1. Against the reigning American League Cy Young winner, the Yankees opened Tuesday’s game with back-to-back singles. Tarik Skubal had struggled in his first two starts of the season, and it looked like the Yankees may be able to get to him early with the heart of the order due up and a chance to give Carlos Carrasco a lead before throwing a pitch.

Instead, Aaron Judge struck out after getting ahead in the count 2-0, Jazz Chisholm hit a weak ground ball back to the mound and Anthony Volpe had an ugly at-bat for an inning-ending strikeout, and that was the game. After that first-inning jam, Skubal looked like his 2024 self, retiring 16 straight until a Paul Goldschmidt single in the sixth.

2. “He’s as good as it gets,” Aaron Bone said. “He had a good day against us today.”

A good day from Skubal is to be expected. But Casey Mize also had a good day against the Yankees the day before and Andrew Heaney had a good day against them the day before that. Add up three consecutive days of a disappearing offense and bad starting pitching and you get a three-game losing streak, which has the Yankees a loss away from falling to .500.

3. During the six shutouts innings from Skubal, Carrasco got lit up. The Tigers scored one run off of him in the second and hit three solo home runs in the span of four batters in the fourth. He lasted just 4 1/3 innings and the Yankees trailed 4-0 when he left the mound in the fifth.

“It’s imperative that he really commands all of it,” Boone said of Carrasco. “He’s gotta be near the edges.”

Ryan Yarbrough relieved Carrasco and gave up a home run to the first batter he faced to make it 5-0, and that’s how it would stay for another Yankees loss.

4. The Tigers are a problem and a horrible matchup for the Yankees. It’s why before the series, I wrote: Had the Yankees played the Tigers in the ALCS, I think it would have been problematic given their pitching staff.

Between their strong rotation, deep pitching staff and experienced manager, they are very Rays-esque. The Rays have dominated the Yankees during the Boone era and the Tigers are starting do the same, having won the last four games against the Yankees dating back to last season. I fear them as much as any team in the AL, and in a short series in October, they would be a big problem.

4. Clarke Schmidt is expected to return to the rotation next week, and there is a debate about whether it will be Carrasco or Will Warren who loses their spot. The argument for Carrasco is that he doesn’t have a minor-league option like Warren does. Umm, who cares? It’s highly unlikely Carrasco will be claimed by another team, and if he is, who cares? Does anyone want him making another start for the Yankees? In three appearances (two starts) this season, he has put 19 baserunners on in 11 2/3 innings and has allowed 10 earned runs. No, don’t let the the guy with a 7.71 ERA and 1.628 WHIP this season (and 5.39 ERA since 2021) get claimed or elect free agency!

5. The Yankees’ 1-through-3 were 6-for-12 in the game. The 4-through-9 were 0-for-20.

Clean-up hitter Chisholm’s big weekend against the Brewers is starting to fade and he’s now down to .196/.260/.500. Austin Wells’ stats are no longer being propped up by homering in the first two games of the year as he’s down to .189/.279/.432. Jasson Dominguez has yet to get going aside from a few plate appearances and sits at .222/.317/.389, though if Volpe had Dominguez’s current .706 OPS during either of the last two seasons there would already be a plaque for him in Monument Park.

7. Cody Bellinger missed another game, this time with food poisoning. Bellinger has missed three of 11 games this year and when he has played he has been bad (.233/.278/.333). He is no way deserves to be hitting second or third before or after Judge in the lineup with the way Ben Rice and Trent Grisham have been hitting, but I expect to see him back in the lineup on Wednesday hitting second or third.

8. The Yankees have a problem right now in that Bellinger is always going to play, Dominguez needs to play, Grisham is tearing the cover off of the ball and Rice is the team’s second-best hitter after Judge. You can’t sit Rice right now. You shouldn’t sit Grisham. But because none of those four play third base, someone has to sit. It may be time for Rice to start taking ground balls at third? Maybe he already is or already has? Maybe he has and he sucked at it? All I know is the Yankees are wasting a lineup spot with whichever third baseman of the day they choose and are putting someone on the bench that shouldn’t be on the bench at the moment..

9. The Yankees will face Jack Flaherty in the series finale. The last time the Yankees saw Flaherty, they chased him in the second inning of Game 5 of the World Series. Flaherty has been very good in his first two starts of the season, and given the way the Yankees offense has hit the last three days, it’s hard to feel confident with them at the moment. It’s also hard not to think they will be thinking about an afternoon getaway day game and returning home tonight with tomorrow off.

10. The series finale is the kind of start the Yankees got Max Fried for. Three straight losses and a matchup against an unimpressive offense. This is a game the Yankees need to Fried to go out there and hand the ball off to Luke Weaver and then Devin Williams with no one in between and salvage the final game of the series and road trip.

1. If a starting pitcher allows five earned runs in six innings, it equates to a 7.50 ERA. There isn’t a person who should think that’s acceptable, especially if the pitcher is making roughly $800,000 per start. But there’s one.

“I thought he threw the ball great,” Aaron Boone said of Carlos Rodon’s disastrous start in Detroit, “I really did.”

2. Last week at Yankee Stadium, Zac Gallen (6.2 IP, 3 H, 0 R, 0 ER, 0 BB, 13 K) “threw the ball great.” Ex-Yankee Andrew Heaney on Sunday against the Yankees (7 IP, 5 H, 1 R, 1 ER, 1 BB, 10 K) “threw the ball great.” Tigers starter Casey Mize on Monday against the Yankees (6 IP, 4 H, 1 R, 1 ER, 3 BB, 6 K) “threw the ball great.” What Rodon did on Monday wasn’t “great.” It was abysmal. It was the type of performance Rodon has given as a Yankees more often than not.

3. “Look, he doesn’t get a call in that inning and makes the one mistake that turns into a three-run homer,” Boone said. “But really outside of that I thought he was excellent.”

Ah yes, outside of the three-run homer that decided the game, Rodon was excellent. Even if outside of the home run he allowed two other earned runs to score and an unearned one. Six runs and five earned in six innings: the definition of excellence.

4. The whining about the missed third strike call in the third inning is embarrassing. Rodon got countless fastballs outside the strike zone called in his favor early in the game. When he didn’t get a 3-2 pitch called his way in his third, it set up first and second with one out for the Tigers. (The 8- and 9-hitters were on first and second, both from walks.) Rodon bounced back to get the second out of the inning on a strikeout. He was one out away from getting out of the inning and couldn’t get it.

5. “We roll that Carlos every time,” Boone said, “we’re going to be in a good spot.”

If the Yankees allow a run per inning every start they’re going to be in a good spot? What? They did that on Monday and lost. They did it on Sunday and lost. They did it on Saturday and were fortunate the offense showed up.

6. “I thought he did a lot of really good things,” Boone said. “I thought he was in control of the game.”

Why was he in control? Because he had eight strikeouts in six innings against a weak offense? He certainly didn’t look in control when he walked the 8- and 9-hitters to start the Tigers’ third-inning rally. He didn’t look in control when he gave up the three-run home run to Andy Ibanez. He didn’t look in control when he walked the 8-hitter again in the fifth and allowed two runs to score immediately after the Yankees had gotten on the board.

In Rodon’s last start, we had to hear about how the rain and weather affected him, while Gallen tossed an all-time gem. Today, it was the wind chill impacting Rodon, while Mize continued to get out after out. There’s always an excuse with him. The weather, heckling fans, a mound visit he didn’t want, a pitch that didn’t get called his way.

7. Rodon was bad on Monday, which he usually is, but even if he had been better, it likely wouldn’t have mattered because a day after getting humiliated by Heaney in Pittsburgh, the offense gave themselves a day off in Detroit.

“I thought we were very close there to really putting together a couple of big innings,” Boone said of his offense as each delusional answer he provided Meredith Marakovits one-upped his previous one.

That will be a good name for the Boone autobiography about his time as Yankees manager whenever his time in the position ends (if it ever does).

“‘I Thought We Were Very Close:’ My Time as Yankees Manager” by Aaron Boone with Andy Martino, foreword by Brian Cashman.

8. Ben Rice reached base three times (but was also inexplicably picked off third), Aaron Judge had an RBI single and a walk and Paul Goldschmidt had two hits. Those were the offensive highlights. The Yankees had seven hits in the game and one for extra bases. Jazz Chisholm, Anthony Volpe and Austin Wells at 5-6-7 combined to go 1-for-12 with five strikeouts. Cody Bellinger continued his early-season failures with runners on and Oswaldo Cabrera went 0-for-4 after being bench the last two games following his three-hit game on Friday. Jasson Dominguez didn’t play because the only prospect to get to play every day from the moment he reached the league (despite horrific results) in this era has been Volpe.

9. The Yankees’ offense scored one run and the Tigers’ defense gave them another. They were shut down by Mize, and three relievers, with Tommy Kahnle being the last of those three. Sure enough, Kahnle pitched a 1-2-3 ninth to close out the game and striking out two, while successfully mixing his fastball and changeup, after only using his changeup for an extended period of time in October, which ultimately led to the Yankees’ demise in Game 5 of the World Series. A memorable performance on consecutive days for ex-Yankees Heaney, Kahnle, Dennis Santana, Caleb Ferguson and Isiah Kiner-Falefa.

10. The Yankees couldn’t hit Casey Mize and now they get to face the reigning AL Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal on Tuesday. Carlos Carrasco will go for the Yankees in what is the biggest discrepancy in starting pitching ability you can have in a matchup this season. Aside from the ninth inning on Sunday, the offense has taken the last two days off. It would be nice if it decides to return to work on Tuesday.

1. On Friday, before the Yankees opened a three-game season in Pittsburgh, I wrote: Anything less than a series win (especially with Paul Skenes not pitching), would be a disappointment. The series wasn’t a disappointment and was successful because the Yankees did win it, but it could have been and (nearly was) so much more if they had completed their three-run, ninth-inning comeback on Sunday and finished the job with a sweep.

2. The Yankees received one strong starting pitching effort in the series and that came from Max Fried on Friday (5.2 IP, 6 H, 1 R, 1 ER, 1 BB, 6 K, 1 HR). It felt like Fried wasn’t even that good, and yet, he allowed one run over 5 1/3 innings. It’s exciting to think about how good Fried will be when he’s “on” in one of his starts, which he certainly wasn’t on Opening Day and really wasn’t against the Pirates.

Fried was the beneficiary of 20 runs from his offense in the second game of the season, and he got more than enough run support again on Friday in the Yankees’ 9-4 win.

“It’s been incredible, especially the early runs,” Fried said. “It takes a lot off me, where I know that I can be a little more aggressive and go after guys.”

Fried is the last pitcher on the Yankees who needs run support. Marcus Stroman, on the other hand, could use all the help he can get.

3. After being bad against the Brewers last weekend (4.2 IP, 5 H, 3 R, 3 ER, 1 BB, 3 K, 1 HR), Stroman was even worse against the Pirates (4 IP, 3 H, 4 R, 4 ER, 3 BB, 3 K). In two starts, he’s pitched 8 2/3 innings, allowing seven earned runs for a nice, tidy 7.27 ERA.

In his start on Saturday, after giving back a two-run lead and then some with four runs against in the fourth, he was saved by a six-run outburst from the offense the following inning. I thought with a four-run lead Aaron Boone would send Stroman back out for the fifth to try to squeeze every last out of him, but instead, he did the right thing and pulled him, preventing further damage and the Yankees were able to coast to a 10-4 win.

I don’t think Boone pulled Stroman because he recognized it as the smart thing to do to win the game. I think he pulled him because the Yankees are going to do everything they can to prevent Stroman’s innings clause for 2026 from kicking in. If Stroman throws 140 innings this season, he is guaranteed $18 million for next season. With 8 2/3 innings through two starts, Stroman is on pace for 139 innings if he were to make 32 starts. For as bad as he has been, there is a very realistic path to him reaching that number even with four- and 4 2/3-innings starts. That means Boone will always have a short leash and an early hook for Stroman this season, and that’s a good thing.

4. Will Warren had himself a Stroman-esque start on Sunday: 4 IP, 6 H, 4 ER, 4 R, 1 BB, 5 K. Warren retired the first eight batters of the game before unraveling in the fourth.

“There was a lot of good in there,” Boone said of Warren, “mixed with little spots where he lost it.”

I would say it was a big spot where he lost it: with two outs and no one on in the fourth. From that moment on, Warren went walk, single, double, single, strikeout, groundout, triple, sacrifice fly, single, double, strikeout. I thought Warren was going to be good and then he walked Isiah Kiner-Falefa (who doesn’t walk) with two outs to start the third-inning rally and let Kiner-Falefa crush a first-pitch, RBI double to the gap in the fourth.

Kiner-Falefa wasn’t the only ex-Yankee to have big day against his former team, keeping up with a tradition that seemingly will never end (except for Nestor Cortes in the second game of the season, though Cortes is now on the injured list with the same injury that kept him out for most of September and most of October last season before Boone decided he was the best option to try to get Freddie Freeman out in Game 1 of the World Series). Joining Kiner-Falefa in the series finale was the pitching trio of Andrew Heaney, Dennis Santana and Caleb Ferguson, all former Yankees pitchers who were all designated for assignment by the team. Heaney had a 7.32 ERA in 35 2/3 innings as a Yankee, Santana had a 6.26 in 27 1/3 innings and Ferguson had a 5.13 in 33 1/3 innings. The trio combined to throw nine innings of one-run ball in the Yankees’ 5-4, 11-inning loss on Sunday.

5. The Yankees’ issues with left-handed pitching have been pronounced through nine games as every opposing manager is doing what he can to throw as many lefties as possible against the Yankees. This isn’t a small sample size issue either. When you can’t hit Heaney (who struck out 10 over seven innings) and Ferguson (who pitched around the automatic runner against the heart of the order in the 10th), it’s a big-time problem.

After staging an improbable comeback down three runs in the ninth, the Yankees were set up to take the lead in the 10th with Cody Bellinger, Aaron Judge and Jazz Chisholm due up. They had used Luke Weaver in the eighth, had him available for a second inning, if needed, and also had Devin Williams available. The extra-inning setup was heavily advantageous for them. And they pissed it away.

With the automatic runner (Paul Goldschmidt) on second to start the 10th, Bellinger got ahead of Ferguson 3-0. If Bellinger were to walk, the Pirates would be forced to pitch to Judge. Bellinger took the 3-0 pitch down the middle and then swung at a slider low, away and in the other batter’s box for strike 2. It was a selfish, undisciplined swing decision from Bellinger. Now at 3-2, he would need to at least put the ball in play to move Goldschmidt to third. He did that, but the Pirates, as expected, sent Judge to first.

Then came Chisholm, who is about the last Yankee you want up in a situational hitting scenario. After putting himself in a hole, Chisholm eventually put the ball in play, but it was a weak flare just past the infield that was easily catchable and too shallow for Goldschmidt to tag up on. Anthony Volpe ended the inning with a groundout.

6. Weaver made quick work of the Pirates in the 10th, but the Yankees couldn’t capitalize on a Pirates error in the 11th with the automatic runner on third and one out. In the bottom of the 11th, the Pirates stole third with one out against Williams, and idiotically Boone let Williams pitch to Tommy Pham, the Pirates one veteran hitter, with first and second base open and Pham hit the ball to left field for the walk-off win.

“It was a little bit of a tough day for us offensively,” Boone said, but what a great rally there in the ninth to get us back into it.”

It was a great rally, ruined by the Yankees’ situational hitting in extras. There’s a reason the Yankees have been one of the league’s worst teams in extra innings since the automatic runner was implemented five years ago: a combination of bad situational hitters and an uninspiring manager. The Pirates stole third with one out in the 11th, knowing they were unlikely to get a hit off of Williams to win the game. The Yankees? They waited around for a hit that never came and wasn’t going to come once Judge was intentionally walked.

7. Williams’ numbers were so good with the Brewers that he had become the best reliever in baseball, at least on paper. But so far, as a Yankee, he has been extremely underwhelming. Maybe that’s because it’s not ideal to have your closer’s best pitch be a changeup. He gets a pass for now, considering his Opening Day debacle was his first appearance with his new team in freezing weather, then he missed time with the birth of his child, and had a long layoff. I expected him to be more unhittable than he has been, and not Tommy Kahnle 2.0.

8. Trent Grisham has been Juan Soto 2.0 through the first week-and-a-half of the season. Grisham is hitting .455/.538/.909 with three home runs, nine RBIs, three walks and only four strikeouts. He homered twice on Saturday and drove in the game-tying runs in the ninth on Sunday. He has already passed Alex Verdugo’s 2024 season in terms of WAR despite this season being only six percent complete and despite Grisham having only started only five of the Yankees’ nine games.

9. After a big first two games as a Yankee, Bellinger is 2-for-19 with six strikeouts sandwiched around missing a couple of games with a stiff back on Friday and Saturday. In the last four games hitting in front of Judge, he’s 2-for-16 with two walks and seven strikeouts. The Yankees are 1-3 in those games. If you’re going to hit in front of Judge, you have to hit, especially since you’re getting pitches to hit.

10. It would be good if Bellinger started hitting in Detroit because the Yankees are going to need him. They are going to need all of the offense they can get (and will continue to need it until Clarke Schmidt and Luis Gil return) as they face Casey Mize (5 2/3 shutout innings in his first start this season), Tarik Skubal (reigning Cy Young winner) and Jack Flaherty (typically tough except for Game 5 of the World Series) over the next three frigid afternoons. They will counter with Carlos Rodon (5.48 ERA in 13 career starts against the Tigers), Carlos Carrasco (I don’t think anyone will ever feel good about him starting) and Max Fried (the Yankees’ only trustworthy starter).

The Yankees struggled with Detroit last season and then the Tigers miraculously made the playoffs, knocked off the Astros and took the Guardians to do-or-die Game 5 before their season ended. The Tigers paved the path to the World Series for the Yankees. (Had the Yankees played the Tigers in the ALCS, I think it would have been problematic given their pitching staff.) This is going to be a tough series.

1. Last July, in the middle of their annual midseason free fall, the Yankees were swept at home in a three-game series by the Reds. It was the first time the Yankees were swept at home by a National League team in a series of at least three games in the history of interleague play. (Another nice highlight for Aaron Boone’s managerial résumé.) On Thursday, the Yankees were faced with the possibility of being swept at home by an NL team for the second time in as many seasons after having never been from 1997 through 2023.

“We don’t get swept at home,” Giancarlo Stanton reportedly told the Yankees clubhouse before Thursday’s series (and season) finale against the Diamondbacks (apparently forgetting about last season’s Reds series). And they didn’t. But their manager, his bullpen management and the back end of their bullpen tried their hardest to.

2. The Yankees took a 3-0 lead in the first inning before making an out, thanks to an Aaron Judge three-run home run. The lead was extended to 4-0 in the opening inning after a Jasson Dominguez single and Trent Grisham double.

Carlos Carrasco gave a run back in the second, but the Yankees got that run back and more when Grisham hit a two-run home run to give them a 6-1 lead through three. Carrasco allowed two in the top half of the fourth, but again the Yankees responded in the bottom half of the inning with a Judge RBI single and a Jazz Chisholm two-run home run to make it 9-3. A six-run lead through four with a well-rested bullpen? Not even Boone could screw this up, but he would try.

3. Carrasco was pulled with one out in the sixth and Adam Ottavino got the last two outs of the inning to preserve the 9-3 lead. In the seventh, the game began to unravel.

Ryan Yarbrough relieved Ottavino for the seventh. He began his night by walking the Diamondbacks’ 8 and 9 hitters. Corbin Carroll followed with a base hit to load the bases with no outs. Yarbrough had thrown 15 pitches and only six for strikes. He had loaded the bases with no outs for the heart of the Diamondbacks’ order. He had faced the minimum three batters and could be removed from the game. Boone decided to stick with the pitcher the Yankees signed three days before Opening Day after he opted out of his minor-league deal with the Blue Jays believing Yarbrough was about to find “it” and turn his night around. Yarbrough allowed a grand slam to the next batter, Geraldo Perdomo.

4. The Yankees’ 9-3 lead was now 9-7 with still no one out in the seventh. Boone decided not retiring any of the four batters Yarbrough faced while allowing four runs wasn’t as bad as it was, so he stayed with him until he recorded a couple of outs. Then Boone called on Mark Leiter Jr. to get the last out of the inning.

The Yankees’ six-run lead had been cut to two, but with a more-than-rested Luke Weaver available, certainly Boone would go to his best (available) reliever (with Devin Williams still on paternity leave) for two innings. Six outs from Weaver would be more than doable since Boone passed on using him in a similar situation on Tuesday and because Weaver hadn’t been used in a week since Opening Day last Thursday.

5. When the eighth began, Leiter Jr. was still on the mound and Weaver was still in the bullpen. Was Weaver hurt and the Yankees weren’t announcing it? Was Boone trying to save him for only the ninth like he regrettably had two nights prior? What the fuck was going on?

After Leiter Jr. allowed a two-out base hit to bring the tying run to the plate, Boone called for Weaver. So Boone was willing to go to Weaver for four outs, but not before Leiter Jr. brought the tying run to the plate. If Boone was willing to go to Weaver for four outs (which he did), why didn’t he come into the game after Leiter Jr. got the second out of the inning? Stealing outs, that’s why. In Year 8 of Boone as manager, he’s still managing like he’s making his managerial debut in Toronto eight years ago.

6. Unsurprisingly, Weaver retired pinch-hitter Gabriel Moreno to end the eighth and then pitched a 1-2-3 ninth to prevent the Yankees from being swept by the Diamondbacks and from falling to .500. (If only Boone had used Weaver two nights early in a situation that called for Weaver rather than a set inning, the Yankees may be 5-1 right now instead of 4-2.)

7. “We never exhale,” Judge said. “We’ve seen that too many times in this game, where you score early and a team answers right back. That’s been our thing at the beginning of this year: Don’t let off the gas.” Keep scoring until you get that final out.”

Judge knows the team can’t exhale with Boone’s bullpen management. No lead is safe with Boone pushing the buttons. This new mantra from the Yankees must be from what unfolded after they took a 5-0 lead in Game 5 of the World Series.

For any Yankees fan who want to blame Yarbrough for the grand slam rather than Boone for sticking with him after he loaded the bases, you’re a fool. This wasn’t Boone sticking with an elite relief option. This was Boone sticking with a reliever who couldn’t get a major-league offer in the offseason and then became a Yankee at the end of spring training because of the litany of injuries to the pitching staff.

8. To Boone’s credit, he did put together a lineup that generated nine runs, even if four of those runs were driven in by Judge and penciling Judge into the lineup is as automatic as Boone stealing outs late in a close game. But Boone did slot Ben Rice in the leadoff spot and he doubled, walked twice and scored two runs, and he played Grisham and he went 3-for-4 with a double, home run and three RBIs.

9. A year ago to the day (April 3), Merrill Kelly pitched well against the Yankees in Arizona (7 IP, 5 H, 2 R, 2 ER, 1 BB, 4 K, 1 HR), but in this one he was atrocious: 3.2 IP, 9 H, 9 R, 9 ER, 3 BB, 2 K, 3 HR. Carrasco was “fine” for Carrasco (5.1 IP, 5 H, 3 R, 3 ER, 2 BB, 5 K) and pitched about as well as any Yankees fan could ask for at this stage of his career. If he can hold the damage to three runs in five-plus innings per start for as long as he’s here, the team will be OK in games he starts. The next time he will get the ball is on Tuesday in Detroit.

Before then, the Yankees will play three against the Pirates in Pittsburgh as part of their first road trip of the season. Thankfully, they’ll miss Paul Skenes in the series (though they will see Tarik Skubal next week).

10. The Pirates are horrible. They are off to a 2-5 start with a negative-12 run differential and it’s highly likely they never see .500 again this season. Anthony Volpe has as many home runs (4) as the entire Pirates roster and the Yankees scored more runs in eight innings last Saturday (20) than the Pirates have scored in seven games (18). This is the type of team contenders beat up on, which the Yankees believe they are. Actually, this is the type of team every team beats up on, as the also-lowly Marlins took three of four from them to begin the season. Anything less than a series win (especially with Skenes not pitching), would be a disappointment.

1. Yesterday, following Tuesday’s first loss of the season, I wrote:

The Yankees can never just lose. By “just lose” I mean get blown out, shut down, shut out, never have a chance in the game. They either win, blow a game late, bring the tying run to the plate in the ninth, have an abundance of blown opportunities to tie or take the lead, or suffer a painful, excruciating loss. Yes, it keeps every game entertaining and means the Yankees are “in” every game, but at the same time, their losses and the way they lose always seem to be extremely detrimental to the health and wellbeing of their fans.

I finished yesterday’s Thoughts with this:

If the Yankees don’t get back in the win column on Wednesday or Thursday, I’m sure it will come as the result of an agonizing loss. That’s the only way they lose.

The Yankees lost a second straight game on Wednesday, and sure enough, it was the type of loss where they drag you back in in the ninth by bringing the tying run to the plate only to lose anyway.

2. For the first eight-and-a-half innings on Wednesday, the Yankees’ 4-3 loss to the Diamondbacks was shaping up to be a “Get ’em tomorrow” kind of game. Carlos Rodon was brutal in the first two innings, staking the Diamondbacks to a 4-0 lead, and Zac Gallen was masterful for 6 2/3 innings, completely stifling the Yankees’ bats, both standard and torpedo.

It was exactly a year to the day (April 2) that Gallen shut down the 2024 Yankees in Arizona: 6 IP, 3 H, 0 R, 0 ER, 3 BB, 6 K. But he was even better against the 2025 Yankees on Wednesday: 6.2 IP, 3 H, 0 R, 0 ER, 0 BB, 13 K. Combine those two lines and you get 12.2 IP, 6 H, 0 R, 0 ER, 3 BB, 19 K. That is a Cliff Lee-against-the-Yankees line.

“It will be a game we will look back on,” Aaron Boone said. “He was just dialed in. He had both breaking balls going. The changeup was working. He was moving the fastball around.”

So based on that summarization, Gallen was … pitching? Using two two breaking balls?! Throwing an effective changeup?! Moving around the fastball?! He was … doing his job? Something Rodon didn’t do in the game until it was too late.

3. Gallen kept the Yankees’ bats off balance the entire night, consistently getting swings and misses on his curveball and changeup. It was frustrating to watch his dominance as he became the first pitcher in history to strike out 13 Yankees without allowing a walk for a win.

The strikeouts didn’t end with Gallen. In 2 1/3 innings of relief, the Diamondbacks’ bullpen added three more for a game total of 16. Add those 16 to the 13 from the previous night and the Yankees struck out 29 times over the last two nights. Twenty-nine! TWENTY-NINE! Over two games, they struck out the equivalent of a full game of outs plus two more outs. That’s the thing about the torpedo bats: they only work when you make contact.

4. Austin Wells was the only Yankee to not strike out, while Aaron Judge, Jasson Dominguez and Ben Rice all picked up hat tricks at the plate. I wasn’t OK with the Yankees’ offensive effort, especially after they mustered only three non-error-aided runs the night before, but I was OK with them losing the way it seemed like they were going to lose rather than giving fans hope they may stage a late comeback. And then they went and tried to stage a late comeback.

5. After making a three-run lead stand up on Tuesday, A.J. Puk took the mound with a four-run lead on Wednesday. Cody Bellinger and Aaron Judge greeted him with singles, but Jazz Chisholm flew out for the first out. Then Anthony Volpe torpedo’d the first pitch he saw just over the wall of the short porch for a three-run home run. Suddenly, the Yankees’ four-run deficit was one.

In that situation I wish Volpe had singled, or walked, or doubled. If Volpe had loaded the bases with one out, or had driven in a run with still two on, I would have liked the Yankees’ chances more. I under statistically that’s wrong, but the math doesn’t account for the human element of Puk having to deal with runners on base and increased pressure. Once Volpe cleared the bases, it allowed a Puk to reset, and he got Wells to pop up and struck out Dominguez to end the game.

6. Never a normal loss. That’s what I wrote after Tuesday’s loss, and it proved true again on Wednesday. The Yankees couldn’t just go down quietly in the ninth. They had to make you momentarily believe they could do to the Diamondbacks what the Diamondbacks had done to them the previous night. They had to make you start playing the “what if” game from the earlier innings. Like what if the Yankees hadn’t stranded runners on second and third with one out in the second? What if Rodon hadn’t thrown 92-mph meatballs in the first two innings? Unfortunately, they did strand those runners, and unfortunately, Rodon was awful in the first two innings.

7. “[Early in the game] maybe it was just a little weather-related, a little cooler and stuff,” Aaron Boone said of Rodon’s performance. “[Rodon] was searching to find the strike zone a little bit there in those first couple of innings, but I thought stuff-wise, once he settled in, he was pretty good.”

YES also talked about Rodon being affected by the weather in the first two innings. Oddly, Gallen didn’t have any issue with the weather. Rodon has spent his career pitching for the White Sox, Giants and Yankees, all teams that are exposed to the elements and all teams that have games at the beginning and end of seasons in poor weather. Gallen has only ever pitched for the Marlins and Diamondbacks, in controlled climates, where weather isn’t a factor.

It’s nice that Boone thought Rodon had “pretty good” stuff “once he settled in.” Once he settled in the Yankees were down four runs against once of the game’s best pitchers. It was the type of performance we have seen from Rodon so many times where he puts the team in an early hole and then figures it out once it’s too late. I guess being able to regrow facial hair wasn’t the key to unlocking the White Sox and Giants version of Rodon.

8. It was a bad night at the plate for everyone other than Wells (single, double, only Yankee to not strike out) and Volpe (three-run home run). I understand Wells hasn’t led off since Opening Day because Boone says the Yankees have faced reverse-split starters since then, but it didn’t seem to matter which hand any of the Yankees used to bat against Gallen on Wednesday. As for Volpe, he has four hits this season and all are home runs. He batted seventh on Opening Day, and then after homering in that game, he has batted fifth since. Being the Golden Boy of the organization is nice.

I could see Wells sitting for the first time of the season on Thursday. I could also see Paul Goldschmidt sitting since Michael Kay said as much on the broadcast, opining, “In all likelihood — he’s played all five games — probably gets tomorrow off,” in regard to Goldschmidt. I’m sure Kay knows something. No Wells and no Goldschmidt would mean the Yankees would need to use a third leadoff hitter for their sixth game of the year.

9. It will be Merrill Kelly against Carlos Carrasco on Wednesday in the series finale. Kelly was good in his first start of the season and was good against the Yankees on April 3 of last year: 7 IP, 5 H, 2 R, 2 ER, 1 BB, 4 K, 1 HR. (It’s crazy both Gallen and Kelly will face the Yankees on the same dates in consecutive seasons.)

I don’t have a lot of confidence in Carrasco. He was good enough to win a roster spot on the team in spring training, helped by the excessive injuries to the Yankees’ staff, but he was horrible in two innings of relief against the Brewers. Do you think Carrasco is the guy who pitched well in fake games in March, or the guy who a 5.36 ERA over his last 401 1/3 innings dating back to 2021? I don’t expect much from Carrasco. I don’t expect anything. I expect Carrasco to make Rodon’s performance from Wednesday feel like Gallen’s based on how I think Carrasco is going to fare on Thursday.

10. Carrasco is pitching for his career at this point. He’s already in line to be a DFA candidate once (if) the Yankees’ pitching gets healthy. Maybe that’s enough for him to turn back the clock five-plus years. It wasn’t when he pitched on Saturday. It needs to be on Thursday, or the offense is going to have to show up after taking the last two nights off. Otherwise, all of the runs, all of the home runs, all of the winning from the weekend will be undone and the Yankees will be sitting at .500.