to set up first and second with no outs. The Red Sox’ challenge was unsuccessful and the replay room allowed the call on the field to stand. After that, Ali Sanchez laid down a sacrifice bunt to move the runners over and Paul Goldschmidt hit a ground ball up the middle to score them both. Cody Bellinger singled and then Ramos broke the game open. The Yankees added a run in the sixth, one in the seventh and nine in the eighth.

5. The good news is the Yankees won the season series, have a five-game edge over the Red Sox and went 7-2 against the Red Sox around the four-game disaster at Fenway Park at the end of June. The bad news is the Yankees are going to have to play in the Wild Card Series against the Red Sox for a second straight season and possibly didn’t face a single starting pitcher the Red Sox would use in that series. I would expect the Red Sox to use Sonny Gray, Payton Tolle and Garrett Crochet (if he returns and is able to start). If not Crochet, then I guess it would be Jake Bennett, who shut the Yankees down on Friday, outside of the Goldschmidt home run.

6. No matter who ends up pitching, surviving a three-game series against the Red Sox is going to be as painful as it was last October and has been every time they have met in October outside of the 1999 ALCS. I’m not yet mentally, emotionally or physically prepared for it. The two teams have met six times in the playoffs — all in my lifetime — and both teams have advanced three times with the Yankees winning 14 games and the Red Sox winning 13 games.

7. And they are going to meet in October, because if I’m going to call the race for the first wild card over, I have to call the division over as well. I guess I already did that when I wrote the Thoughts titled Division Race About Done three weeks ago. At the time the Rays were 71-46 and the Yankees were 66-52. Since then, the Rays have gone 11-8 and the Yankees have gone 12-7. Three weeks and 19 games have come off the schedule and the Yankees have made up a single game. It’s just not going to happen unless the Rays lose something like 16 or more of their remaining 26 games.

8. The Padres blew a three-run lead in the seventh inning in a loss to the Rays on Saturday and then blew a two-run lead in the ninth inning on Sunday. It’s hard to be upset with the Padres for being shit when the Yankees couldn’t take care of their own business against the Rays this season (the Yankees are 3-6 against the Rays) or really anyone for two months, but the Yankees better sweep the Padres next weekend like the Rays just did this weekend.

9. So it’s looking like the Yankees’ postseason path in 2026 is going to be a lot like 2025: host the Red Sox for a three-game series, and if they survive that, they get to go on the road for the ALDS with their rotation out of whack to play an opponent they have trouble beating in a venue they have a hard time winning in. It’s less than ideal. That’s what happens when you don’t win the division. The Yankees’ only path now is to sweep the four-game series against the Rays in late September and play one game better than them in their other 21 games.

10. Next up is a West Coast trip to Anaheim and San Diego. Three straight 9:38 start times and a 9:40 start time. It’s going to be a long week of late nights, but it will be easier to handle if the Yankees can beat up on an Angels team that is the worst in all of baseball and a Padres team that just pooped their pants against the Rays. Couple that with the Mets and Rangers beating the Rays and I will gladly trade sleep to cut some games off the division deficit to begin September.