fbpx

Yankees

BlogsYankeesYankees Thoughts

Yankees Thoughts: Brian Cashman Leaving Season Up to “Hope”

The Yankees played on Tuesday and that means their season loss total increased by one. Here are 10 thoughts on the Yankees. 1. It takes a lot for Brian Cashman to join the Yankees on

The Yankees played on Tuesday and that means their season loss total increased by one.

Here are 10 thoughts on the Yankees.

1. It takes a lot for Brian Cashman to join the Yankees on the road, and losing 16 of their last 22 games entering Tuesday certainly constitutes as a lot.

“Thankfully, we got out of the gates really strong,” Cashman said at Tropicana Field before Tuesday’s game. “Hopefully that cushion will allow us to work through this. Hopefully sooner than later because it’s gone on long enough.”

Whenever you’re using the word “hopefully” to discuss your baseball season, you’re screwed, and Cashman used the word twice in 11 words. You would think more than $300 million in salaries could buy you more than hope, but that’s all it has gotten Cashman. It’s all he has gotten after incorrectly spending more than $3 billion in salaries since the Yankees’ last World Series appearance.

2. Cashman could do something other than “hope” the season will turn around. He could replace his manager and try to remove the comfortable-with-losing stench Aaron Boone has covered the Yankees’ winning tradition with. But he won’t. That would go against “the process” Cashman has frequently mentioned in recent years as an excuse for his team’s shortcomings. It would go against his belief that the process is more important than the results, which he said at his end-of-the-season press conference in 2022.

“It’s been a tough stretch for us,” Cashman added.

If by “stretch” Cashman means the entirety of the Boone era, then yes, it’s been a tough “stretch.” Unfortunately, that’s not what Cashman meant. He was referring to just the last month. In fact, he didn’t hesitate to praise the work Boone has done this season, saying his manager has navigated this collapse “as well as he possibly can.”

3. Not only did Cashman defend his handpicked manager’s leadership during a third straight disastrous mid-June collapse, he doesn’t think this season is any way like the last two.

“I think every year is different,” Cashman said. “I think those teams are different and some of the issues are different.”

What? WHAT? WHAT?! Like Mugatu yelling about Zoolander’s faces, THEY’RE THE SAME THING! Blue Steel? Ferrari? Le Tigre? 2022? 2023? 2024? THEY’RE THE SAME THING!

Each Yankees season is a continuation of the previous season. This season is a continuation of 2023 and 2023 was a continuation of 2022 and so on. The collapses have been the same. The offensive issues have been the same. The oft-injured players inevitably getting injured are the same. The underperforming players are the same. When you run it back with the same front office, same manager and essentially the same roster over and over, you get the same result. This collapse isn’t an anomaly. It’s not part of the ebb and flow of the baseball season like Boone likes to say. It’s expected. It’s part of who these Yankees are.

4. Cashman’s presence at the Trop on Tuesday did nothing to stop the Yankees from free falling into nothing as they lost again. After they scored a first-inning run on a Gleyber Torres RBI single, the thought the game may play out differently than nearly every game for the past month may have entered your mind. Then Carlos Rodon walked to the mound.

Two batters and seven pitches into Rodon’s night, the Yankees lead was gone and the game was tied at 1. Two batters and seven more pitches from Rodon, and the Yankees trailed by three runs and the remaining eight-plus innings were just a formality in leading the Yankees to their 17th loss in their last 23 games.

5. “It has not been fun, that’s for sure,” Rodon said. “I’m just not really giving my team a chance to win, giving up runs early.”

The Yankees have lost each of Rodon’s last four starts, and in those games, he has put 41 baserunners on in 19 innings, pitching to a 10.89 ERA and 2.053 WHIP. Opposing hitters are batting .356/.423/.713 against him for a 1.135 OPS. For reference, Aaron Judge has the highest OPS in the majors at 1.103, so opposing hitters are collectively the best hitter in the game against Rodon.

6. It was always going to be extremely difficult to like Rodon as a Yankee after his first season with the team when he came to spring training unfocused and possibly out of shape, got hurt before Opening Day and said he would be pitching if it were the playoffs then missed the first half of the season, pitched to a 6.85 ERA over 14 starts, blew a kiss to heckling fans, turned his back on the pitching coach and gave up eight runs without recording an out in his final start of the season. With what has gone on with him this season, I can’t envision ever being a fan of his as a Yankee.

7. Rodon allowed four runs on Tuesday before recording an out didn’t stop his manager from supporting the lefty (who makes roughly $800,000 per start).

“Once he gets settled he’s got a lot of ways of getting you out,” Boone said.

Rodon has a 9.00 ERA on the season in the first inning. He loses each game for the Yankees before they have a chance to bat at home or before they have a chance to bat for a second time on the road. But hey, once he gets settled, watch out!

8. Rodon’s next start will come on Sunday in Baltimore in the final game before the All-Star break. He faced the Orioles in Baltimore on May 2 and allowed six earned runs on eight hits, including three home runs and the Yankees lost 7-2. You can put the Yankees down for a loss this Sunday in Baltimore.

Since the Yankees already lost on Tuesday and are likely to lose on Sunday with Rodon pitching again, that means they would have to win the next four games to post a winning road trip. The last time the Yankees won two games in a row was June 11 and June 12. Today is July 10.

9. With “hope” being Cashman’s solution to the season, the best the Yankees can “hope” for on this six-game trip to Tampa and Baltimore is to go 3-3, and even then it’s not exactly promising. A 3-3 trip would keep them running in place while the Red Sox keep winning and the Orioles gradually increase their separation. On June 12, the Yankees had a 2 1/2-game lead over the Orioles and a 14-game lead over the Red Sox. Today, the Yankees trail the Orioles by four games in the loss column and their 14-game lead over the Red Sox is down to two games in the loss column.

10. The stuffing in the “cushion” Cashman spoke about is bursting at the seams. The Yankees are a bad rest of this road trip from being buried in the division race and from hanging on to a postseason berth. The team Cashman said is “pretty fucking good” during his unhinged tirade over the winter is anything but. For the last month, they’ve been pretty fucking bad, and the “hope” they will magically turn it around is fading by the day.

Read More

BlogsYankeesYankees Thoughts

Yankees Thoughts: ‘It’s All Right There in Front of Us’

The Yankees lost another game and another series and their season is collapsing. Here are 10 thoughts on the Yankees. 1. “We had chances to grab that game, take that game. We didn’t,” Aaron Boone

The Yankees lost another game and another series and their season is collapsing.

Here are 10 thoughts on the Yankees.

1. “We had chances to grab that game, take that game. We didn’t,” Aaron Boone said. “And that’s where we are right now, and it’s really difficult right now.”

“We gotta play better period,” Boone continued. “And the great thing is it’s right in front of us. It’s right here and we can fix it. It’s right here. It’s there and we can run away with this thing. And we got the dudes in there to do it.”

“If we don’t score,” Boone added, “tough to win.”

Boone said none of that after Sunday night’s 3-0 loss to the Red Sox. He did say all of that on Aug. 20, 2022 with the Yankees’ season in the type of free fall Tom Petty sang about. But you wouldn’t know Boone said that nearly two years ago and not this weekend because his summarization of the Yankees’ situation is the same today as it was then.

2. What Boone did say after losing yet another series was, “It’s all right there in front of us.” It was the same line he used in that Aug. 20, 2022 meltdown when he slammed the table with his right hand while saying it. It’s not the only other time he said it.

Aug. 20, 2022: “It’s right in front of us.”

July 15, 2023: “It’s all there right in front of us.”

July 7, 2024: “It’s all right there in front of us.”

For three straight seasons the Yankees have endured a mid-June collapse, and for three straight seasons, the man leading the team has regurgitated the same tired line.

The 2022 Yankees were 61-23 and then went 38-40.

The 2023 Yankees were 36-25 and then went 46-55.

The 2024 Yankees were 50-22. They are now 55-37, having gone 5-15 in their last 20 games.

When Brian Cashman gave up on Sonny Gray after 2018 and traded him away for nothing, he said, “I don’t feel like we can go through the same exercise and expect different results.” But when it comes to the person responsible for in-game management and creating a winning culture, Cashman is completely fine with living the same season over and over.

3. This week will be a month since the Yankees last won a series. It’s now been more than a month since they won a home series. And after this 1-5 homestand against the Reds and Red Sox, Boone has added some more glowing accomplishments to his impressive resume:

– Only Yankees manager to get a fifth season on the job without a championship (and now a sixth and seventh season)

– Manager for the most lopsided home postseason loss in franchise history (Game 3 of the 2018 ALDS)

– Manager for the worst single-month record in 33 years

– Manager for the worst season record in 31 years

– Manager for the most steals allowed in a single game by franchise in 109 years

– Manager for the first three-plus-game-series sweep by NL team at Yankee Stadium in franchise history

– Manager for the first Yankees team to lose five straight home series in 34 years

– Manager for the first time in Yankees history the team allowed 35-plus home runs and had a losing record over any 16-game span

– Manager for the first Yankees team to not steal a base over 20 consecutive games in 61 years

4. This can’t go on. It couldn’t go on after Boone’s decision-making in the 2018 ALDS, but it did. It couldn’t go on after his decision-making in the 2020 ALDS, but it did. It couldn’t go on after the disgraceful 2021 season, but it did. It couldn’t go on after the second-half collapse, use of the 2004 ALCS at motivation and embarrassment in the ALCS in 2022, but it did. It couldn’t go on after the worst Yankees season in 30 years with the team missing the postseason in a format in which 40 percent of the league makes the postseason in 2023, but it did. It can’t continue for the rest of 2024. But it will.

5. It will because Cashman is in charge, and he’s invincible as general manager of the Yankees. He’s as close to being a member of the Steinbrenner family as one could be without having their last name. Cashman built a roster in which the Yankees are heavily relying on a 25-year-old rookie to be the third-most important bat in the lineup after Aaron Judge and Juan Soto. He’s the one who thought Anthony Rizzo coming off a lost season would stay healthy at almost 35 years of age. He’s the one who thought relying on Giancarlo Stanton to be available all season despite a lost tenure as a Yankee would suffice. He’s the one who thought DJ LeMahieu would turn back the clock five years. He’s the one who has held on to Gleyber Torres to the point where he has no value and will leave the Yankees for nothing in return in three months. He’s the one who thought Alex Verdugo’s contact ability would help a strikeout-heavy lineup, despite all of his contact being ground balls to second base. He’s the one who hung his hat on Anthony Volpe as the shortstop of the future and passed over every big-name free-agent shortstop available. He’s the one who gave Carlos Rodon $162 million to be a fifth starter at best. He’s the one who built this bullpen that has one trustworthy option in it (Luke Weaver), and it’s a stretch to call that one option trustworthy.

6. Unfortunately, Cashman isn’t going anywhere. Despite being unable to build a core of his own since being named general manager 26 years ago, there’s a better chance the Yankees remove the interlocking NY from their hat and stop wearing pinstripes than there is Cashman is removed from his position. He will remain in his position for as long as he wants, and when he no longer wants to be in the position, he will handpick the next person to do the job so Hal Steinbrenner doesn’t have to.

Cashman created this mess of a roster, though he likely doesn’t see it as that considering over the winter he said his team coming off an 82-win season is “pretty fucking good.” But he also created this culture of losing by installing a manager who is accepting and comfortable with losing. A manager who calls extending losing streaks “bumps in the road” and refers to historic collapses as “the ebbs and flows of a baseball season” and considers catastrophic, avoidable losses to be “just part of 162” all while telling everyone at the end of each disappointing season how “sweet” it will be when the Yankees finally “climb the mountain” and win a championship under his watch.

7. It would take an incredible amount of good fortune and luck for the Yankees to win a championship with Boone as their manager. I’m not talking about a few bounces going their way or an unlikely bat getting hot in October. I’m talking about the kind of good fortune and luck needed to win the lottery and then win it again two days later.

If you’re one of the few lunatics who feels Boone is undeserving of losing his job, then you must be of the idea that no manager should ever lose their job because there’s no one more deserving of losing their managerial job than Boone. Boone isn’t the problem, but he is a problem, and he’s certainly not part of the solution.

8. If you listened to Anthony Volpe speak with the media after his lack of hustle led to the Yankees not scoring a run that would have won them the game on Friday night, it was as if Boone scripted Volpe’s responses for him. Judge frequently talks about “getting them tomorrow.” Last year, Rodon said, “It’s in front of us” as the season fell part, and a week after that, Harrison Bader responded, “No concern” when asked about the Yankees being 4 1/2 games out of a playoff spot. One of the reasons Joe Girardi was let go was because Cashman feared the young core of players would take on the tense characteristics of their manager. That young core under Boone didn’t grow up by taking on the characteristics of their happy-go-lucky, Pollyanna manager, they have become him.

9. With Gray, Cashman eventually said enough is enough. With tens of millions of dollars owed to pitchers and players like A.J. Burnett, Alex Rodriguez, Jacoby Ellsbury and Aaron Hicks, he thought paying them to not play or to play against the Yankees was better than paying them to play for the Yankees. When it came to his belief that winning with an all-right-handed lineup was possible while completely disregarding lineup balance, he finally gave in and traded for and signed left-handed bats. But for some reason, when it comes to Boone, he can’t make a change. He won’t make a change.

10. There’s 70 games left in the season. Seventy games to try to save a season that is taking on water at a faster rate than the previous two. Seventy games to not waste another season of the primes of Judge and Gerrit Cole, and not waste possibly the only season of Soto as a Yankee.

Coming off a season in which the Yankees were one win away from the World Series, Cashman handed the team over to someone with no managerial or coaching experience at any level. There’s no fixing or making up the last six lost seasons, but by finally ending this experiment Cashman can do something his manager has rarely ever done: put the team in the best possible position to succeed.

Read More

BlogsYankeesYankees Thoughts

Yankees Thoughts: Luis Gil Handed Career-Worst Loss

The Yankees suffered their most lopsided loss of the season and it came in the most important game of the season to date. Here are 10 thoughts on the Yankees. 1. The Yankees couldn’t have

The Yankees suffered their most lopsided loss of the season and it came in the most important game of the season to date.

Here are 10 thoughts on the Yankees.

1. The Yankees couldn’t have been set up better for their three-game series at home against the Orioles. They had Monday completely off. Their elite relievers were well rested after having not been needed on Saturday and Sunday in two losses against the Red Sox. They had the advantage in every starting pitching matchup with Nestor Cortes and his 1.57 ERA going against journeyman Albert Suarez (who hadn’t pitched in the majors in seven years before this season), Gerrit Cole making his season debut against Cade Povich in his third career start and American League Cy Young favorite Luis Gil against Cole Irvin and his weak 6.5 strikeouts per nine innings. The Yankees wasted all of their advantages and lost two of three to their direct competition for the division.

2. The Yankees held on to win the series opener 4-2, were managed to a 7-6 extra-inning loss in the middle game and then were humiliated in a 17-5 loss in the rubber game.

“They are a good club. We saw that last year,” Aaron Judge said. “They play hard. They play fast.”

3. Gil picked a bad day to have the worst start of his career (1.1 IP, 8 H, 7 R, 7 ER, 2 BB, 1 K, 1 HR). After dominating the Orioles in Baltimore on May 1, Gil couldn’t get out of the second inning on Thursday and provided the Yankees with their first start of less than four innings of the season.

“It happens. That’s baseball,” Judge said. “You are going to have those outings like that.”

4. Gil had been so good overall before being embarrassed by the Orioles, but his disastrous start was kind of foreshadowed in his previous two starts. Two starts ago, the Dodgers tagged Gil for the most runs he allowed since April and it was the first time since April he didn’t complete six innings. Then in his last start, he gave the Yankees five innings of one-run ball, but walked four and put eight on in a grind-it-out effort.

5. The Orioles didn’t sit back and let Gil get ahead to blow them away with his riding fastball or low-‘90s changeup. They swung early in the count and attacked Gil before he could attack them. Gil faced 15 batters and 11 of them reached base.

“Today I missed pitches,” Gil said. “They took advantage of it, but it’s definitely a learning experience.”

6. The inconsistent Yankees offense can’t be trusted, but they have never had a chance on Thursday, considering they trailed 7-0 in the top of the second. Every Orioles starter had a hit in the game. The 4 through 7 hitters each had two hits and the 1 through 3 hitters each had three. The Orioles’ 17 runs were the most against the Yankees in five years.

“They came out swinging early on,” Judge said. “We really couldn’t answer back after that.”

7. Gleyber Torres hit his seventh home run of the season, a meaningless solo shot with the Yankees down seven, and Judge hit his league-leading 27th home run. (I’m glad Judge was healthy enough in the Yankees’ eyes to play on Thursday and hit a home run, but couldn’t have pinch hit 19 hours earlier in a game the Yankees could have won.)

8. The defense was sloppy with three errors, and the bullpen gave up 10 runs in 7 2/3 innings. Newest Yankee Tim Hill showed why the White Sox gave up on him as he allowed a three-run home run in his only inning of work. Caleb Ferguson and Victor Gonzalez provided their latest examples of why the Dodgers were willing to trade them, and Ron Marinaccio, who was good enough to relieve Cole in a tie game the previous day, is no longer good enough to be a Yankee and was sent down after the 12-run loss.

9. The Yankees are 6-7 in their last 13 games, dating back to the first game of the Dodgers series. They are 2-5 against the Orioles with six games left against them (and will need to win five of six to hold the head-to-head tiebreaker over them). They are 10-12 against the AL East. Their issues have been glaring over the last two weeks: lack of lineup depth, untrustworthy bullpen, a starting catcher who can’t throw, a pitching staff that can’t hold runners and a manager who continues to be a liability in close games.

10. It’s not going to get any easier. The Yankees were fortunate to get the Orioles’ worst three starters over the last three days, and now they will unfortunately get the Braves’ best three starters over the next three days: Chris Sale, Charlie Morton and Max Fried. The Braves have been playing much better of late (6-1 in their last seven games) after their slide following Ronald Acuna’s season-ending injury. They aren’t playing the way they played for all of last season, but the ability to is still in there (minus Acuna) and they are showing it. The next three days at the Stadium will be another tough three days.

Read More

BlogsYankeesYankees Thoughts

Yankees Thoughts: Aaron Boone Pushes Every Wrong Button

The Yankees lost to the Orioles 7-6 in 10 innings in a game they had many opportunities to win. Here are 10 thoughts on the Yankees. 1. Aaron Boone has managed 946 regular-season games for

The Yankees lost to the Orioles 7-6 in 10 innings in a game they had many opportunities to win.

Here are 10 thoughts on the Yankees.

1. Aaron Boone has managed 946 regular-season games for Yankees and Wednesday night against the Orioles was the worst of them all. (Emphasis on regular season since no regular-season game can top Game 3 of the 2018 ALDS or Game 4 of the 2018 ALDS or Game 2 of the 2019 ALCS or Game 2 of the 2020 ALDS or Game 1 of the 2022 ALCS.)

Every single decision Boone made on Wednesday was the wrong one. Every time a new player or pitcher was inserted into the game it put the team in a worse position to win the game, which is odd, considering Boone’s sole purpose as manager is to put his players in the best possible position to succeed.

2. Boone’s egregious decision making on Wednesday began before the game even started. It began when he held Aaron Judge out of the lineup. It was reported Judge wanted to play in the game, and he was still held out. Judge doesn’t have a broken hand. He doesn’t have ligament or muscle damage. If he did, he would be on the injured list. (Then again, it was said Anthony Rizzo would be out four to six weeks and then he was placed on the 60-day IL.) Judge was held out because the Yankees wanted to be “cautious.” Cautious of what? It’s not as if Judge’s hand is on the brink of breaking and playing baseball on Wednesday would have pushed his hand over the edge to breaking. His hand hurts. It’s going to hurt for some time. If he can play with it hurting (which he apparently can since he wanted to play) then he should be playing. He didn’t. (I’m sure he will be playing on Thursday afternoon with his hand magically healed 17 hours after Wednesday’s loss ended.)

3. Gerrit Cole made his season debut. In his last rehab start he threw 70 pitches, so going off of standard pitch count build-up history, he would be in line to throw about 85 pitches on Wednesday. Boone wanted to pull Cole after four innings and 61 pitches despite that being less pitches than he had thrown in his last start, and despite the Orioles’ 7-8-9 hitters due up, but YES showed Cole tell Boone in the dugout he wanted “one more.”

He got one more batter. Cole allowed a first-pitch single to start the fifth and Boone pulled him. Cole had only thrown 62 pitches or eight fewer than his most recent start. I don’t know how that’s building up his pitch count.

“We weren’t going to go over 65 tonight with the jump up,” Boone said.

The “jump up” from 70 to 65? Umm, 65 is less than 70.

“I thought he got a little tired there in the fourth,” Boone said of Cole.

Cole had a 1-2-3 fourth and struck out the last two batters of that inning. He had struck out five of the last seven batters he faced through the fourth. He wasn’t tired.

“I thought I held up well, Cole said. “I felt I could definitely keep making pitches.”

If Cole can’t be trusted to pitch to Ramon Urias and Jorge Mateo after 62 pitches then what was he doing starting a game of this magnitude? The Orioles are the Yankees’ only competition for the division. Each of their 13 head-to-head games is immensely important and Boone managed it as if it was a throwaway game in the final week of September with the division clinched.

4. If the plan was for Cole to get through four or five innings and then piece together the final 12 to 15 outs with the best relievers on the team, that would have been one thing. But when Boone took the ball from Cole with the game tied at 1 in the fifth, the first reliever he went to was Ron Marinaccio, the same reliever who wasn’t good enough to be on the team over Dennis Santana this season, and wasn’t on the team until the Yankees finally gave up on Santana and his 6.26 ERA. Because of the three-batter rule, unless everything went right and Marinaccio got a double play in the inning, he was going to have to face Gunnar Henderson. Boone was willing to let a reliever the organization liked less than Santana all season face the Henderson. Everything didn’t go right. Marinaccio needed 27 pitches to get the three outs in the fifth, allowed his inherited runner to score and gave up two runs of his own on a home run, double, single and walk.

5. In the sixth, the Yankees trailed 4-1. With two outs and no one on, the Orioles went to the bullpen for lefty Cionel Perez. DJ LeMahieu singled, Ben Rice and Jose Trevino walked and the Yankees had the bases loaded with two outs and Trent Grisham up. Grisham hits lefties better than righties. He’s not exactly Aaron Judge against lefties, but there’s great disparity in his numbers between the two. He’s a reverse-splits guy. We know this because Boone cited Grisham’s reverse splits as a reason for allowing Grisham to hit (and fail) against a lefty reliever earlier in the season. Apparently, the splits were no longer good enough for Boone to use in his decision making, like a Blackjack player hitting on 12 with the dealer showing a 6 sometimes, but not all the time. Boone called Grisham back and went with Jahmai Jones.

Tuesday will be the halfway point of the season. Jones entered Wednesday (Game 76 of the season) with 16 plate appearances. Sixteen times he has faced live, in-game pitching in nearly three months. Why wouldn’t he be the guy you would want up with the bases loaded and two outs in a crucial game? After Perez walked the previous two batters and had yet to record an out, showing little command of any pitch, Jones chose to swing at the first pitch he saw and flew out to end the inning.

Tommy Kahnle came in in the seventh and gave the Orioles their fifth run since giving up runs is what Kahnle does best now. In his last five appearances, he has only recorded eight outs, allowed eight baserunners, three earned runs and all three of his inherited runners to score.

The Yankees trailed 5-1 in the bottom of the seventh, before rallying to pull within one after a three-run home run from Giancarlo Stanton.

In the bottom of the eighth, the Yankees still trailed 5-4. Rice led off with a single. Trevino was due up against the righty Bryan Baker. The spot called for Austin Wells, but Boone let Trevino hit for himself. Trevino hit the first pitch he saw into a double play. Pinch-hitter extraordinaire Jones ended the inning with a ground out to the catcher.

6. Down 5-4 headed to the ninth with shaky Orioles closer Craig Kimbrel looming and the top of the Yankees’ order due up, the Yankees had a real chance to tie or win the game in the bottom of the ninth if they could hold the deficit at one. Boone decided the best choice to hold that deficit would be recently called-up Anthony Misiewicz, the 29-year-old with a career 4.71 ERA in 114 2/3 innings. Misiewicz is so low on the organization relief depth chart that Jonathan Loaisiga had to go down for the year, Santana had to get released, Marinaccio called up and Nick Burdi and Ian Hamilton go on the IL for him to be given a chance. Misiewicz would be facing the 9-hitter and then the top of the Orioles lineup. Boone wasn’t just playing with fire, he was dousing himself in gasoline and holding lighter fluid-soaked rags while playing with it by going to Misiewicz.

Misiewicz loaded the bases, because of course he did. He miraculously got out of the inning unscathed when Alex Verdugo made a spectacular running catch on a ball Anthony Santander hit 395 feet with a 106.1 mph exit velocity. In using Misiewicz to hold the deficit and having him succeed, Boone had done the equivalent of drinking 17 beers and then driving home, but because he made it safely, he thinks he made the right choice.

7. In the bottom of the ninth, The Yankees came back to tie the game against Kimbrel, because as mentioned, Kimbrel sucks. Anthony Volpe led off the ninth with a double and Stanton singled him home. With Stanton on first, Boone replaced him with Wells as the pinch runner. So Wells could be used as a pinch runner, just not as a pinch hitter for Trevino in the eighth with the leadoff man on and a righty on the mound? Managerial masterclass.

8. In the 10th, Boone went to Clay Holmes with the automatic runner on second. Holmes has been very bad since May 20 (21 baserunners in 11 innings and only seven strikeouts), but Boone went to his closer with the score tied in extras at home. It’s now 23 baserunners in 12 innings with only seven strikeouts as Holmes allowed a single, a double and a pair of runs to score with some help from his awesome catcher Trevino. After the Red Sox stole nine bases off him on Sunday, the Orioles stole three bases off him in the first nine innings on Wednesday, and on their fourth attempt in the 10th, Trevino threw the ball into left field to allow a run to score.

Unless something gets dramatically fixed instantly, Trevino can’t catch another game. The Red Sox let the entire league see what the worst-ranked catching arm in the sport is incapable of when they went 9-for-10 in steals on Sunday and the Orioles followed that up by going 4-for-4 on Wednesday. It’s embarrassing, pathetic and not fitting of a major-league catcher. And it’s not going to end.

9. With the Yankees now down two runs in the bottom of the 10th, LeMahieu led off with a single to move automatic runner Gleyber Torres over to third. Runners on the corners with no outs. Rice hit a ball that needed a Santander diving catch to prevent from falling in, but Torres scored on the sacrifice fly to make it 7-6. The tying run was still on base in the form of Oswaldo Cabrera (who pinch ran for LeMahieu), but at the plate would be Trevino followed by Jones.

With Trevino at the plate, Boone chose to send Cabrera and his 13 career steals in three years. Cabrera was easily gunned down as the ball was waiting for him at second.

Trevino ended up walking, bringing up Jones as the game-winning run. Facing Dillon Tate, who only averages 5.8 strikeouts per nine innings, Tate had yet to strike out a batter in the inning and Jones would at least be able to put the ball in play against the righty. Or not. Jones struck out on three pitches. Game over.

“We could have grabbed that game,” Boone said.

Yeah, you could have if anyone else had been managing.

10. With the loss, the Yankees are now 1-5 in extra-inning games this season, the worst mark in the league. And with the loss, their division lead is back to just a 1 1/2 games as they are once again tied with the Orioles in the loss column.

Wednesday was a winnable game the Yankees lost thanks to their manager. There have been too many of those since the start of his tenure, but none in the regular season worse than this one.

Read More

BlogsYankeesYankees Thoughts

Yankees Thoughts: Avenge Aaron Judge’s Hit By Pitch

The Yankees beat the Orioles 4-2 on Tuesday and avoided a potential disaster after Aaron Judge was hit by a pitch. Here are 10 thoughts on the Yankees. 1. Nearly two weeks ago, while the

The Yankees beat the Orioles 4-2 on Tuesday and avoided a potential disaster after Aaron Judge was hit by a pitch.

Here are 10 thoughts on the Yankees.

1. Nearly two weeks ago, while the Yankees were sweeping the season series from the Twins, all of the attention for Yankees fans turned to wondering why Juan Soto was removed from a game following a rain delay. It was later announced Soto had left with left forearm discomfort and would be sent for imaging and tests the following day. The next 18 hours were spent hoping and praying the tests would come back favorably for Soto and the Yankees. Without Soto, the 2024 Yankees would become the 2023 Yankees offensively. Thankfully, everything worked out and Soto only ended up missing three games with inflammation.

Similarly, the status of Aaron Judge’s left hand became the focal point of Tuesday’s immensely important game against the Orioles once the center fielder was removed from the game after being hit by a pitch. If Judge’s testing came back unfavorably, the offense would become a shell of itself, as it would without Soto. With the seven non-Soto and non-Judge hitters being inconsistent and unreliable, the Yankees can’t afford to lose either for an extended period of time. Thankfully, like Soto, Judge is fine.

2. “It’s a big relief,” Judge said. “Just being hit there before a couple of years ago and breaking my wrist, you never know what’s going to happen.”

Losing Judge for weeks or months would have put a damper on the Yankees’ 4-2 win, but everything worked out on the field and in the X-ray room.

“We just wanted to make sure to get it looked at,” Aaron Boone said of pulling Judge, “and see what we were dealing with.”

It doesn’t matter that Albert Suarez wasn’t trying to hit Judge, he still hit him. If you can’t pitch inside without hitting batters, don’t pitch inside.

3. “We all know that they didn’t try to hit Judge right there, but it’s a little frustrating,” Soto said. “It’s a little uncomfortable.”

It’s more than a little frustrating. It’s a lot frustrating. If Judge is forced to miss Wednesday’s game or Thursday’s game against the Orioles, the hit by pitch has enormous implications on the AL East and could be the difference between having to play in the best-of-3 wild-card round or having a bye to the best-of-5 ALDS.

4. “At the end of the day, we don’t take what happened lightly,” Alex Verdugo said. “But at the same time, I don’t believe it was intentional.”

Well, the Yankees do take it somewhat lightly since no Oriole was hit. Nestor Cortes threw inside to Gunnar Henderson, but didn’t hit him. If that was all the Yankees plan on doing in retaliation, that’s not enough. Whether or not Judge was hit on purpose, Henderson needs to be hit. That’s the way it goes. Henderson or Adley Rutschman. Take your pick. One of them needs to eat a fastball.

5. “I wouldn’t say I would expect anything to roll over,” Verdugo said. “But I do expect that there’s gonna be a little bit more edge.”

If any of these next two games gets out of hand, I do expect it to roll over. Unfortunately, four runs wasn’t enough of a lead on Tuesday to avenge Judge since the Yankees ended up needing every run they could get with Clay Holmes on the mound.

6. Holmes entered with the Yankees leading 4-0 in the ninth, allowed a leadoff single to Henderson and then promptly gave up a two-run home run to Anthony Santander. Holmes eventually got out of the inning, but not before making Yankees fans squirm again.

Since the disaster on May 20 against the Mariners (when Holmes entered with a 0.00 ERA on the season), he has allowed eight earned runs and 22 baserunners in 11 innings with only seven strikeouts. I can’t continue to stress enough how important it is the Yankees have a closer who doesn’t rely on balls in play to get outs.

Another reason for Holmes’ issues on Tuesday was another extended layoff. Holmes went four days between appearances last week against the Royals and lost the game in the ninth. Prior to Tuesday, he hadn’t pitched since that Royals game five days earlier and allowed two runs. Holmes needs to pitch somewhat consistently, save situation or not.

7. The Yankees’ offense had six hits in the game (just one extra-base hit), but did manage six walks (three from Soto). The Orioles’ offense only had one of their eight hits go for extra bases as well and had just one walk, against Michael Tonkin.

Tonkin’s role with the Yankees continues to grow in importance, and it seems that he has passed over both Tommy Kahnle and Ian Hamilton for Boone’s bullpen pecking order. Tonkin was given the seventh inning on Tuesday in a four-run game against the Yankees’ sole competition for the division title. There isn’t a person in the world who envisioned this for Tonkin when the Yankees picked him up off the scrap heap and inserted him into that April 26 game against the Brewers. From April 26 through the end of May, these are the games Tonkin pitched in as a Yankee:

April 26: Lost game in 11th with him on the mound
April 28: 10-run win
May 2: Five-run loss
May 7: Seven-run win
May 11: Five-run loss
May 19: Five-run win
May 22: Four-run win (would have been a six-run win, but he allowed two runs)
May 26: Three-run loss
May 30: Five-run win

Tonkin wasn’t allowed near a close game in his first month with the Yankees, and the only close game he appeared in was one he made close himself. But then everything changed for him on June 2 in San Francisco (the crazy ninth-inning comeback game) when he pitched two scoreless innings in that 7-5 win. Since that day, Tonkin’s stock has risen within the Yankees and based on Tuesday night, he’s going to be the guy bridging the gap from starter to Luke Weaver in close games, and he deserves it with his 0.00 ERA in 13 innings since May 22.

7. Ben Rice made his major-league debut and went 1-for-4 with a line-drive single. A nice debut for Rice, who was removed for defensive purposes in the eighth.

Rice is viewed as a kid getting his first call-up to the majors, and he is, but what’s crazy is Soto isn’t even four months older than him. I think people tend to forget how young Soto is because this is his sixth season in the majors. He’s 25! Give him $1 billion!

8. DJ LeMahieu will always be the man for his 2019 and 2020 seasons when he tried to single-handedly carry the Yankees at times when the rest of the names in the lineup were hurt or underperforming. I was all for re-signing LeMahieu because of this and because the Yankees’ lineup lacked depth prior to the 2021 season. (Aaron Hicks was the Opening Day 3-hitter.) But after season-ending injuries in 2021 and 2022 that cost him postseason play both years and then his ongoing injuries in 2023 and this year, it’s difficult to believe LeMahieu will ever be even a shell of his former self. He used to be the guy I wanted up most in big spots, and now he’s the guy I want up least. Every ball is hit on the ground, and he has yet to pick up an extra-base hit in 56 plate appearances.

He has only played in 16 games and deserves a longer leash than that, considering Gleyber Torres and Anthony Rizzo have endless leashes, but the early results are not good. I’m holding out hope that this is him shaking off the rust, but I fear it’s not.

9. Nestor Cortes was awesome (6 IP, 5 H, 0 R, 0 ER, 6 K), but it was to be expected with him pitching at home. Cortes now has a 1.57 ERA and 0.818 WHIP in eight home starts and a 5.57 ERA and 1.452 WHIP in eight road starts.

Because of this, if the postseason started today and Gerrit Cole is his normal, healthy self the rest of the season, I would go Cole in Game 1, Cortes in Game 2 and Luis Gil in Game 3, and then pray for rain between Games 3 and 4 to get Cole back on the mound on normal rest in Game 4 to keep Carlos Rodon and Marcus Stroman away.

10. Cole will make his 2024 debut on Wednesday night against the Orioles. He’s not completely stretched out, so he’s likely to only give the Yankees four or five innings, unless he’s extremely economical (which he tends to not always be). His return comes at the perfect time with the Orioles on the schedule and Cody Poteet headed to the injured list.

After Tuesday’s win, the Yankees’ division lead is back up to 2 1/2 games. If the Yankees can win behind Cole’s debut on Wednesday then Luis Gil goes in the series finale on Thursday. This series with its pitching matchups heavily favoring the Yankees is set up for the Yankees to create some real separation in the standings. I don’t want to get ahead of myself, but it’s hard not to, especially if Judge is in the lineup.

Read More